8 ms·
Long Covid Appears to Have Led to a Surge of Disabled in the Workplace (2022)
- Animats 4y agoAmazingly, this is not being treated as a big problem.
- das-hinterland 4y ago[flagged]
- semicolon_storm 4y agoPretty wild you think millions of people are making up a debilitating illness because they "don't want Covid to ever end". Further, you seem to forget immunocompromised people exist. You don't seem to realize that people have different life experiences than you.
- das-hinterland 4y ago[flagged]
- semicolon_storm 4y ago>Immunocompromised people existed before covid yet they weren't walking around like Darth Vader. It's almost like there's a serious and highly infectious virus still circulating. Perhaps one that has a reputation for seriously harming or killing immunocompromised people. >When is it going to end? Better question, why do _you_ care when _others_ decide to stop wearing a mask? This is like a non-asthmatic person criticizing someone with asthma for living in fear by carrying their inhaler in their pocket. When is asthma going to end? Surely they can't just carry around an inhaler for the rest of their lives, right? >They cannot continue to live the rest of their lives in fear, it's debilitating to their mental health. However social media has enabled this behaviour. Yet you're here on social media stressing about other people choosing to wear masks. Honestly for many people it's second nature at this point. Other countries like Japan had people wearing masks in public long before 2020.
- josephcsible 4y ago> Better question, why do _you_ care when _others_ decide to stop wearing a mask? The issue isn't that others are still wearing masks themselves. It's that they're trying their hardest to force the rest of us to wear masks still too. E.g.: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35582836 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35582836
- semicolon_storm 4y agoThere have been zero masks mandates in place for over a year and Covid policies are only getting more relaxed, so that "issue" doesn't really seem to have any teeth.
- josephcsible 4y agoThe thread I linked is full of posts advocating bringing them back.
- pandaman 4y agoThis is not true, e.g. California just lifted its mask mandate in "healthcare settings" less than two weeks ago [1]. Different institutions still maintain their own mask mandates to this day though and not just in California. 1. https://www.msn.com/en-us/health/other/the-california-mask-mandate-is-gone-now-some-patients-fear-for-their-health/ar-AA19JnLp https://www.msn.com/en-us/health/other/the-california-mask-m...
- das-hinterland 4y ago1. There was a serious and highly infectious virus circulating. However this is no longer true hence the rest of society having moved on. 2. The asthma analogy is irrelevant. 3. Societies in east Asia wear masks when they're sick; to prevent the spread of illness. Somewhere along the way this narrative has changed to it being a magic invincibility cloak and credited to Asian society, which it never was.
- ghaff 4y ago
- _ugfj 4y agoThose who are more vulnerable are watching as the world left us hanging dry. There was no reason to end mask mandates. None. Except a few loudmouths the entire world have caved to. We have seen how cheap DIY filter boxes are. There is no reason not to have one in every classroom and workplace. And yet. I am desperate enough to experiment with a Cleanspace Halo, the smallest positive air pressure respirator there is to be able to go among people. If no one else is willing to provide clean air, I need to filter my own. It's bloody ridiculous but what can I do?
- ceejayoz 4y agoWhatever one thinks of general mask mandates, I think I'll always be baffled that we're ditching it in healthcare settings, especially places like ERs. I don't expect to ever go into an ER or pediatrician's office without one.
- hezralig 4y agoIt makes more sense if you view it as an extremely politically motivated decision to signal that we should stop thinking about COVID entirely.
- standardUser 4y agoYour theory sounds conspiratorial and lacking in evidence.
- hezralig 4y agoIronic considering your comment.
- mardifoufs 4y agoWhat was conspirational in his comment?
- 4y ago
- psychphysic 4y agoBecause surge is a bit of an overstatement looking at the graph and that long COVID seems to resolve the workforce has bigger fish to fry. The recent progress of AI is a bigger concern.
- erentz 4y agoMore like the progress of AI may be our savior here. Allowing fewer to be more productive. (Hopefully.)
- psychphysic 4y agoHopefully, it may also reverse the trend that work tools a require higher IQs to effectively utilize.
