2 ms·
> There are potential privacy issues that could be troubling if not managed well Under Supreme Court precedent, United States v. Antoine Jones (2012) [0], atta
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> There are potential privacy issues that could be troubling if not managed well
Under Supreme Court precedent, United States v. Antoine Jones (2012) [0], attaching a GPS tracker to a vehicle is a search, and requires a warrant. A fancy delivery system doesn’t seem to change the Constitutional parameters.
[0] https://www.gps.gov/news/2012/01/supremecourt/#:~:text=10%2D1259)%2C%20a%20case,order%20to%20monitor%20its%20movements https://www.gps.gov/news/2012/01/supremecourt/#:~:text=10%2D....
- anfilt 4y agoPolice generally need a warrant to enter someones house too for the same reasons. However, if they chasing someone or there imminent danger they can enter someones house not search it, but it is only to deal with chasing the person or preventing the imminent threat. The only reason I see police deploying this would be to avoid a high speed chase. Where that ends up constitutionally I don't know not a judge or lawyer, but it is one of those imminent danger/pursuit situations the courts have carved for other circumstances. Now I will say if the police follow someone they are chasing into an other persons house and in that house see drugs. Under most circumstances that could not be used as evidence against the person that lived in the house since they did not have a warrant to search for drugs in the house. Their only legal reason to be there was to catch someone, so anything unrelated to that narrow purpose generally can't be used in court.
- runnerup 4y agoIt could change them due to “hot pursuit”. You generally don’t need a warrant when you’re in hot pursuit.
- dragonwriter 4y agoYou don’t need a warrant to enter a home or similar property to effect an arrest when you are in hot pursuit of a subject who you have probable cause (in a situation not requiring a warrant) to arrest because, in that context, the entry is not a search. I don’t see how that helps here, because the whole point of putting a GPS tracker on a car is to allow abandoning hot pursuit in favor of (what has been determined to be) a search.