5 ms·
Seems like tons of Mastodon advocates are the ones always pitching it as an alternative to Twitter. Every time that happens, I'll just get the numbers out since
by rvz 4y ago
Seems like tons of Mastodon advocates are the ones always pitching it as an alternative to Twitter. Every time that happens, I'll just get the numbers out since you brought up the total number or registered users which is irrelevant to active users:
Twitter: 220M+ DAU over 17 years.
Mastodon: ~50,000 DAU (1.4M MAU) over 7 years.
What matters in social networks is scale and it still means more users and there is already evidence that Mastodon not only was and is still struggling to scale, but eventually needed to re-centralize to handle their scalability issues, ie. using Cloudflare. Most of the instances there, are hosted by enthusiasts and hobbyists which intermittently struggle with more users.
If an instance is too small, it will easily be at risk of getting attacked and overloaded with users, with the instance falling over and having to close signups. If its too large, they become more centralized and to incentivise federation they have to close signups. Either way, centralization is inevitable.
It's already bad enough for normal users to 'choose an instance' if their can't register on a closed one or if a rouge admin bans you or an entire instance over something silly. Thus, It is quite clear to me, that for normal users who are not techies or geeks, Mastodon is not a viable alternative or even remotely to replace Twitter or even a recommendation.
- phoe-krk 4y ago>If an instance is too small, it will easily be at risk of getting attacked and overloaded with users, with the instance falling over and having to close signups. Co-admin of https://functional.cafe https://functional.cafe here. Mastodon lists us as having 213 active users currently, so I guess this counts as a small instance. Haven't seen our instance fall over for more than a day or two except for hitting hardware limits, mostly hard disk space. Also, I have no idea why you perceive closing sign-ups as a sign of failure. Closing sign-ups or going invite-only protects the current users and state of the instance (and, indirectly, the rest of the Fediverse) both from the dangers of attacks from new users and from explosive growth. Is it some sort of measure of success, to be able to always invite new people even at the expense of already existing ones?
- boudin 4y agoWhat's this thing with the absolute wish to centralise everything? The Internet is decentralisation, it's birth is interconnecting networks, having one massive network being just not scaleable. The web is a decentralise content system, allowing anybody to add content easily is the reason it scaled. Same goes for the domain name system. Companies like Twitter HAVE to decentralise their system in some ways to make it scale, because centralisation does not scale (using CDNs, caches, replication, etc...). Centralisation do makes seems much simpler to build, but it's not a strength, it's a big weakness and create single points of failure.
- jeroenhd 4y agoAll the important accounts I followed on twitter switched to Mastodon when Elon got his hands on the platform. I don't want Mastodon to be a Twitter alternative, really, even if it is only for some circles. The endless Twitter drama and hot takes being pushed in your face by Twitter's engagement algorithm is tiring. I'd be happy if that dredge would be kept away from the Fediverse. It sadly isn't, but at least the situation hasn't gotten nearly as bad as Twitter's thanks to smaller communities that aren't afraid to practice moderation. I know the idea that someone might kick you off your server for being toxic is a problem for some free speech absolutionists, but personally I'm glad to see them return to Twitter/Truth Social/Gap/that weird web3 Twitter without moderation. If you're trying to build a brand, Twitter is a lot better. Their fake engagement statistics below every post help a lot when it comes to inflating popularity statistics and you can't use ads on Mastodon to force your brand down other people's time lines. Only people who genuinely want to see what you're saying are seeing your content and that's why Mastodon will never replace Twitter:you can't buy your way to some twisted sense of popularity. I doubt complete centralisation will ever happen. We'll probably end up with a sort of email light, where it's quite easy to set up a smaller instance but the majority of users flock to a few popular servers the same way Gmail and Outlook have replaced ISP mail accounts. However, because Mastodon and other Fediverse services don't really have a way to do AI moderation in a way that pretends to work well enough, I don't think scaling up to servers of more than a few thousand people is really viable.
