3 ms·
> about American individualism[0] and not wanting to share anything if you don't absolutely have to. I don’t know if this is an American quality specifically.
by lotsofpulp 4y ago
> about American individualism[0] and not wanting to share anything if you don't absolutely have to.
I don’t know if this is an American quality specifically. It could just be that Americans can (or used to be able to) afford it, whereas most other people in most other societies never could.
For example, what young married couple would want to live in their parents house if they can afford their own? All of my extended family grew up in intergenerational households because they were poor immigrants who had to make do, but all the cousins became doctors/lawyers/engineers/etc and got their own house.
That is not to say that my cousins would not let their elderly parents stay with them if the need arises, but being financially independent does allow people to do what they want.
- lambdasquirrel 4y agoWell it's great that America tested that out so the rest of the world can see how miserable it is. Europe paid attention. Verdict is still out on China and India.
- vladvasiliu 4y agoHow so? I live in France and "single-family" dwellings are the norm. I don't know anyone living with their extended family.
- rayiner 4y ago> For example, what young married couple would want to live in their parents house if they can afford their own? Anyone who has kids and sometimes wants a break. > All of my extended family grew up in intergenerational households because they were poor immigrants who had to make do, but all the cousins became doctors/lawyers/engineers/etc and got their own house. How much of that is just unconsciously going along with American culture? America is structurally set up to fragment your social relationships, especially among higher achieving, professional people. You go to school and seek jobs across the country, etc. I’m also an immigrant and I followed the same trajectory. Came to America, was already disconnected from family. Went to school hundreds of miles away, etc. Kind of by accident, I ended up living 10 minutes from my parents, in a neighborhood where most people don’t have a college degree. We’re over at my parents several times a week. And multiple families in my neighborhood have parents in the neighborhood or rent a house from their parents who live nearby.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> Anyone who has kids and sometimes wants a break. But that does not require living in the same house. Having grandparents a few doors down (my preference) or a few minutes away is good enough for this purpose. Living under the same roof involves a ton more tradeoffs.
- emodendroket 4y ago> Anyone who has kids and sometimes wants a break. I am quite confident that occasionally having someone watch my kid would not offset the extent to which my parents (or my in-laws) and I would begin to grate on each other.
- scarface74 4y ago> Anyone who has kids and sometimes wants a break And then there is the lack of privacy. Your parents who came from a different generation trying to tell you how to live your life (ie my parents are very religiously conservative). I would have to deal with my mom and my wife walking on eggshells to not offend each other. I would have to deal with my dad wondering why I would waste money paying people to cut my lawn, etc.
- reducesuffering 4y ago> I would have to deal with my dad wondering why I would waste money paying people to cut my lawn That can't be the problem that comes to mind when dealing with a parent. I love my parents, but if that's the extent of your annoyance, you got off real real easy.
- scarface74 4y agoThat’s an example of someone who doesn’t believe in “wasting money on things you can do yourself” and constantly judging our decisions? Did I mention the whole religious conservative thing and how they would probably grit their teeth when my wife and I would just casually talk about going out to dinner with “her friend and his husband”?
- renewiltord 4y agoThis is quite interesting, actually. Perhaps it is cultural. My cousins had kids and the grandparents spent all the time with them. My other friends also did the same, once immigration concerns were handled. The positives I can see from the outside are: 1. Childcare is a lot easier with multiple people 2. Experience makes child care much easier 3. Principal-agent problem for child care is absent with grandparents. Grandparents obey parents' choices in broad strokes while providing a high degree of attention. 4. Fulfilling for grandparents Overall, I'm in my mid 30s and watching the experience of my cousins, part of my desire to get going on the kids thing is that I want my parents to be able to help before they are too old.