6 ms·
Consider Japan: (fact) a single market with a single language (fact) geographically isolated (fact) not much space (fact) burned to the ground in WW2 and y
by WalterBright 4y ago
Consider Japan:
(fact) a single market with a single language
(fact) geographically isolated
(fact) not much space
(fact) burned to the ground in WW2
and yet for a while it was an economic powerhouse on the world stage.
Taiwan, Hong Kong and S Korea, similar stories.
So what is the common thread? Free markets.
- zzzzzzzza 4y agomortgage slavery is the common thread for some reason this motivates people. primordial need for land ownership. the call of the feudalism. engine runs out of steam once the growing cabal of landlords eat the last marginal production in excess of rate of interest america has more land relative to its population so takes longer to nimbify it all
- __pache__ 4y agoWhy? Seems to me owning what you create is the key, instead of having it ripped from your hands.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoAs if you can cleanly define "what you create". Or "you". Or "create". Back to the philosophy playpen, John G.
- __pache__ 4y agoI mean, yeah? Markets are great at finding how much something is worth. uhhhh Want to give some examples?
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoNo examples needed. You can't adequately define "what you create", because nobody can. Where does your contribution begin, and end? Where does the contribution of your parents, your neighbors, your friends, your society begin, and end? To what extent did you create anything, or was it just a remix? Is everything a remix? Who are you? You have a unified, continuous sense of self, but most contemporary psychology finds it fairly easy to take people through processes that break this down (as do a number of psychedelics). We don't need simplistic randian objectivism - it fails to describe the nuance, the beauty, the depth, the wonder, the complexity and the truth of reality.
- WalterBright 4y agoIf it wouldn't exist without your efforts, then you created it. There's no mystery to it. People freely willing to pay for it with their own money is sufficient evidence.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoBut if it wouldn't exist without other's people efforts too, then what? And they may be people you don't know. They may be people who are dead. "paying with their own money" ... ack, not this simplistic nonsense again. People temporarily gain control over some measure of various economic resources. It's not their own money, beyond some temporary mutual agreement. Tomorrow, it may not be. Also, people pay for things regardless of the creator or the morality of its creation. Their willingness to pay for something speaks to their relationship with the thing, not that of the thing's nominal "creator".
- elefanten 4y agoYou’re mixing different levels of abstraction and equivocating across them. Sure, no human could produce anything modern on their own, without knowledge, training, support, materials, products, labor, etc. that comes from others. A child raised by wolves will never launch a new line of tennis shoes. At the same time, no complex effort comes to be without someone’s motivation and effort to take the risk, coordinate the activity and see it through. It doesn’t have to be one primary person to do so, but it certainly can be. It is not difficult to look at the history of a given project and conclude who most acutely put it into motion. The choice to incentivize this acute influence has trade-offs, but many different societies across history have tried many variations of what / where to incentivize. Abstracted, that’s one of the main points being discussed here. That doesn’t mean all stories about who started / created / produced something are told accurately. But to throw your hands up and say “everything comes from everyone” is completely useless when designing society with the goal of solving problems, providing for its members and improving the human condition.
- 4y ago
- WalterBright 4y ago> more land So does S. America, which has never been prosperous.
- zzzzzzzza 4y agoargentina and venezuela have gone through periods of prosperity. Rule of law is too unstable for the system to get off the ground. Also political intervention by foreign actors, resource curse.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe great thing about free markets is that any country can do it. Free people thrive wherever they are.
- EduardoBautista 4y agoPlenty of underdeveloped countries are free markets as well. China is attempting to show that not even democracy is needed to be prosperous.
- __pache__ 4y ago[flagged]
- ETH_start 4y ago>>Plenty of underdeveloped countries are free markets as well. All less developed free market economies have been free markets since relatively recently. The wealthiest economies are generally those that adopted market based rules the earliest, e.g. the Anglosphere and North West Europe, which were free market based since the 19th century.
- WalterBright 4y ago> Plenty of underdeveloped countries are free markets as well. Example? And you're right that democracy is not a requirement for free markets, though they usually go together.
- friend_and_foe 4y agoSomalia and Yemen are about as free market as it gets.
- mrleinad 4y ago(fact) Karoshi I won't claim to know anything else about Japan. Would love to visit, but I'm not sure I'd love to be part of its economy as a salary man.
- awesome_dude 4y agoThe Japanese directly intervened in their manufacturing companies, and shaped their economy via the Bank of Japan to "rebuild" and grow their economy. They also have a notoriously closed (to outsiders) economy.
- WalterBright 4y agoCuba's economy is closed to outsiders. Didn't make them prosperous. They have a state run bank, too. Didn't make them prosperous.
- awesome_dude 4y agoWhilst your comparison is problematic on the grounds that Cuba suffered from decades of economic sanctions, it still manages to do better than similar nearby economies, Haiti, Jamaica, etc. The point I was making was that the person I was replying to was claiming that Japan's economic prosperity was due to it have a "free market" which it does not (unless you count socialism for the companies as "freedom").
- awesome_dude 4y agoOne other thing that should be noted about the Japanese "miracle" is the fact that, at a crucial point in time, their manufacturing got a huge cash shot from the USA, due to a need for vehicles for the Korean War.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe USA has given huge cash shots to many countries, and no miracle resulted. Afghanistan, for a recent example. All that foreign aid money, which does not produce any visible results.
