51 ms·
Obscenity is not in question...Only utility. You'd be surprised how significant the precision of wording is in law. And I would be surprised if lawyers didn't
by bilbo0s 15y ago
Obscenity is not in question...Only utility.
You'd be surprised how significant the precision of wording is in law. And I would be surprised if lawyers didn't seek to have this very point litigated.
- anigbrowl 15y agoNot really, as I am a law student and quite interested in first amendment issues. However, the question of whether porn is obscene is at the outer limits of being relevant on HN to begin with, and I'm reluctant to spend a whole afternoon writing an extended argument with citations and so forth. If you're interested in why I think the utility argument is a dead letter, look up the work of Edward De Grazia, a leading legal writer and litigator in this area.