It seems obvious to me that they want to move to more of a service model where you pay for an "Xbox" subscription and play on whatever devices you have and leav

It seems obvious to me that they want to move to more of a service model where you pay for an "Xbox" subscription and play on whatever devices you have and leave the traditional model behind. We can quibble about the wisdom but it seems like you're calling them a failure for doing exactly what they want to do.