3 ms·
Batteries work fine at scale. What they don't do is get you to 100% renewables. But hydrogen can be used for that last 5-10%, and Europe has many petawatt hou
by pfdietz 4y ago
Batteries work fine at scale. What they don't do is get you to 100% renewables. But hydrogen can be used for that last 5-10%, and Europe has many petawatt hours of hydrogen storage potential available in salt formations.
- VHRanger 4y agoSources on "they work fine at scale"? Last I checked 4 years ago they didn't at all in terms of costs or pollution to produce/dispose of. Natural stores energy like nuclear or hydro remain best.
- pfdietz 4y agoNow you're moving the goal posts. If something is too expensive, it's too expensive at small scale as well as large scale. There is no engineering reason why a grid cannot have very large amounts of batteries attached to it. If they're at the moment too expensive, that's no inherent obstacle, since battery prices have been falling rapidly, much faster than nuclear's price ever did. > Sources on "they work fine at scale"? Hitchen's Razor. I can dismiss your original claim without evidence, since it was presented without evidence. In other words: sources? You go first. I suspect you are parroting studies that assume batteries are used to get to 100% renewables, then clutch their pearls at how many batteries are needed. Using batteries for that last 10% or so is just bad engineering, so those studies are strawmen.
- _hypx 4y agoIf you have many petawatt-hours of hydrogen storage, you don't need batteries at all.
- pfdietz 4y agoBatteries are likely going to be better for short term storage, due to their higher round trip efficiency. Hydrogen would win for long term storage (seasonal, for example) and backing up the system against rare prolonged dark-calm periods. A combination of the two storage modes could be better than either one alone. Adding additional capabilities (transmission, intermediate term storage, dispatchable demand of various kinds) can only make things cheaper.
- _hypx 4y agoIgnoring the high cost of batteries and the environmental harm in building them. You can eliminate pretty much an entire class of storage needs and all the cost that portains. Heck, even pumped hydro doesn't really need to exist if you have this one, practically unlimited storage system.