8 ms·
Chocolate: Open-Source Media Manager
- leemailll 4y ago>>"To use it you first need to rename your files" What the hack
- techaqua 4y agowhat is the advantage of using this over jellyfin?
- Jabihjo 4y agolooks like chocolate supports ROMs
- INTPenis 4y agoA lot of us have been waiting for a Python project to contribute to because we don't know .net. Other than that I predict a lot of growing pains. Media management seems simple until you run into a new use case every day.
- drewcoo 4y ago> because we don't know .net But Chocolatey is a totally different kind of project. ;-) https://chocolatey.org https://chocolatey.org > Other than that I predict a lot of growing pains Agreed. It's a larger, more nuanced, more finnicky problem.
- osmanzeki 4y agoPrevious commenter was talking about the fact that Jellyfin is written in C#/.NET, nothing to do with Chocolatey.
- 1letterunixname 4y agoTo be honest, I throw everything into one enormous directly by category without looking. I let a certain app figure it out because there's no value in me spending time to structure things when it's already indexed and organized automatically by the app. I don't need ROMs and not sure how I'd play them across all devices. Is there webassembly MAME?
- thunderbong 4y agoWhich app do you use to automatically index and organise the files?
- boomboomsubban 4y ago>Is there webassembly MAME? https://archive.org/details/internetarcadeturbo https://archive.org/details/internetarcadeturbo
- upon_drumhead 4y agoI'm really hoping that a project is picked up that removes the lock-in and centralized storage of the metadata providers. Having TMDB/TVDB/etc all have a feed of everyone's media content via ip is a privacy issue and potentially a legal issue if the MPAA/RIAA/Whatever target it. Storing the metadata into something like IPFS+TOR would be amazing for privacy concerns.
- quaintdev 4y agoFetching metadata deeds not imply I have highest movies. I could just be testing my movie app.
- snapplebobapple 4y agoDoes this have any clients? That's the problem with stuff like jellyfin, not really the backend server/web interface
- charcircuit 4y agoJellyfin has clients. The mobile app and web clients work fine for me.
- snapplebobapple 4y agoYes I know that, I am using them. For set top box the android client is ok too. The rest of the clients are in varying states of ok to not great though and the linux client is a pain to setup for set top box use when I tried it.
- mmgutz 4y agoThat's one of the reasons I prefer Jellyfin over other media servers. The Web UI works fine on a plain browser. No need for a proprietary client.
- afavour 4y agoThere’s plenty of need if you’re one of the millions of people that has a device plugged into their TV like an Apple TV , Android TV or Roku. None can use a web interface. This is what keeps me on Plex despite preferring the open source nature of Jellyfin.
- codethief 4y agoThere was a discussion here recently[0] where many people recommended Jellyfin in conjunction with its apps[1] for Android, Android TV, Roku, etc. I have never used Jellyfin before but their recommendations made me put it on my list of things to look into. So what are you (and GP) missing from those apps? [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35461596 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35461596 [1]: https://jellyfin.org/downloads/clients/ https://jellyfin.org/downloads/clients/
- ugh123 4y agoLooks nice, but never seen so many rules on file organization. A good media manager would be able to sort that stuff out automatically. Am I missing something?
- Z7YCx5ieof4Std 4y ago> Looks nice, but never seen so many rules on file organization. A good media manager would be able to sort that stuff out automatically. Am I missing something? Same here.I want to just name. Seriesname - Season xx - SxxExx- If I have to rename a serie for using an app its a no-go. I will still try it once.
- 4ndrewl 4y agoThis is an actual good use case for ML.
- nyx_land 4y agoMy attempts at making a media manager/server (like Jellyfin and Subsonic) have shown that it's easier said than done to reliably sort video files since there's not really a standardized way of embeddeding metadata into video files like music files have with ID3v2. I imagine this is because unlike with music which had the MP3 player craze, by the time it became normal for users to have access to digital AV media due to improved storage and networking, locally saved files were bypassed by streaming. So you have to resort to ugly regexes to strip out all the nonsense from a filename (like if you have acquired a movie file from a torrent or something), which has a whole bunch of edge cases. It's made even more annoying by TMDB not having something like MusicBrainz to rank similarity of searches, so you better hope the file you end up with is a good quality string with ideally also the year of release, otherwise you'll probably have to tag stuff manually. So I can't blame the devs for just expecting the user to sort their movie files beforehand (maybe with a different tool (except there aren't any for movie files as far as I know)). It's the kind of thing that there aren't any good solutions to. Not sure how Plex manages to guess movie files better than Jellyfin (I just ended up stealing JF's regexes for my thing) but since it's proprietary there's no way of knowing what regex magic they use.
- noobcoder 4y agoI love the video game support, but I have concerns about the 'proper name' requirement for movies. It would require me to reorganize my entire library and lose a lot of information that other apps use. Also, the lack of subdirectories for organizing books is a limitation for those with large libraries. Overall, it seems like your app is targeted towards users with small, non-automated libraries, and the organizational requirements may prevent some people from using it
- agilob 4y agoHalf of the readme is about what technologies this project uses. Why would the first thing about the project be about Vue, JSON and database, or planned move to React? You better give me compatibility with Sonarr and better ways to name files than E1.mkv E2.mkv.
- call_me_g0d 4y agoLooks good, but imho too many rules rules on file / folder org
- smegsicle 4y agobut can it play doom? or download and install packages from the command line on windows?