3 ms·
> This sort of thing happens all the time in private transactions. But it has never happened in a case with one of the most important websites in the world! We
by yieldcrv 4y ago
> This sort of thing happens all the time in private transactions. But it has never happened in a case with one of the most important websites in the world! We should know more!
Based on what? You're not going to if a private company doesn't want you to and is structured correctly.
> The only reason to act against such strong incentives is if you have something to hide.
Yes, like the natural persons involved, because that's the default state of private companies structured correctly. Just like they said in the interview quoted.
> The victims harmed by Pornhub deserve assurances that the current owners will be better than the past abusers.
lol. punt your thinly veiled voyeurism to a third party. that's... rich.
- pavlov 4y ago> "Yes, like the natural persons involved, because that's the default state of private companies structured correctly." Arguably it shouldn't be the default state, or even possible.
- yieldcrv 4y ago> Arguably And what is that argument? Why are they not afforded privacy that you are afforded? Or does your argument apply to you too, in which case I'm even more interested in seeing this anti privacy argument.
- jwestbury 4y agoPhilosophically: The more impact you have on society, the less privacy you deserve. You're free to disagree with this, but not to claim it's an invalid view simply because it does not align with current law.
- golergka 4y agoImpact they have on society is based on completely voluntary interactions by millions of users. Some choose to upload videos, some choose to watch them, and all of them are completely okay with Pornhub being private. You suggest that an unrelated third party (government) comes into these interactions, invents a "society", which isn't really a subject but an abstract category, insists that it acts on behalf of it, and unlike all previous actors, wants to force submission not with voluntary transactions, but with the use of force. I can't see how a reasonable human being would possibly advocate for something so amoral.
- AlecSchueler 4y ago> Impact they have on society is based on completely voluntary interactions by millions of users. S So what does that change? They either have big impact or they don't. > I can't see how a reasonable human being would possibly advocate for something so amoral. Maybe you should look at some parliamentary discussions from the countries that already legislate for business transparency in these cases and see why they came to the positions they came to?
- golergka 4y ago> So what does that change? They either have big impact or they don't. Society isn't a subject. It shouldn't be treated like such, and no arbitrary organisation should assume the role of it's representative.
- AlecSchueler 4y agoWhere did the role of representative come into it? It's more a question of them being accountable for their responsibility, even if (especially if?) that responsibility is bestowed unto them by the public/the market.
- golergka 4y agoYou don't become responsible for something just because you have influence for it. You can only assume responsibility voluntarily by entering a relationship with somebody, a concrete subject, which society isn't.
- AlecSchueler 4y agoI disagree completely but I can understand there are cultural differences place to place in terms of individual responsibility within the collective.
- golergka 4y ago
- pavlov 4y agoIt applies to me too. I have absolutely no problem with public records that show if I have substantial ownership or a board seat in a private corporation. In fact my home country Finland has such a public company registry.
- AlecSchueler 4y ago> The victims harmed by Pornhub deserve assurances that the current owners will be better than the past abusers. Why is that not a reasonable position? Pornhub moved to it's current position of requiring verification etc after years of allowing non-consensual intimate media to thrive on its platform and only after multiple legal cases brought against them by victims. Of course a change in ownership raises questions about the future for victims and for their allies. For a site that's still dubious of Microsoft after their business dealings 30 years ago it's amazing to see so many people jump to "it's their private business, not for us to speculate on" just because the company in question is a porno provider.
- yieldcrv 4y ago> it's amazing to see so many people jump to "it's their private business, not for us to speculate on" just because the company in question is a porno provider. Can you elaborate on this criticism? Its a private business, not for us to speculate on just because the company in question is a private business. Where did you get that its just because its a porno provider? Did you misword your own argument or are you incapable of seeing that you're the only one making an exception? There are words for this kind of projection, but I'm trying to give you the benefit of the doubt.
- AlecSchueler 4y ago> Its a private business, not for us to speculate on just because the company in question is a private business We literally speculate on this kind of thing daily on HN but I only see this defense of the company when it pertains to Pornhub. I can look up some other threads about acquisitions, like Libery Media buying Formula 1, and we can quantify how many of these comments are present in those threads. Or one of the many acquisitions Google have made that have been discussed here ad nauseum. I've seen this kind of legalistic defense of pornography on HN every time it comes up on discussion. Worries about AI replacing developers are given time and nuanced discussion but any concern about women being abused with deep fakes are dismissed on these kind of technical terms. It's not surprising as the demographic of HN has a pretty big overlap with porn users (male, single, chronically online, etc.) so the people here are some of the biggest beneficiaries of the porn industry while the people who suffer are almost entirely unrepresented. No one's saying it explicitly today and I am indeed drawing conclusions based on my experience but that's a normal human thing to do.