3 ms·
That smells like illegal age discrimination for any other employer.
by loeg 4y ago
That smells like illegal age discrimination for any other employer.
- ars 4y agoAge discrimination is illegal only if it does not materialy impact performance. Try to get a job in the NBA or any other sports team in your '40s and see what happens.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 4y agoNBA doesn’t have a public disclaimer saying “only people under the age of 30 have the possibility of joining” though
- nostromo 4y agoIf you can play basketball like a pro, you’ll get in no matter how old you are.
- midoridensha 4y agoI guarantee that if some 50-year-old guy tried out and they found he could play better than Michael Jordan in his prime, they'd take him. Of course, this is extremely unlikely, and he might have a hard time getting in front of the right people to prove himself. Pro sports doesn't have age limitations that I'm aware of; it's all entirely performance-related. People who can't perform don't get new contracts, regardless of their age, and of course as people get older (and accumulate more sports injuries), they become less competitive.
- stametseater 4y ago> as people get older (and accumulate more sports injuries), they become less competitive. I don't think they wait for you to get injured. Before signing you on, they surely require you to pass some physical examinations first. Old people are unlikely to pass those psychicals regardless of how good they are at basketball, since their bones and joints are relatively weaker and therefore more susceptible to injury. What's the point of hiring the world's greatest basketball player if he'll break a hip the first time he falls? If a player has an unusually high risk of being severely injured, then it doesn't make sense to sign them in the first place. Doing so would be tragic and exploitative. Anyway, the oldest NBA player ever was 45, and there have only ever been 7 who played past 42. Michael Jordan retired at 40 years and 58 days, and that was notably old. A player at 50 who makes the cut is basically fantasy.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- midoridensha 4y ago>since their bones and joints are relatively weaker and therefore more susceptible to injury. Regular 50-year-olds, sure. But if they find some genetic mutant who looks like he's 25 even though he's 60, and passes all the physical tests as well as a 25-year-old, age isn't going to be a factor. Meanwhile, over in the aviation field, that same genetic mutant would be unable to become a pilot purely because of his age.
- runnerup 4y agoRight? Can I do this at my company?
- toomuchtodo 4y agoWill customers at your company die if you make a mistake? I do not support age discrimination (roughly around 40), but also want to survive my flights, medical procedures, and anything else where age impacting ability intersects with life safety. A tricky balance for sure. The military has some rough age bands as well: https://www.usa.gov/military-requirements https://www.usa.gov/military-requirements Maybe dial back the age restriction with strong workload automation around airspace situational awareness and routing?
- SOLAR_FIELDS 4y agoIs there documented scientific evidence demonstrating that pilots, surgeons, etc over 40 crash more with statistical significance? 50? 70? I’m sure there is a date when that does happen, but if you are going to be slapping age related restrictions on everyone, you had better come in with guns blazing on your numbers demonstrating that statistically this is bad for society
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- stametseater 4y agoIn short, yes. It's an evidence-based qualification. FAA takes this stuff seriously.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 4y agoCool. Makes sense. Where is the evidence that was used to make this determination and the document released by FAA using that evidence to make said determination?
- 4y ago
- nordsieck 4y ago> That smells like illegal age discrimination for any other employer. Sure. But that's the benefit of wearing the crown. The government also gets to run IQ tests[1] on many prospective employees, which would be illegal in the private sector due to the 4/5ths rule. --- 1. https://www.officialasvab.com/ https://www.officialasvab.com/
- hgsgm 4y agoThe private sector basically can't give IQ tests but can give work-related skill tests that are extremely similar IQ tests. "LeetCode" tests famous on HN are one example.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> The private sector basically can’t give IQ tests False. > but can give work-related skill tests that are extremely similar IQ tests. Legally, the conditions in which the private sector can give work-related skills tests that are extremely similar to IQ tests are when they fulfill the exact same requirements with regard to those tests that they would need to fill with regard to IQ tests to be able to legally give them; if they are functionally very similar, the circumstances in which they will satisfy those conditions will also be very similar. The fact that the case establishing the rule on disparate impact discrimination involved (among other hiring practices) the use of IQ testing doesn’t mean that the disparate impact rule applies differently to IQ testing than to other “extremely similar” tests.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Sure. But that’s the benefit of wearing the crown. Except its not, see, e.g., the Supreme Court decision in Babb v. Wilkie (2020). https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/19pdf/18-882_3ebh.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/19pdf/18-882_3ebh.pdf
- j16sdiz 4y agoWikipedia article, for those not vested in legalese: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Babb_v._Wilkie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Babb_v._Wilkie > Section 633 of the Age Discrimination in Employment Act of 1967 permits federal employees to sue over any adverse personnel action that is influenced by age, even if age was not the determinating factor.
- stametseater 4y agoIt's legal age discrimination because they've determined it to be a BFOQ.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 4y agoI can buy this defense if they have a reasonable justification for this determination published somewhere publically (via court documents or otherwise). Do they? This isn’t something that we just take their word for it.
- rhapsodic 4y ago[dead]
- stametseater 4y agoYou're acting like this is some new development (presumably because you just now learned about it), but it's been this way since forever. If it were legally dodgy, then why hasn't it been challenged in court and torn apart? Because you're the first to be offended by it, or because it isn't dodgy and the FAA are on firm ground? The latter. Age limits for pilots and ATC are textbook examples of BFOQs. > This isn’t something that we just take their word for it. If you want to hit the books, knock yourself out. I am perfectly content to take the FAA's word for it, and think you'd be wasting your time.
- hgsgm 4y agoHow is age (regardless of ability) a qualification? Why can't they give an entrance test?
- jabroni_salad 4y agoAs you get older, your cognitive throughput is going to decrease. They want to train you up in the money zone and then give you the boot before you decline past a certain point and cause a disaster.