- rapnie 4y ago> What matters in social networks is scale What value does scale have, if you get only lazy retweets and likes and low-quality responses? I don't need 'eyeballs-on-tweet' kind of exposure, but interesting discussions. I get these on the Fediverse, and yes I managed to pass the 15 minutes selection of an instance. Which isn't all-too-important either, as instances federate with each other and you can migrate later, if you wish. Btw, for an example pitching that Twitter isn't a good replacement for Mastodon, see yesterday's thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35578226 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35578226
- rvz 4y ago> What value does scale have, if you get only lazy retweets and likes and low-quality responses? I don't need 'eyeballs-on-tweet' kind of exposure, but interesting discussions. Normal users use the block button, protected tweets and whitelisted or follower-only replies which those already exist. Problem solved. This is a non-issue. Even by looking at the so-called 'migration', it has failed to convince existing Twitter users to stick around on Mastodon which by comparing with the figures: 220M vs 50,000 daily active users, it is not even close to 1%. It's clear the Mastodon has decided to immediately disqualify itself and has decided to add more barriers to entry and migrations within migrations as features as you have just admitted: > ...yes I managed to pass the 15 minutes selection of an instance. Which isn't all-too-important either, as instances federate with each other and you can migrate later, if you wish. My point(s) still stand. An island for techies and geeks isn't a great pitch to normal people who dislike Twitter and are looking for a viable alternative.
- yzydserd 4y agoThis seems erroneous "~50,000 DAU (1.4M MAU)". It can't be true that the average monthly user only interacts once per month (1.4M/50k). How do you explain the figure? Dividing MAU by 30 would not be a good approach.
- rvz 4y agoAt least one 'Toot' from a registered user a day = 1 daily active user (DAU), no matter how many times they toot, boost, reply or whatever. > Dividing MAU by 30 would not be a good approach. It is. By doing so with the top 20 Mastodon instances [0] we get even less than 50,000 users using it daily, hence the generous approximation. Even if we don't, we can only imply that the DAU is ultimately far less than 100,000 users a day, posting at least once on the platform. This is why many Mastodon supporters would rather not tell me the daily active users and would immediately avoid mentioning it, which this is the real reason why they cannot claim that millions are using it 'daily'. [0] http://demo.fedilist.com/instance?software=mastodon&onion=not&sort=mau http://demo.fedilist.com/instance?software=mastodon&onion=no...
- lapcat 4y ago> At least one 'Toot' from a registered user a day = 1 daily active user (DAU), no matter how many times they toot, boost, reply or whatever. This is not how Twitter measures DAU. In fact, most Twitter users are quiet lurkers who rarely if ever tweet. Twitter makes money (or used to make money) from their eyeballs, not from their tweets.
- rvz 4y agoWe are talking about Mastodon's DAU which that is still a mystery. Twitter's DAU is already known to be over in the hundreds of millions approximately. The whole point is: >> Even if we don't, we can only imply that the DAU is ultimately far less than 100,000 users a day, posting at least once on the platform. Either way, it is safe to assume and with the data from Fedlist and matching it with the instances of 'active users' it is still less than 1% of the DAUs on Twitter, hence why Mastodon fans (like yourself) cannot claim and proudly show that there are 'millions of users' using it daily. Furthermore, debunking the so-called 'Twitter migration' that wasn't.
- throwbadubadu 4y ago> What matters in social networks is scale If you care about a revenue stream like ads, or are a prominence wanting a broadcasting platform.. but in general: why, no, not at all?
- qtzfz 4y agoBecause the more people you have to read or talk to, the better? Because you want all your friends and people you want to hear from to be already there? It's like those threads about Signal, talking about how much better it is compared to whatsapp and the rest - okay, maybe, but if my friends aren't there already, it's worthless.
- throwbadubadu 4y agoNo, for some maybe, for others not. Also quantity vs quality. And also, what about those monopolies, I understand motivation, but the outcome is problematic.. If we want the everybody encompassing user platform it shouldn't be commercialized and owned like that, with a lot of idealism ;) > but if my friends aren't there already, it's worthless See that is another level problem there also.. if everybody jumps out of the window, I need too?How did we survive just prior to mega social networks.. huh. So again, I know for some what you mention is the important point. But don't tell evryone, and also every playform, that if they are not aiming for super growth they are doing it wrong, because (and likely even intentionally) they aren't!
