6 ms·
Who owns history? How historical footage is hidden and monetised [video]
- pcf 4y agoWebsite for the project: https://www.ahistoryoftheworldaccordingtogettyimages.com https://www.ahistoryoftheworldaccordingtogettyimages.com
- robtaylor 4y agoStrange way to make the film available then not at various times considering the subject matter.
- layer8 4y agoYes, but at least “From summer 2023 onwards, it will be permanently downloadable from this site.” RemindMe! 3 months
- kevviiinn 4y ago>RemindMe! 3 months Does this bot exist outside reddit
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Joeboy 4y agoFestivals quite often want films to be "exclusive", so maybe it's to do with that.
- _a9 4y agoWent digging through the wayback machine to find it and its available here: https://web.archive.org/web/20230117024804/https://www.ahistoryoftheworldaccordingtogettyimages.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20230117024804/https://www.ahist... which leads to: https://drive.google.com/file/d/16ATMkf7SAwwjePZZZb0mFrFX5rM39R1M/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/16ATMkf7SAwwjePZZZb0mFrFX5rM...
- sorokod 4y agoI know that this is not civil disobedience but for some reason it feels like one. Well done!
- mikhailfranco 4y agoFeels like opening the cell door for an innocent prisoner, who had their conviction overturned, but was left to rot in jail.
- Joeri 4y agoCounterpoint: archiving costs money, even for public domain content. Who pays the archivist, if not the users of the archive? And the more obscure a work is, the fewer users of that work the cost can be spread over, so the oldest and most obscure materials would have the highest access cost. It is tricky, because one could argue government could take on the role of archiver, but do we really trust government to maintain an unfiltered archive indefinitely? Or we may say archives should be privately funded and there should be redundancy, but then how do we guarantee continuity of funding?
- vlovich123 4y agoIPFS kind of solves this I think. If content is interesting enough to archivers, they can pay to pin that data. If you make it open, then conceivably your costs could be reduced. I don’t know if IPFS supports it but you could image a fractional ownership model.
- lozenge 4y agoWhat's interesting today to people with money is not necessarily the same as what future historians and researchers will be interested in.
- vlovich123 4y agoThe amount of money to require you to record your entire waking moment in full high depth video is about 6 tib / year. The cost of storing that on the commercial cloud is relatively inexpensive. Less than a few hundred a month at most. My point is that the cost is not about what people with money choose to archive, it’s that there’s a curation challenge that is the bigger financial obstacle. Storage costs might also start to skyrocket if everyone starts to record 24/7 video about their lives (already a problem for video cameras).
- tmtvl 4y agoAre you certain of that? If we say every waking moment in full high-def means 16 hours per day in glorious 1080p, I'd back-of-napkin that to 17 petabytes.
- akudha 4y agoIsn't MLK's "I have a dream" speech copyrighted and aggressively enforced by his estate? Even today, some 60 years later? I suppose if something can be commercialized, humans would do it, happily and forever. It doesn't matter how culturally significant it is (like the MLK speech). Money first, I suppose
- comrh 4y agoIt's also how they can protect it from being used in ways they disagree with.
- slim 4y agothey don't have any legitimacy to disagree with any use of it
- tudorw 4y agovery salient point, similar rights also cover musicians from having their music associated with something obnoxious
- randombits0 4y agoNot very often. Music is mostly licensed through ASCAP/BMI. The musician, if signed to a label, has no choice in the matter “They don’t have my permission to use my music!” They didn’t need it, you’re getting paid, shut up and be the whore like the contract you signed says you are.
- anigbrowl 4y agoImpressive strawman, would cheerfully torch again.
- CharlesW 4y ago> …shut up and be the whore like the contract you signed says you are. Setting aside your concerns about how poor, helpless politicians are being bullied by all-powerful artists, the fact is that licenses often have carve-outs for conventions and other campaign events. Artists can also prevent use by arguing that it infringes on their Right of Publicity or the Lanham Act.
- sema4hacker 4y agoOn Vimeo: https://vimeo.com/762560153 https://vimeo.com/762560153
- saddist0 4y agoApparently the creator didn't make it available on Vimeo/Youtube, and someone did without his permission. Unfortunate. https://twitter.com/RichardMisek/status/1647622806899765251 https://twitter.com/RichardMisek/status/1647622806899765251
- jjulius 4y ago>... and someone did without his permission. Unfortunate. Unfortunate, or the result of releasing something as a CC0[1]? Not saying he shouldn't have done that, nor am I particularly blaming him, but this is the very risk inherent with that type of license. [1]https://creativecommons.org/share-your-work/public-domain/cc0/ https://creativecommons.org/share-your-work/public-domain/cc...