- arethuza 4y agoAll that money probably had very visible results in places like Dubai?
- solidsnack9000 4y agoJapan is a relatively populous single market with a single language -- about 125 million people at present. It's smaller than the USA, at about 332 million; but almost 60% larger than the most populous Western European country, Germany.
- BartjeD 4y agoYour data are wrong. Germany is home to approximately 83 million people. Japan 126 million. Japan is 40% bigger than Germany, not 60%. US is roughly 334 million. Europe is rougly 748 million, of which the EU is roughly 447 million.
- solidsnack9000 4y agoWhat data is wrong? Germany is the most populous Western European country. The figures that you quote for the EU have nothing do with the comparison we're making in this thread. I don't see how the figure for a percentage that you're quoting is compelling in any way: 126 / 1.6 = 78.75 126 / 1.4 = 90 1.6 * 83 = 132.8 1.4 * 83 = 116.2
- antman 4y ago(fact) Market was not free, US imports were taxed for decades and Japanese exports to the US were not effectively subsidizing Japanese economy for political reasons
- WalterBright 4y agoNothing is a perfect free market. One can still reap the benefits of free markets without them being perfect.
- andrewjl 4y ago> So what is the common thread? Free markets. Not when it comes to Japan. During the post-war boom era the majority of its largest businesses were conglomerates with interlocking ownership structures that prevented accountability to shareholders. In addition to that a large amount of corporate investment was state-directed by the Ministry of International Trade and Industry (MITI). It was an effective system (at least for a time) but not one that can be accurately described as driven by free markets.
- WalterBright 4y agoThis is not as cut and dried as you suggest. https://www.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/serials/files/cato-journal/1984/11/cj4n2-8.pdf https://www.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/serials/files/cato...
- throwaway173738 4y agoCato has a pretty clear pro-market anti-regulation stance so this isn’t a surprising article from them.
- nrp 4y agoInterestingly, among the Asian Tiger economies, their massive growth first unlocked during a period where they were not meaningfully democracies and their governments intervened heavily to pick winners. The proximate success of their economies was export oriented industry, but the industries and the companies within them were more or less hand picked by the ruling regimes. The remarkable thing is that Korea, Taiwan, and Singapore have all successfully turned the corner to being functioning democracies that are still driving economic growth rather than devolving into corrupt dictatorships.
- ido 4y agoAnd of course the biggest (in scale) economic success story of our time is China the last couple decades - which is not a democracy at all as well as having massive government intervention and ownership.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoChina was an economic backwater until they implemented free markets. The Chinese miracle is probably the biggest and most obvious example of how important free markets are to growth.
- ido 4y agoNot just free market, and not completely free markets (there’s a lot of government regulation, intervention and ownership). More specifically they followed Singapore’s model.
- nethdeco 4y agoTell me how Singapore is a democracy ?
- tim333 4y agoThey have elections and the government follows the wishes of the people to some extent even if it doesn't change over much https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Representative_democracy_in_Singapore https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Representative_democracy_in_Si...
- friend_and_foe 4y agoWhile I agree with you that free markets are a very powerful benefit to any state, you're biased in favor of it being the driver of America's success. America has access to both oceans, which means maritime access to the entire world without being able to be blockaded along the way easily. This is asymmetrical, it doesn't necessarily confer advantage the other way around. It has an absolutely massive population, and unimaginable amounts of diverse resources. These alone make for a very powerful state, no matter what system you have. Now add in that it's populace has more small armaments than every other armed forces in the world combined (including it's own), and the free markets, you get a pretty unbeatable recipe, unless theres another continent nobody knows about lurking around the corner waiting to be discovered.
- inglor_cz 4y ago"America has access to both oceans, which means maritime access to the entire world without being able to be blockaded along the way easily. This is asymmetrical, it doesn't necessarily confer advantage the other way around. It has an absolutely massive population, and unimaginable amounts of diverse resources." If those matter so much, Mexico should be much stronger than it is. Unblockable access to two oceans, big population, reasonable amount of resources. What is lacking is rule of law...
- friend_and_foe 4y agoWell, yes, but that explains other phenomena that lead to this. Mexico has had a lot of state blunders in the past 150 years that have led to it being behind the US, and the US got there first. Once someone gets there, they necessarily have to try to prevent someone else from doing so. Mexico could've, but they made a lot of mistakes along the way that set them behind. Lawlessness is a symptom of these blunders.
- diordiderot 4y agoIt's hard to know who's best when you don't play fair https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_involvement_in_regime_change https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_involvement_in...
- alex_sf 4y agoIs the US somehow unique in history for this? If the US is simply better at it, isn't that relevant? It's not like other (former) superpowers didn't do the exact same things: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_involvement_in_regime_change https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_involvement_in_regime_c... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_involvement_in_regime_change https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_involvement_in_regime_... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sino-Third_World_relations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sino-Third_World_relations
- diordiderot 4y agoTouché. I suppose inwardly focused benevolent systems wouldn't spread because they wouldn't want overthrow other systems
- alex_sf 4y agoCan a benevolent system be inwardly focused? How benevolent is it to ignore your neighbor? If we say that it's not a pretend virtue to care about democracy and freedom around the world, then wouldn't it would be a reasonable imperative to interact with the world?