4 ms·
Why do so many tech companies think they have a right o issue decisions to employees, contractors, or customers without communicating context? Lack of contextua
by anigbrowl 4y ago
Why do so many tech companies think they have a right o issue decisions to employees, contractors, or customers without communicating context? Lack of contextual information seems to account for a large proportion of tech grievances discussed on HN.
Running a business as a top-down dictatorial entity with zero accountability says something bad about the founders and owners. The standard excuse is that 'if we give out too much information, people will game the system'. But by evading accountability and often regulation, it's these companies who are gaming the marketplace/regulatory system in which they operate, while offering themselves as victims of unscrupulous individuals whenever one of their counterparties exhibits even a slight degree of autonomy. This kind of control freakery is recapitulating the worst aspects of 20th century Taylorism.
I was very much in favor of Uber as a disruptive entity when they first appeared, given the numerous flaws in the in then-dominant taxicab model. But (along with many other companies that adhere to the same platform mentality) have mutated into something significantly worse.
- rqtwteye 4y agoThey are building the ultimate faceless bureaucracy. Super efficient and amoral. Mix in some AI and most of your life will be controlled by entities that make decisions about your life without accountability. I am sure Kafka would write an excellent book about this
- SoftTalker 4y agoYeah you’re seeing a replay of the sorts of things that lead to taxi regulations in the first place
- sublinear 4y ago> Why do so many tech companies think they have a right to issue decisions to employees, contractors, or customers without communicating context? You're probably not gonna believe it, but it's because they don't know much, especially the context in which they're making decisions. How could they really? The reality of any company is not its ideas, but its implementation details. For tech companies that's really difficult. You know how everyone with a room temperature IQ keeps insisting that AI is gonna take away programming jobs? Imagine that it already happened except that instead of losing your job you have been left to manage the robots... that's the position they're in, but the robots are instead extremely stubborn 20-something contrarians who want to rewrite everything in Rust. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanlon%27s_razor https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanlon%27s_razor
- toomuchtodo 4y agoThey know, they just to care, hence the need for strong regulation to protect the populace from the tech industry.
- artogahr 4y agoI feel called out.
- ipaddr 4y agoYou are probably at that 4-7 years experience level where you are at the top of your stack and feel like you know everything. In the next 15 years you will learn anything can be implemented in any language and the tradeoffs are less important than they appear
- pydry 4y agoNo, they know. They just want to protect their automated systems that determine innocence or guilt from being gamed. That, and liability. The fewer reasons they give the harder it is to be held liable for getting it wrong.
- mihaic 4y agoAlso blame a litigious culture, where context can be used against you in a court of law. It does need to be easier to give feedback without opening yourself up for a frivolous lawsuit.
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoIt is easier to give such feedback, as long as the reasons for firing are lawful, the company can request summary judgement. I honestly would think that a firing for no reason would be more likely to spark a lawsuit that actually goes all the way to a jury (or at least through the discovery process), than a firing where lawful reasons are given.
- NoZebra120vClip 4y agoBecause the more information a company communicates about such a decision, the more likely they are to be liable, or sued, or litigated, or arbitrated based on some part of the decision that could be illegal, discriminatory, exculpating, etc. Many employees are at-will, and that means that they can quit any time, for any reason, and their employer can terminate them at any time, for any reason. That means the company is not required to give context or information about their reasons; they don't need a reason and they don't need to tell anyone, so they won't.
- anigbrowl 4y agoI...don't care. Economic transactions between peers can and probably should proceed on a no harm/no foul/no reason basis; simplicity is the lubricant of economic activity and where and how you choose to spend your money is a sufficient signal. But once you have such large asymmetries that the possibility of dependence arises (eg a rideshare driver or a small online marketplace vendor), the great economic power comes with great responsibility. The approach you describe is like a major league baseball player crushing little league kids. Sure, the major league player is winning through superior ability, but it's also a shitty way to behave.
- Nextgrid 4y agoProviding context requires someone to understand the context and the variables that went into the decision (including potential software bugs or edge-cases) and confirm the decision to the standard they're claiming "we've carefully reviewed this decision/etc BS". Problem is that in reality, the decision is made by some heuristics that can be flawed due to software issues and/or eventual consistency (and the developer who brought up these issues got told "don't worry, it'll only affect 0.1% of users"), and the "escalation path" is an outsourced idiot that presses random buttons while moonlighting as a tech support scammer.
- bagels 4y agoWell, in the case of firing people, generally there is no legal requirement in the US to provide a reason. I know this story isn't about the US though. It can actually hurt you to do so if it can be construed to be an illegal reason (discrimination).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tivert 4y ago> Why do so many tech companies think they have a right o issue decisions to employees, contractors, or customers without communicating context? Lack of contextual information seems to account for a large proportion of tech grievances discussed on HN. Because they're extraordinarily self-centered and irresponsible. Issuing decisions without context is cheaper (e.g. the can use an insane algorithm without human backup), makes them harder to challenge, and insulates them from legal liability (because it's hard to know if they were improper). IIRC, Google's about to get slapped by the courts because even its top executives were willfully avoiding legal record-keeping requirements around their decisionmaking.
- nomel 4y ago> Why do so many tech companies think they have a right o issue decisions to employees, contractors, or customers without communicating context? They don’t think they have the right, they do have the right, at least in the US.