15 ms·
And also destroys your ability to pose realistic hypotheticals. Just like mathematics solved Zeno’s paradox, CS has solved the trolley problem. But it makes you
by vlovich123 4y ago
And also destroys your ability to pose realistic hypotheticals. Just like mathematics solved Zeno’s paradox, CS has solved the trolley problem. But it makes you seem smart to continue to pose unrealistic hypotheticals because you can avoid listening to people challenging your premise.
Now people will say that the answer to the trolley problem - AI avoids the trolley problem in the first place + you can minimize the total kinetic energy in the system when you simulate forcing into it - is a cheat because humans can’t do it and it doesn’t address the underlying moral question.
Who cares? We know that the trolley problem doesn’t actually appear in reality in the clean way it’s presented anyway. So if the philosopher is cheating with an unrealistic scenario that would never happen, it’s fair for the student to find a solution by cheating in response (ie Kobayashi Maru).
- PaulHoule 4y agoThere are those cases also where you want to let the trolley go one way then push it back the top of the hill, throw the switch, and let it get the other way.