6 ms·
I have to say, this is the aspect that almost shocks me the most. The leaker himself doesn't seem like the most sympathetic character, and it might be very well
by xg15 4y ago
I have to say, this is the aspect that almost shocks me the most. The leaker himself doesn't seem like the most sympathetic character, and it might be very well be that he was some rightwing gun nut who shares this for entirely questionable motives.
And yes, I'd also condemn publishing detailed military positions or names of sources.
Nevertheless, I think it's unsettling how quickly media, politicians and the public are to treat any kind of leaking as a grave crime. From what I understood, the documents contained evidence of illegal activity by us agencies - spying on allies, and possibly misleading the public about casualty numbers (that seems questionable though). Yet everyone is condemning the leaker for exposing this stuff instead if demanding an investigation.
Looks like the US press really learned their lessons from the Snowdon leaks - and it weren't the ones he intended.
You can see it in the naming conventions as well - he is called "leaker" now, not "whistleblower" - or, if any media has to, it's "self-described whistleblower".
- baseballdork 4y ago> spying on allies, and possibly misleading the public about casualty numbers Are either of these things illegal? Because what the leaker did absolutely _is_ illegal.
- xg15 4y agoGood question. Not on a national level, I'm sure, though I'd have thought there were international treaties or UN rules about this.
- theknocker 4y ago[dead]
- mjreacher 4y ago> spying on allies That is one of the exact purposes those agencies exist for in almost every country of the world. > possibly misleading the public about casualty numbers The numbers given in the documents are consistent with the numbers publicly stated by the US military. > demanding an investigation For what? I don't see how he is a whistleblower when he hasn't exposed any illegal activity. It's pretty clear from what he friends said that he was doing this solely to impress his friends, which is pretty clearly illegal.