4 ms·
It sounds to me like a weak defense. Promoting science and useful arts may be one reason why copyright exists but I don't think it should be taken as the full e
by InclinedPlane 15y ago
It sounds to me like a weak defense. Promoting science and useful arts may be one reason why copyright exists but I don't think it should be taken as the full enumeration of every possible reason for copyright protections. The actual protections affirmed mention only that authors and inventors should be given the exclusive rights to their works, without exclusion based on whether such work is "useful".
- redthrowaway 15y agoIt should be noted that that's just one part of her case (and she's the plaintiff). The other parts include the defendant harassing her for downloads that supposedly occurred before the film was released, failure on the defendant's part to mitigate damages through the DMCA, the defendant purposefully setting up honeypots to catch infringers (but putting the work out there in the first place in the process), and others. Her claim is not limited to the inadmissibility of porn as copyrightable material.
- nokcha 15y ago>without exclusion based on whether such work is "useful" The term "useful Arts" has a specific meaning (see, e.g., http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Useful_arts http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Useful_arts); likewise, the term "Science", as used in the Copyright Clause, refers not only to what we would call "science" today, but also includes, e.g., literature and the fine arts.
- MBlume 15y agoThe actual protections are embodied in laws passed by congress. The claim here is that under the constitution, congress had no authority to pass those laws except insofar as they promote science and useful arts.