3 ms·
I got out of this particular job type just before HDR became widespread as a consumer product. Chasing color accuracy is one of the top 3 things I hate about co
by dylan604 4y ago
I got out of this particular job type just before HDR became widespread as a consumer product. Chasing color accuracy is one of the top 3 things I hate about computing only proceeded by choosing a font, and printing.
I spent time in a color correction facility where we had to calibrate Sony studio reference CRTs, LCDs (or other flat panel tech), Christie projectors, and desktop monitors. I absolutely hate Hate HATE it. The external monitors being fed by a Decklink card would have to be calibrated using a dedicated instrument for each type of screen. The desktop screens would have to be calibrated by another device. At the end of the day, the client was always advised to base color decisions on the calibrated display monitors and NOT the desktop monitors. Luckily, all of this was handled by the video engineering department, and I only know as much about it from what I asked. Thankfully, it was never my responsibility! So, I guess I'm saying good luck with that! ;-) Trying to dial in all of the different display devices to match is a journey into madness. There was a time when commercial content was only ever critically evaluated on broadcast quality monitors. As web content became larger, people were less concerned about the broadcast safe and pushed values to no longer be broadcast safe so that they looked good on iPhones. All of that to say, you're not alone in your pain.
Also, are you working a PC or Mac? If you're on a PC, I have zero experience with this on that platform. Fun fact (using air quotes), there was a bug in QTPlayer so that the first file you opened would display with an incorrect gamma value. When doing critical color decisions with that player, we would open some random file first, then open up the rest of the files we were interested in. Don't know if that bug is still around or not. If you're facing brightness differences between apps, my first assumption would be gamma differences between apps.
- aikinai 4y agoOh okay, thanks for the response though! Yeah, this whole space is such a mess and I'm not even trying to do something at a professional level (which is why I'm using my Mac screen and not a reference monitor). There are a lot of blog posts and YouTube videos about matching Davinci, QuickTime, YouTube, etc. but so far I've only found answers for SDR. Native Mac screens have a true HDR mode built in you can see clearly when you play any HDR video in Photos, QuickTime, etc. The normal UI is capped to, I believe, 500 nits, and then HDR video unlocks up to 1600 nits. I can see my settings in Resolve are unlocking the higher brightness, so it should be triggering the MacOS HDR pipeline, but it's too bright, so I agree the gamma must be different somehow.
- aikinai 4y agoI played with it a bit more just now and I'm very close! For anyone who stumbles on this thread in the future I found that in Resolve if I disable automatic color management, and set the output color space to "ST2084 500 nit", then the gamma seems to match Quicktime exactly (though I'm not a professional). It's still clearly going over 500 nits in the viewer, so I guess that's some sort of baseline that matches the "default 500 nits but go over for HDR" that Macs do. The colors are still just a bit off and I think that might be something about how Quicktime and Resolve are interpreting the Sony HLG3 colors which don't exactly match the standards. I might try some of the normalization products offered here[0] later when I get time. [0] https://xtremestuff.net/sony-and-hybrid-log-gamma-hlg/ https://xtremestuff.net/sony-and-hybrid-log-gamma-hlg/