4 ms·
This is a great article, not only in explaining a lot of aspects of color spaces, but also highlighting just how maddening it is to use tools that deal with col
by crazygringo 4y ago
This is a great article, not only in explaining a lot of aspects of color spaces, but also highlighting just how maddening it is to use tools that deal with color spaces, because every tool has all sorts of silent defaults and assumptions that are always different/incompatible with another tool. It's maddening.
And it's only getting worse now with HDR (high dynamic range) content, as opposed to regular SDR (standard dynamic range). Fun fact: on a Mac at least, if you have the same content (hit TV show or movie) in SDR (usually 8-bit 1080p) and HDR (usually 10-bit 4K), there is no video player that will play the HDR version in a way that matches the SDR version. They range from unwatchable (VLC plays HDR content impossibly dark) to watchable-but-still-darker (Infuse) to weird (IINA is normal brightness but the colors have weird tint/saturation).
How HDR is defined in theory sounds reasonable but is disastrous in practice. While SDR just maps brightness to whatever your display is (from 0 to 255), HDR maps actual real-life brightness from pitch black to the brightest sun (from 0 to 1024). So the idea is that if you shoot outdoors on the brightest day, a hypothetical screen someday should be able to display it equally bright.
Now this is disastrous in practice from a creative standpoint because if you're watching a movie, cutting from a dark indoor nighttime bedroom scene to a sunny outdoor party scene is going to hurt your eyes. It's too jarring. Movies and TV generally don't want a real-life range of brightness. Not to mention, of course, that we don't have display technologies that can achieve it anyways, or even anything close to it.
So what are TV shows and movies doing? As far as I can tell, they're essentially filming and color-correcting in SDR as they've always done, and then using some totally arbitrary formula to convert that to HDR for HDR mastering. Bright sunlight scenes are never encoded as actual sunlight brightness (thank god), the relative difference between a nighttime bedroom scene and a bright outdoor scene in HDR is the same as it is in SDR (again, thank god). The only HDR "special features" seem to be that things like VFX lightsabers, explosions, sparks, and so forth get extra-boosted brightness in HDR.
Now back to the video players on Macs: because there is no official recommendation of how to translate HDR to real screens that have traditionally only shown SDR content (e.g. a Macbook display), they all do it differently. Which sucks. Not only are they all playing HDR content badly, there isn't even a right way to do it. We're lost in the desert.
What's the solution? Somebody needs to contact Hollywood to figure out what the de-facto translation is that they're using when they release SDR and HDR versions of the same content, and then just run the formula backwards so playing my TV show that's HDR-mastered looks identical to the SDR source they also put out. (At least for regular scenes, both nighttime bedroom and outdoor party. The VFX things like lightsabers and explosions might get washed out to bright white but that's far preferable to the other 99% of the content being too dark.)