3 ms·
Victron is good stuff and it is made to last. They're a big supplier to maritime integrators to provide power on board of ships of all shapes & sizes. I've yet
by jacquesm 4y ago
Victron is good stuff and it is made to last. They're a big supplier to maritime integrators to provide power on board of ships of all shapes & sizes. I've yet to see a Victron inverter fail before the end of the lifetime of the installation it was a part of whereas most other inverters including Xantrex and ABB tend to die after a decade or so. Which isn't bad but still it can be a big hassle to replace an inverter if the form factor has changed.
Also: consider decoupling your battery charger setup from the solar portion, this will give you a lot more flexibility in terms of siting (you can then place your battery and charger where you want on your local installation). You can use HA to bring your battery online when it is most needed and even when to charge it based on the outputs of multiple fields of solar, an integrated solution really only works with a single inverter or a set of inverters of a single brand.
And if you can stay away from stuff that requires an internet connection to some manufacturer, not all upgrades are positives and your data shouldn't be going there anywhere. Also it probably isn't a good idea to hand over control of a grid connected device to another party, especially when that device has firmware that can't be audited.
- mapmap 4y ago> consider decoupling your battery charger setup from the solar portion Can you provide more details on this? I’m having a hard time imagining how the solar, inverter, and battery chargers are connected in relation to the house and grid. And what is HA? Thank you.
- jacquesm 4y agoHA -> Home Assistant If you have a separate charger/inverter that you can control remotely using HA then you simply monitor your outgoing power and if that goes negative and your batteries aren't charged yet you instruct the charger portion to charge the batteries. Then, when the sun goes down you can order the inverter part to come to life and supply current up to the point where the outgoing current is close to zero. Like that you maximize your own usage. And by having this split up you can site your batteries in a spot where the temperature is relatively stable, but still outside of the house which is usually not where you have your solar panels. A solar inverter should be sited relatively close to the panels to avoid cable losses and to reduce the risk of having unfused 800V DC cabling running through your house for any appreciable length. Ideally you want those cables to be just long enough to get under the roof to the spot where the inverter sits and then regular cabling to the distribution panel. By connecting the charger/inverter combination to the distribution panel in the same manner you get a lot more freedom. And if you have multiple sets of solar panels that's really the only setup that makes sense otherwise only a limited number of panels can be used to charge the battery (the ones that are directly connected to the inverter that feeds that battery). That's why I'm not a huge fan of the so called 'hybrid' inverters. They make a lot of assumptions about the physical layout of the location that may not hold true in practice. Here I have 50 panels divided into five fields, 6,8,8,10, and 18 panels in each of them and three inverters. This gave a lot of flexibility in where panels could be located. But if I want to charge a battery in a hybrid setup I'd have to pick which set of panels to use and then I'd still be limited in where I could locate the batteries, presumably they'd be close to whichever set of panels I would like to use to charge them with. But by decoupling that and using the AC network as the bus I can put them pretty much anywhere that I can reach with another cable run into the distribution panel. That way all 50 panels can contribute to the charging. An interesting extra option is to run one more cable from the battery charger/inverter to the inverter port, that allows you to power a set of critical loads from battery power. But since the grid here is very reliable I won't be using that. hth, feel free to ask more.
- TrueDuality 4y agoI haven't heard of a setup like this before. It seems like you would be loosing a lot of efficiency having to translate the voltage to AC and back to DC to charge your batteries.
- jacquesm 4y agoNot really, those inverters are 96-98% efficient.
- archi42 4y agoAh, a jacquesm reply, I feel honored :) Of course you're right, the Victron are good, and they're proven. They're incredible flexible and for hackers like us they're amazing units. But for me the Deye was 2500€ shipped (group order with the german tax break applied), with 10yr warranty and a local company acting as a liason for warranty claims. If the Victron setup would have been 3000 or maybe even 3500€ I wouldn't have looked at the Deye - but we're currently energetically renovating a house, and with the current price hikes we have to be careful not to drain our funds before we're done. So for me the choice was a smaller system (both kWp and kWh), or the Deye. Since I can locally control the unit via RS485 (I use HA and node-red), I'll eventually do a lot of sheningans as well. I despise things that require cloud and the Deyes cloud connection is no different (and hence severed in the OpnSense). If people want to consume most of the generated power onsite good local control is a necessity. Once we have other things like the central heating and the new roof done and when I'm not busy with plaster work around the new windows anymore, maybe then I'll setup the more advanced energy managment like evcc or custom automations. Until then the 14kWh battery takes care of ensuring energy stays local (and I only make sure not to charge the PHEV battery from it by accident - the Deye happens to have a suitable output port that's activated if the battery is full; I have yet to wire that port though). Anyway, for someone who has the liquidity, and feels they want to use the Victron ecosystem, by all means, for lots of metrics it's better than the Deye; but for me I didn't see that the Victron would save me more money than the initial invest. Also, the single Deye happens to fit my requirements pretty well (it's a bit more powerful than necessary, but the extra costs over their smaller units were neglibible).
- jacquesm 4y agoIt's all trade-offs. I have a pretty weird setup with lots of gear that gets switched in and out according to power availability, and inverters in different spots (two in the garage and one in the attic). I still haven't installed a battery because we - for the moment - have 100% net metering here so it would be a waste of money. TCO is one way to look at things, installation flexibility another and finally of course initial outlay: better to buy the setup you can afford than to drool over a better one that you can't. I've yet to come across Deye in the wild so nice to have some data points. What I'm really curious about is to what degree the various setpoints are configurable. I have a Growatt here that is giving me a ton of trouble and two Solax units that have been rock solid since first installation (and without any configuration at all). All of them offline. On the panel side here I have a bunch of AEG branded glass/glass panels (AEG has licensed their brand so these aren't actually made by AEG but they are made in Germany and look to be well constructed and with a 25 year predicted life span I think I'll be long gone before the panels will die). I'd love to hear how you are faring with all of the stuff that you've done.