- BeefWellington 4y ago> Because the more people you have to read or talk to, the better? Not really. Having quality interactions is more important to me than having many interactions.
- vidarh 4y agoWhat matters is if the right people are there. Same reason why we're on HN even though it's tony compared to Reddit. And many of us are both places. For me, Mastodon now have more of the right people than Twitter, but I still hold on to my Twitter accounts too because there are others I still want to talk to there.
- mal-2 4y agoScale isn't the whole story. The most noticeable thing for me on fedi was that people actually saw my posts and interacted with them. All the DAU on Twitter doesn't matter when you need to pass the Great Filter of the algorithm to get seen. Every post I made on Twitter got almost no engagement, and my friends who followed me would tell me they never saw it. Instead my timeline was full of influencers, bots, and that week's outrage. On fedi I feel like I have a small community who engages with my posts. I think that's what people want, even a few hundred followers is enough to feel heard. I can control my own timeline and find content I want. It really doesn't matter if it's only 1% the size of Twitter because my timeline is leagues better.
- Hamuko 4y ago>The most noticeable thing for me on fedi was that people actually saw my posts How do you know that people saw your posts on Mastodon?
- mal-2 4y agoReplies, boosts, likes, follow requests.
- BeefWellington 4y agoEngagement on Mastodon is simply higher quality IME as well. Whether it's an "Eternal September" thing or not that Mastodon hasn't hit yet remains to be seen. It really reminds me of modern social media meets older school internet (IRC & web forums days).
- tedivm 4y agoI posted on the #fedihire tag and got an amazing response, and then a job. My twitter engagement was basically a single "like" and then nothing.
- vidarh 4y agoI have about 100x as many followers on my biggest twitter account as on my Mastodon, and yet typically get more engagement on Mastodon... Much of it down to the algo, but also, I suspect simply churn: A whole lot of followers who are now longer active. My Mastodon account hasn't had time to accrue many of those so far.
- lapcat 4y ago> Mastodon: ~50,000 DAU Citation definitely needed for this number. It's not only false, it's egregiously false. These stats seem to suggest that there are well over a million DAU: https://api.joinmastodon.org/statistics https://api.joinmastodon.org/statistics
- rvz 4y ago> These stats seem to suggest that there are well over a million DAU Please. That is the figures for the MAUs [0] and you're clearly using that to attempt to pass that as a source for the non-existent daily active users metric and you know it. [0] https://joinmastodon.org/servers https://joinmastodon.org/servers
- lapcat 4y agoWrong. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35602391 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35602391 Moreover, you're still attempting to pass off 50,000 as something you just didn't make up out of thin air.
- rvz 4y ago> Wrong. Correct. [0] "Monthly Active Users" That does NOT say "Daily". Surely you can read that. > Moreover, you're still attempting to pass off 50,000 as something you just didn't make up out of thin air. Even it is wrong, There are no sources out there that is verifiable and you haven't provided one after I debunked your figures (which is actually the MAUs). So as long as the exact DAUs is unknown, the figures can be estimated to be as low as 100,000 DAUs and even worst case 50,000 DAUs. [0] https://joinmastodon.org/servers https://joinmastodon.org/servers
- lapcat 4y ago> That does NOT say "Daily". Surely you can read that. Yes, I discussed the issue in the link I gave. Surely you can read that. > So as long as the exact DAUs is unknown, the figures can be estimated to be as low as 100,000 DAUs and even worst case 50,000 DAUs. This doesn't follow. I can estimate it as 2 people. Or 2 billion people. Where does 100,000 or 50,000 come from? You repeatedly refuse to give any evidence that you haven't made those numbers up out of thin air. Anyway, it's redundant to argue the exact same thing in 2 different threads, so let's stick to the other thread please, since it has more info and explanation.
- rsynnott 4y ago> Mastodon: ~50,000 DAU (1.4M MAU) Hold on, are you... getting DAU by dividing MAU by 28? That's very much not how that works; perhaps the easiest way to illustrate this is by considering Facebook, which has ~2bn DAU, but obviously does not have 48bn people using it every month. In general for social media stuff, DAU and MAU are pretty close to each other; Facebook is 2bn vs 3bn or thereabouts, and AIUI Twitter is even closer.