3 ms·
> they hear "nuclear catastrophe averted", when they should hear "we love to see more coal burned, more radiation released, and accelerate climate change". I d
by jacquesm 4y ago
> they hear "nuclear catastrophe averted", when they should hear "we love to see more coal burned, more radiation released, and accelerate climate change".
I don't think either of those are necessarily true. It could very well be that Greenpeace sees nuclear as a vestige of the non-renewable past and that they wish to remove hindrances that slow down the further acceptance of the fact that we will have to bet heavily on renewables if we are to make it out of this. The problem with strawmen of your own making is that they can be cut down by others just as easily as you could do so yourself. Greenpeace is obviously not pro-coal and the resulting release in radiation, they would have much rather seen that instead of building these nuclear plants in the first place the money that went into them had gone into renewables instead, which would have had a more positive impact on climate change in the longer term. Besides, coal isn't the only replacement fuel for the drop in nuclear capacity, which wasn't all that large to begin with so this is a bit of a FUD argument, especially given that after the studies that showed the amount of radioactivity released through fly ash there have been substantial efforts made to contain the exhaust and capture the fly ash (electrostatically, for instance).
But the pro-nuclear faction is now equating less nuclear with more coal in an attempt to greenwash nuclear power. Chernobyl was as good as it gets for an accident of that scale, Fukushima closed the door as far as Germany was concerned. And France is an accident away from having a real problem because they are quite dependent on nuclear power and if the tide ever turns there they will have a real problem catching up.
Germany, meanwhile has a pretty high percentage of renewables already:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renewable_energy_in_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renewable_energy_in_Germany
And given the amount of funds they are pumping into renewables they may well end up ahead of their schedule (in part due to the drop in Russian natural gas).
If anything here in NL the war in Ukraine has given a massive impetus to the transition from fossil to renewables and I hope the effect of that lasts long enough to get us to the finish line.
- madsbuch 4y agoIt is fair enough to argue that Greenpeace in fact want renewables. However, that should be seen as an energy conservatism direction. The energy production needed to be supplied is not todays need, but the need of a future where we don't want to dig up oil. This means that jet fuels need to be produced by sequestration and all transport needs to powered by electricity (or fuel from sequestration). We also want a future where most of the land is not occupied as farm land and is more wild. This requires indoor farming techniques – again extremely energy intensive. In the end we should plan for a world that uses a lot more energy than today. As renewables scale roughly linear to land it is by many not seen as a feasible alternative, as it wouldn't be able to supply 10x the need of today (which it will already struggle with). In the end: Greenpeaces argument only works if they believe that we are at the end of technological development.
- jacquesm 4y agoI think Greenpeace is more of a political organization these days than an activist organization, and it exists mostly to perpetuate itself and raise more funds. That said, they are found on the long term 'right' side of most of these arguments and a lot of their numerical work on the real cost of nuclear power has proven to be accurate in the longer term (even if at the time it seemed a bit pessimistic). This alone should qualify them to see the achievement of shutting down nuclear power as a major milestone for their organization as something of the end of an era. They worked - especially in the past - quite hard to achieve this goal. I remember when Greenpeace was a bunch of guys and girls and an old boat that they painted over because they cared about the whales. Such idealism is a necessity in order to provide some balance in a world where business tends to dominate over social and long term welfare issues. In that sense they succeeded where many others have failed, their voice has added a lot of weight to various issues and has measurably increased awareness of many environmental issues. To present their effort as having the opposite effect isn't really productive, it clearly isn't their goal nor does it match with any statement that they have made or even a realistic assessment of the technical situation. And that's what makes these arguments so annoying, it's just gamesmanship, it elevates winning the game to a higher level than that it does our long term survival. Massive renewables + a viable storage option is clearly the way forward, anything else is just money games by vested interests. As for jet fuels: I think the age of the jet will come to an end at some point and I'm not at all going to mourn that. It was a luxury that we probably couldn't afford and don't actually need all that much. Travel should be time consuming and expensive because if it isn't we will move around so much that the planet will suffer dis-proportionally. Maybe we'll see another round of boats or maybe a slower form of air travel, I really don't know. But the idea that you hop on a plane at 7 in the morning, are in Barcelona at 9:30, attend a meeting, have lunch and fly back has so much wrong with it that I much prefer our current COVID incentivized world of video conferencing.
- madsbuch 4y agoActions speak louder than words and good intentions don't justify bad actions. > As for jet fuels: I think the age of the jet will come to an end at some point This is fair, you argue within a framework where we have seen the technological peak – something I don't think you will meet to much sympathy for in the forum. As such, this is also where this conversation stops – you can't build a house without the foundation.