3 ms·
Given the popularity of porn, it seems to me that people have a pretty common use for it - it should fit the idea of being a 'useful art'. Porn is even referre
by vacri 15y ago
Given the popularity of porn, it seems to me that people have a pretty common use for it - it should fit the idea of being a 'useful art'.
Porn is even referred to as being 'used'. "He uses porn". Fine art isn't referred to this way with respect to consumers. Someone wandering through an art gallery isn't said to "use Rothko" (though another artist may have their influence described this way).
anigbrowl has also pointed out some things that are obscene - actions which intentionally injure others. Rescission departments in insurance agencies are a better example of obscenity than porn.
- sliverstorm 15y agoWhere does the Miller test talk about "usefulness"? It speaks of "serious literary, artistic, political or scientific value". Also realize the First Amendment is not talking about the "utility" of "art". http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Useful_arts http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Useful_arts Lastly, you really have a tortured definition of "obscene": http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/obscene http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/obscene
- vacri 15y agoBy 'tortured definition', do you mean "Perfectly fits section 2c of my linked definition"?
- sliverstorm 15y agoI realize now you are using "injure" as simply, "to offend". It is rare I use, or hear it used, in such a fashion. My apologies.
- vacri 15y agoNo, I meant actions intended to actually harm, physically or otherwise. Recission departments exist to intentionally screw people over - you make people pay for a product that you then do you best to squirm your way out of providing. Recission departments are "repulsive by reason of crass disregard of moral or ethical principles" Given the popularity of porn, I truly think that if you were able to get honest answers out of people (ie no social pressure to answer in a given way), more would have a problem with the existence of recission depts than with the existence of porn.
- sliverstorm 15y agoOh, I think I understand now. When you say "anigbrowl has also pointed out some things that are obscene - actions which intentionally injure others" you mean: 'here are some actions which are obscene' rather than 'obscene means actions which intentionally injure others'