5 ms·
You can't be "rabidly apolitical" and be anti-abortion and claim the government has been "censoring the right via tech platforms when it goes against their narr
by krapp 4y ago
You can't be "rabidly apolitical" and be anti-abortion and claim the government has been "censoring the right via tech platforms when it goes against their narratives," both of which are explicitly right-wing political positions.
- baremetal 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- t-3 4y ago> And the fact that tech platforms censor the right is a fact, it may be a right wing talking point but that doesn't negate it being factual just because it displeases some people on the left when they hear it. You're not wrong, but the issue is way overblown. The far left is censored just as much or more as the far right, but have much less mainstream political support in the strongly anti-socialist US. Censorship and free speech are the issue far more than political persecution of one side or another. Allowing the debate to be turned into a neolib vs neocon political battle rather than a matter of fundamental rights and Constitutional law is a mistake.
- kelipso 4y agoThe difference is the "far-left" by your definition is a few edgy online people making up less than 1% of the population while the "far-right" by your definition have their own established political party and makes up some 30% of the population.
- t-3 4y agoI didn't give a definition of either, so I don't know where you're getting any of that from, but you're wrong in any case. Not all, or even a majority, of republicans are far right. Endorsing conservative social policies, libertarianism, or being religious are not at all equivalent to being a fascist, a bigot, or a racial nationalist.
- kelipso 4y agoI'm getting the definitions from people who get banned on the big social media sites mapped to the left-right spectrum. Bans on left aligned people tend to be the edgy lefties while bans on right aligned people tend to be a lot of just to the right of center type people.
- _heimdall 4y agoIf you're talking about a group of people that makes up 30% of the country and a majority of one side of our two party system, I believe they'd just be "the right" not the far right.
- rpastuszak 4y ago> Politics (from Greek: Πολιτικά, politiká, 'affairs of the cities') is the set of activities that are associated with making decisions in groups, or other forms of power relations among individuals […] I think you’re (plural) using and understanding the word “politics” in slightly different ways. As long as you believe that others should follow the rules you follow, it’s politics*. Even if your decision is motivated by religion, it’s still political in practice. Nothing wrong with that. Nowadays saying that something or someone is political is automatically understood as an expression of identity/belonging, or placing someone or one at o other side of sort of a spectrum. But that’s not what the term politics means. * gross oversimplification, I know, just trying to keep it brief
- DoctorOW 4y agoThe use of the term "anti-abortion" is misleading in the age of US abortion restrictions. Preserving bodily autonomy is still pro-choice regardless of whether or not you personally would like one.
- _heimdall 4y agoYou got me curious, how is antiabortion misleading? I've always actually disliked the term "pro-life" as it felt misleading to me when the debate is over abortion rights specifically and not life as a whole
- DoctorOW 4y agoThe debate is about the right to get an abortion, not personal preference. The opposition believes there should be no right for anyone. In a context where you're discussing politics and not medical history, the presumption is that "anti-abortion" describes the political position. This is analogous to the difference between "anti-gay" and "straight".
- _heimdall 4y agoThat's an interesting take on it that I hadn't heard clearly laid out before, thanks! That makes a lot of sense with regards to anti-abortion being a personal preference rather a stance on what others should do. I can't quite wrap my head around how "pro-choice" doesn't also fall into the trap of being a statement of personal preference, but that probably gets too nitpicky about symantics to be important
- DoctorOW 4y agoWhether you personally do or do not want an abortion, you can be in favor of someone having a choice.
- _heimdall 4y agoWith that I wholeheartedly agree. I've never had a strong opinion on abortion laws because I'll never personally have to make that choice. I strongly support everyone's right to choose though. Ironically that landed me on the other side of the fence during Covid from most that are pro-choice with regards to abortions but very much against the right to make other medical choices.
- themitigating 4y ago"And the fact that tech platforms censor the right is a fact" Proof?
