3 ms·
A real 5 whys analysis probably should give a tree. Why did X happen? Because A, B, and C. Why did A happen? Because A1 and A2. And so on.
by AnimalMuppet 4y ago
A real 5 whys analysis probably should give a tree. Why did X happen? Because A, B, and C. Why did A happen? Because A1 and A2. And so on.
- drivers99 4y agoFishbone diagram is one way to do that https://asq.org/quality-resources/fishbone https://asq.org/quality-resources/fishbone
- bluGill 4y agoYou don't need to do that because there will be more 5-whys. Just pick whichever of A1, A2 seems like a bigger deal and find a B that seems like the biggest contribution - until you get to some deep root cause you can solve and mitigate. Then you fix that one issue and move one. You WILL see more issues, if they are always in other places you must have got the right one, if not then you will see this again and this time you can go down A2. The important part of the above is by refusing create the whole tree you actually get something solved. Sometimes you will get the right one, sometimes you won't. You can spend a lot of time building a tree of problems, and find tens of thousands of things you can fix - and now you have a larger todo list than you have time to do and likely you don't get anything done. Or analysis paralysis in other words.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoThis is specifically where bias comes in. People selectively prune the tree in ways that are either interesting (in a positive take) or deceptively based on their desire to avoid certain topics. Because the tree can be so large it isn’t always obvious even to the author whether they picked a branch because it was useful or because it served some other purpose - divert focus to a team they want to see behave differently, avoid taking blame for something, avoid being asked to fix something they don’t want to, etc. So, in this case the real question is “will they pick the branch that blames the people that pay and promote them, or take the branches that are of the least resistance.” Something this contentious would be vetted by committee in some way or another and at that point any upward finger pointing would be almost certainly curtailed in favor of a less contentious branch.
- bluGill 4y agoOnce again, there is only so many times you can keep re-running the same tree before someone will look for a different root cause. If you only run the process once you can place blame wherever. However when it is multiple different people for slightly different problems running it over several years, eventually you will get to the right branch.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoOnly if it’s independent in each run. Even with different people on different problems they’re still subject to the same pressures by the people that pay and promote them.