3 ms·
Although things are not that easy and ordered.... You can look at simulated orbitals here: https://falstad.com/qmatom/ https://falstad.com/qmatom/ s-orbitals
by scotty79 4y ago
Although things are not that easy and ordered....
You can look at simulated orbitals here: https://falstad.com/qmatom/ https://falstad.com/qmatom/
s-orbitals are spherically symmetrical. You might convince yourself that p-orbitals are also fine, because 3 of them in 3 dimensions do have reasonable rotational symmetry.
You'll notice that when you move to d-orbitals things start to get really weird. 4 of them are fairly equivalent but it turns out that you can cram 10 electrons of this energy around the nucleus in this fashion. So there are 5 d orbitals. And we can't really fit the fifth in similar manner as other 4.
https://profound-advice.com/what-is-the-difference-between-the-dxy-and-dx2-y2-orbitals/ https://profound-advice.com/what-is-the-difference-between-t... Check the video.
So while we technically have 5 d orbitals, one of them is weird. Its weirdness is an artifact of math. To get the orbitals we are solving Schrodinger equation in spherical coordinates, where one axis is chosen as special. This gives us this weird solution. https://chemistry.stackexchange.com/questions/117243/why-is-there-a-z%c2%b2-label-for-d-orbitals-but-no-x%c2%b2-and-y%c2%b2-labels-with-correspondi https://chemistry.stackexchange.com/questions/117243/why-is-...
Physical reality can't depend on our choice of coordinate system so this tells us that orbitals as we draw them don't really directly express the physical reality. In actual physical reality all five of d orbitals have the same shape (somewhere in between the nice d and weird d), but since we can't tell the difference between electron on one d orbital from the electron on another then as long as all 5 orbitals sum up to physical reality our math still works, even if we choose to decompose the solution into 5 non-rotationally-symmetrical parts to make math easier on ourselves.