3 ms·
Maintaining backwards compatibility with FCP makes sense, but the hubris of the iTMS team was also quite funny to me as well. They could have handled this on th
by dylan604 4y ago
Maintaining backwards compatibility with FCP makes sense, but the hubris of the iTMS team was also quite funny to me as well. They could have handled this on their end knowing that the Apple ecosystem was fractured regarding QT. They could have built Transporter to be much more tolerant of files created by FCP/Compressor to not be rejected because of these differences in Atoms within the container. Instead, many 3rd party apps had to be built/used by people instead of just handling it internally.
I also relate back to their air of superiority from another situation I had with them. Their original specs called for video content originating on film to use IVTC to return the frame rate back to original progressive frames for the obvious reasons. However, they clearly were not familiar with TV/Episodic content that was originally shot on film, but edited at 29.97 with broken cadences, use of 30p graphics, and other content that was true 29.97i. There was a specific F/X series that 2 different providers had their files rejected from the show because of faulty IVTC processing. My company got involved, but iTMS said to send them the unprocessed 29.97 content because they "knew" how to handle it. They didn't, and then it landed in my lap. I processed the files and submitted them where they were approved. There was a request from iTMS to find out how they were made. Very smuggly and with a righteous smile on my face, I got to quote an answer they had provided me previously back to them, "this is a proprietary process developed by our in-house engineers." We got a lot of work because of that.
It was examples like this that make me roll my eyes when FAANG types are held in such high regard. They're just humans trying to figure stuff out with people available to them. They might not actually know everything just as us mere mortals, but some of us have unique experiences that allows us to tell the emperor he's not wearing any clothes when the FAANG types issue decrees from up on high that are clearly just not right.
- giantrobot 4y agoEven internally I got the same sense of the iTMS team. To this day I don't know where they got that attitude from. If I were to guess it would be they had a ridiculous revenue-to-engineer ratio and got a lot of attention/praise at the executive level. Every time (for some approximation of every) their pipeline ran they generated millions of dollars in revenue. Meanwhile the QuickTime Player/plugin/QuickLook was invoked likely billions of times a year and generated revenue on a tiny fraction of those invocations. I can't say for sure but it was very annoying at times interacting with them internally. Dealing with that externally I could imagine being a complete pain in the ass.