- LocalH 4y agodeleted tweet
- onetokeoverthe 4y agoDownload from here https://www.sendspace.com/file/oakqxm https://www.sendspace.com/file/oakqxm and upload to archive.org 80mb low res version downloaded from vimeo. Does anyone else see the irony of a non-shared doc about how Getty is not sharing?
- saddist0 4y ago@dang: Can we change the link from Aeon to original website? It looks like Aeon re-published/re-shared without the permission, and are just enjoying the ride. Creator's request to Aeon: https://twitter.com/RichardMisek/status/1647622806899765251 https://twitter.com/RichardMisek/status/1647622806899765251 Original project link: https://www.ahistoryoftheworldaccordingtogettyimages.com https://www.ahistoryoftheworldaccordingtogettyimages.com
- Jap2-0 4y agoI agree that the original source is probably better and that permission and attribution would be the best thing for Aeon to do (particularly as a sizeable publication), however he did intentionally publish it as CC0. I suppose things like this are why people hesitate to publish under CC0: it sounds great from an ideological perspective, it's much more difficult when you realize how little control it leaves you with.
- NoZebra120vClip 4y agoPublic domain and now issues an informal takedown? About this topic? That's seven layers of irony.
- saddist0 4y agoYup, agree that attribution might have been more ethical thing to do, even if not required legally. As far as I understand the author wanted to release it as CC0 after the summer screenings i.e. few months. Due to which the video isn't really available for download on official website. Anyways, it was a fun read about CC0 after reading your comment. :)
- tingletech 4y agothere is attribution if you scroll down
- kristianp 4y agoYou might want to email hn support for that request.
- 4y ago
- WeylandYutani 4y agoAs a gamer I learned about this when MGS2 was delisted from GOG because it contained documentary footage. Copyright is just a damned nuisance.
- acidburnNSA 4y agoI became aware of a huge trove of forgotten 1960s-1970s Atomic Energy Commission videos sitting in a basement at the National Archives on 16mm film. I started filling out forms and personally funded the digitization of one of them [1]. Then, I leveraged how awesome it was to convince a utility in Nebraska to fund the digitization of another 2 (which were relevant to them) [2]. Roughly $900 a pop, but so worth it. Now I just have to find funders for the next ~90. [1] https://whatisnuclear.com/zppr.html https://whatisnuclear.com/zppr.html [2] https://whatisnuclear.com/news/2023-03-13-hallam-historical-films-scanned.html https://whatisnuclear.com/news/2023-03-13-hallam-historical-...
- SoftTalker 4y agoPeriscope Films does a lot of this, they have a lot of old 16mm government and military films on YouTube. I don't know if they have other stuff behind a paywall.
- acidburnNSA 4y agoYes they're great. They put their watermark on them and post them on youtube, which is huge amount better than nothing. Some of my favorite old vids come from them. You can guy unwatermarked ones from them, which I guess is how they sustain. I'll take it I guess. They hadn't gotten to these extra obscure AEC ones yet though.
- wingworks 4y agoWow, thanks so much for doing this. And in 4K too! It's a shame there isn't any govt org that is working on digitising (and making public) all these old govt films.
- midoridensha 4y agoIs there really any point to digitizing 16mm film to 4k, instead of 1080p? The initial quality of 16mm film is so bad, I don't see how 1080p is really limiting.
- bawolff 4y ago> for example, the Apollo moon landings and the first breach of the Berlin Wall – are owned by Getty. How does that work? Works by us federal gov employees are generally public domain
- renlo 4y agoIt seems that while it's in the public domain, it's not easily accessible, it really only exists digitized on Getty's servers. It sounds like when you download from Getty, their license restricts you from distributing the copy that you obtained from them (gleaned from the documentary linked in the OP, though I'm not sure how this is legal).
- markdown 4y agoAmazing. I've ranted about the disgusting practices of Getty Images before. They claim ownership of public domain photos and demand payment of $1k/photo for access to them. Utter gutter scum.