2 ms·
The arguments are extremely flawed on several fronts. 1. We don’t know how to do good risk modeling with huge unknowns. How do you know the universe you create
by vlovich123 4y ago
The arguments are extremely flawed on several fronts.
1. We don’t know how to do good risk modeling with huge unknowns. How do you know the universe you create will meet the criteria that would put into the benefit part of the cost/benefit curve? So we don’t know X. We don’t know what the magnitude of the benefit is. Is it really 1e9? And we don’t know the probability of failure. Is it really 1e-6? So sure, for some random set of hypothetical numbers, the cost benefit trade off is there. But we don’t know what the real numbers are and we don’t know what the uncertainty space is.
2. This argument implicitly puts cost/benefit into a single linear variable. But we know that’s not the case. What if the harm is an exponential and the probability of it / magnitude has different scaling factors than your benefit function?
3. If all you need is a planet and you have this tech, what is the likelihood that you can’t use a planet other than Earth or you can’t migrate humans away first?
This is like those mathematical logic puzzles that get you to conclude that 1=2 because an interim step was a division by 0.