2 ms·
> This seems like a non-issue as both Apple and Cupertino are just following the law as written. If they were following the law as written, they probably would
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> This seems like a non-issue as both Apple and Cupertino are just following the law as written.
If they were following the law as written, they probably wouldn’t have been found out of compliance by a state audit based on compliance with the law as written.
I mean, its not impossible, state auditors aren’t infallible, but...
- crazygringo 4y agoState officials disagree with each other all the time, they get corrected by courts all the time, etc. A state audit is always going to be heavily biased toward state interests as opposed to corporate or local interests. Laws aren't black and white and auditors make arbitary distinctions over gray areas all the time. Being found out of compliance by a state auditor isn't even remotely a sign that Apple and Cupertino weren't following the law -- especially when it's not like Apple cheaps out on its lawyers. It's simply that the auditor is challenging their interpretation of the law. Ultimately, a court would decide. And states lose in court all the time.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> A state audit is always going to be heavily biased toward state interests The state gets the same share no matter where in the state the transaction is assigned. > Laws aren't black and white Some are quite black and white, some are less so.
- crazygringo 4y agoThe state is mainly composed of all the other municipalities that aren't Cupertino, and they're the ones losing out financially.
- eep_social 4y ago> The department has been auditing whether companies participate enough in online sales to assign them to cities with warehouses or offices. This isn’t cut and dry the way you make it seem. This agreement is a common tactic and William’s Sonoma is apparently having the same issue with the state and is appealing. [1] https://news.bloomberglaw.com/daily-tax-report-state/apples-local-tax-arrangement-with-hometown-comes-under-fire https://news.bloomberglaw.com/daily-tax-report-state/apples-...