3 ms·
The article doesn't mention fusion even once. Byt yes, major science breakthroughs don't happen in a day or even a year, or 10.
by bawolff 4y ago
The article doesn't mention fusion even once.
Byt yes, major science breakthroughs don't happen in a day or even a year, or 10.
- nextaccountic 4y ago> Byt yes, major science breakthroughs don't happen in a day or even a year, or 10. Sometimes they happen in a day. But major engineering breakthroughs, now that's hard, because you have to build the thing.
- jacquesm 4y agoThey take a long time to set up and then they can happen quite quickly but they are usually incremental and tend move the needle only bit-by-bit as we go forward in spite of being a revolutionary science breakthrough. Take flight as an example. People had been experimenting with it probably since the first human saw a bird and wanted to be able to do that. That went exactly nowhere until someone built a kite large enough to support the weight of a (light) human. And since then every few hundred years there was some kind of 'breakthrough', each of which building on probably hundreds or even thousands of failures in the intermediate. Until finally the Wright Brothers made their first powered flight and then we were off to the races. If not for all those failures and all of those baby steps the revolution wouldn't have happened when it did. The Wrights had a number of pre-requisite inventions at their disposal and as much as theirs was the true breakthrough without those other inventions they'd be sitting on a beach playing in the sand. It's layer upon layer of failure, the occasional step of real and measurable progress and even rarer a real breakthrough.
- canadianfella 4y ago[dead]
- mhb 4y agoJust like how Hemingway went bankrupt.
- anonylizard 4y agoThe definition of breakthroughs is that nothing happens for 10 years, and then suddenly everything happens and is possible. AI was wandering in the wilderness just like fusion, a theory without results or practicality. But first alexnet in 2012, then transformers in 2017, and we are now at the stage where "AI is moving too fast and we must pause it!!!" Who knows, maybe the alexnet of superconductors is lurking somewhere.
- sublinear 4y ago> we are now at the stage where "AI is moving too fast and we must pause it!!!" I disagree. The problem isn't the technology, but that for once we have something that demands more deliberate use. LLMs directly confront the literacy gap between the most and least educated members of the public, and I really do mean that in all senses of the word "literacy".
- anshumankmr 4y agoWe have all grown up reading about how inventions were the sole genius of one person. Take the case of Edison's light bulb. Even he admitted he tried 10,000 varieties before getting it right. And even his invention probably came of the back of many others before who probably did research for producing glass at an industrial scale, research into various materials and elements (which could be used for filaments) and so on so forth. It will be quite a while before we get super conductors produced reliably.Of course the prerequisite is that a true super conductor is really created, in a lab condition, is going to take quite some time.
- agumonkey 4y agoElectromagnetic control of liquid crystals is from 1927 (and original research on the chemistry/material side being from 1888) .. things did take a long time to evolve. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fr%C3%A9edericksz_transition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fr%C3%A9edericksz_transition
- danabrams 4y agoThe breakthrough of Edison in the case of the light bulb is less the filament (which he did try thousands of materials for) but the innovations: 1. He figured out that the filament wouldn’t immediately burn out in a vacuum 2. Built machinery to blow glass to the right shape and form the vacuum inside (so he figured out how to make the glass on an industrial scale) 3. Most importantly, figured out how to build a commercially viable system of power generation and distribution in Manhattan so his bulbs would be of use. Yes he worked incrementally. He also invented ways to manufacture and create markets for his novel inventions.
- HansHamster 4y ago> It will be quite a while before we get super conductors produced reliably.Of course the prerequisite is that a true super conductor is really created, in a lab condition, is going to take quite some time. We do have working super conductors produced at scale, some of which are just 'boring' alloys. The problem is that the cryogenics required for operation are expensive and complex, making them not very appealing for widespread use.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoThere's a sort of bermuda triangle of notorious physics vaporware that's been 20 years into the future ever since they were first conceived. * (useful) Fusion * Room Temperature Superconductors * (useful) Quantum Computers There's always breakthroughs but nothing seems to ever come out of it. Will they ever happen? Maybe. That said I've got a degree in theoretical physics and I'd bet against all three within my lifetime.
- Retr0id 4y agoDon't forget next-gen battery chemistries!
- mecsred 4y agoI want to preface this: I'm not trying to be snide, genuinely curious. What kind of person gets a degree in "theoretical physics", something that is by definition speculative, if they also bet against any of the speculation panning out?
- marginalia_nu 4y agoTheoretical physics isn't speculative physics, but physics focusing on mathematical modelling rather than experimentation.
- mecsred 4y agoIf it's not validated by experiment, it's speculative. That's the fundamental principal of science.
- dotnet00 4y agoThe point is that they specialize in the theoretical side, not that they don't try to validate it. The difference is that their validation focuses on math rather than physical experimentation. Eg there's no way to verify Hawking radiation in person (because well, good luck getting near a black hole to do so). But it's still supported by existing models of physics, thus it is science and not mere speculation. Another recent example would be that the idea of time crystals was a theoretical physics result, backed by existing physics. That backing made it more than just speculation, leading to the investment of resources that eventually led to them actually being created. Of course probably the most famous example of a theoretical physicst would be Einstein. Lots of stuff typically goes through theoretical physicists before experimentalists determine how to test the idea. For example, all the particle accelerators, synchrotrons etc are initially designed by theoretical physicists via simulations etc to meet certain goals before putting in the billions of dollars it costs to actually translate those designs into something that can be built and used.
- HPsquared 4y agoMajor science breakthroughs in a given field also aren't guaranteed to even happen.