- _heimdall 4y agoThe Twitter Files could help out here. Plenty of examples in there of tech censoring topics and individuals that largely fell into what most people would consider "the right" during our pandemic response. "The right" is generally defined as policital views focusing on individual rights. Tech platforms were blatantly censoring discussion that they believed could lead to vaccine hesitancy and individuals making their own decision. They censored topics related to alternative treatments and palliative care. The motivation was clearly to push individuals to go along with the recommendations from government authorities at the expense of individual rights, freedoms, and choice.
- Timon3 4y ago> The Twitter Files could help out here. We know that "The Twitter Files" were a completely one-sided effort to only release information on one political side. Hell, we even have evidence of the Trump White House asking Twitter to take down posts that make fun of Trump. The partisan nature of the release should not just put it into question, but (in my opinion) serves as direct evidence that the right is treated preferentially. If there really was a preference for the left, they would have shown just how few requests the right made, and just how few leftists were banned. But all of this information is kept secret, and it's kept this way for a reason.
- _heimdall 4y agoTo the original question of proof, it sounds like we agree that there is indeed proof that tech platforms were censoring the right. I purposely left the question open with regards to the left being censored. I expect it does happen and examples could be found - I simply don't have proof handy, possibly because as you said the Twitter Files seem to have been one side. The absence of evidence shoeing censorship of the left has no bearing on whether there is evidence that the right was being censored.
- kaba0 4y agoYou are free to deny medical care for yourself based on your religious views (e.g. not accepting blood), but your religion means nothing when it comes to other people’s freedoms. Or what, you shouldn’t be eating pigs because I’m Muslim or what?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tzs 4y ago> You are free to deny medical care for yourself based on your religious views (e.g. not accepting blood), but your religion means nothing when it comes to other people’s freedoms Religion is not really relevant here. If the fetus is a person then aborting them is denying other people's freedom. The question of when along the path of human development one becomes a person is not inherently a religious question. I know many atheists for example who are fine with banning abortions of healthy fetuses that are moments away from birth unless there is something about the birth that would put the mother at unusual risk. That's because they can't find a way to count a newborn baby as a person but exclude a soon to be born fetus because nothing changes between those two times in the things that they consider relevant for determining personhood.
- kaba0 4y ago> the fetus is a person then aborting them is denying other people's freedom. Even if it is a person, you completely fail to take into account the mother as a living human being. Should we save someone in need of a kidney by forcing someone else to give up one of theirs? Not even another person’s life worth more than forcing away the freedom to bodily autonomy - and pregnancy does take an insanely huge toll on the women’s body, so she should be the only arbiter in deciding what she does with it. And “she chose to have sex” is not a valid argument, it is basic human need, and even with protection it is not 100% safe, shit happens. Of course no sane person talks about aborting in like the 8th months or so, but early enough it is absolutely not a huge deal, especially that not doing so would just break two people - a mother that didn’t want to become one, and an unloved child.. who does it benefit?
- ctyc 4y agoI used to be pro abortion as well. I’m now anti abortion because the science has proven at this point beyond a shadow of a doubt that at conception there is a distinct, DNA-unique human being present. Call it what you want to make yourself feel better if you must, but at the end of the day you’re deciding to kill another human life by choosing abortion.
- petee 4y agoCall it what you will, but it's unable to survive until birth, so its not really alive is it? Do we consider ejaculation murder too? They survive on their own, and can navigate their way to an egg... clearly they are from a human, living, and independent:)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Timon3 4y agoThen why is there no large-scale moral outcry over IVF? The process creates and discards a number of fertilized eggs, each of which has unique DNA. Isn't that the much more pressing issue, both considering the procedure is never medically necessary for survival of the woman, and considering that the embryos are created in the knowledge only few will develop into a full human?
- humantiy 4y agoNot sure how you define large scale but there are religions who do have a moral objection or at least rules around Ivf. As an example for Catholics each embryo must be treated as sacred and respected as human life. If you have extra embryos you must do everything possible to respect that life (ie transfer the embryos to someone in need and/or keep in cryo until that can happen). These rules aren’t typically known because ivf is a small minority of people that actually go through the process.
- Timon3 4y ago