- erentz 4y agoI worry the impact this will have long term. Both economically as a lot are taken out of the workforce or remain but with less function. And socially as we have this bigger pool of people we need to care for (and likely fail to care for). It’s remarkable it’s been ignored but turning it into a culture war for short term political gain seems to have made any serious discussion about it impossible now. Just look how immediately comments about masking in this discussion were grayed out.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- standardUser 4y agoIs it being treated any better or worse than the dozens of other "big problems" we collectively have to deal with? Are we moving heaven and earth to stop sexual assaults? Or Fentanyl overdoses? Or cardiac deaths? Or youth suicide? Or mass shootings? It seems like there is only a finite amount of friction we can endure en masse to mitigate the problems that plague our health and well-being. If anything, I see several other issues in more urgent need of greater sacrifices on all our parts than long COVID.
- 399215728 4y agoI think there are different people working on each issue. There's no collective "they" that has to split their focus. The microbiologists and epidemiologists that could be studying long COVID aren't the same people that would be working on preventing youth suicide.
- standardUser 4y agoThe collective "they" I was referring to was society at large. The general public. But even among researchers working on solutions to these problems there certainly is a limited amount of resources to fund their research.
- 399215728 4y agoI totally agree that the "general public" has "limited focus," especially since public health campaigns are hard! However, my claim is that a lot of progress on these issues doesn't need to be very public. Telling the public to do a thing sounds like the last step of the process, after researchers have already found a definitive solution. I also agree that researchers have a limited amount of resources! But I don't think that funding a research area is necessarily zero-sum. If a company or government decides to throw extra money to start researching a thing, research on other things doesn't stop. As an example, when the NSF provides more funding for research, the number of PhD students goes up, since there are more research grants to go around.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- onos 4y agoTo get the convo started: The skeptical take is of course that there is no long covid. either people are faking for benefits or they are being sincere but imagining it. Similar concerns around Lyme disease. Q: is there firm evidence for long covid that excludes these possibilities?
- afry1 4y ago[flagged]
- HarryHirsch 4y ago[flagged]
- burnished 4y agoBeing dismissive is not helpful, trying to reduce some one's attempt to bypass the bullshit and get to the meat of the matter to a 'cognitive bias' is also not helpful.
- howinteresting 4y agoBad priors are a cognitive bias.
- burnished 4y agoAre you kidding? What pointless drivel.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- SamoyedFurFluff 4y agoI would argue at least in the United States, the benefits for being disabled is quite limited. There’s wealth limitation (ie. You cannot own more than a certain amount of anything among any assets) and this often precludes disabled people from marriage among other sucky things. The other thing is iirc there’s been brain scans and other biomarker testing of long Covid that shows noticeable differences similar to ME/CFS.
- ministryoftruth 4y ago[flagged]
- djinnandtonic 4y ago[flagged]
- oaththrowaway 4y ago[flagged]
- das-hinterland 4y ago[flagged]
- skrebbel 4y agoMy wife’s long covid (14 months and counting) started after her 3rd jab. You know that day after the jab sometimes when you feel all tired and woozy and sick-ish and can’t get anything done? That just never ended for her. Even though she got vaccinated 3 times, she got called an anti-vaxx loony for a long time, for even daring to suggest that the vaccine clearly marked day one. But by now, increasingly many official sources concur that there are indeed a very small % of people whose symptoms started after a vaccine. Eg C-Support, a semi-government non-profit here in NL says[0] that ~400 of the people they track long covid got it from the vaccine. Out of 39 million jabs, mind - these are tiny (but nonzero!!) likelihoods. This shit shouldn't be political. Saying that the vaccine can or cannot have bad side effects got hijacked as signaling which camp you’re in. This is nuts. Insights can change, and a vaccine can both be effective (ie better on average than the alternative, getting sick without) and harmful at the same time. Maybe its time for both camps, at least on a place like HN, to stop triggering so intensely when people say stuff about covid vaccines that don’t match your priors. [0] https://www.c-support.nu/langdurige-klachten-na-vaccinatie/ https://www.c-support.nu/langdurige-klachten-na-vaccinatie/
- PheonixPharts 4y agoI do agree with you that people are way too quick to politically dismiss criticism and questions surrounding the vaccine. However the logic you're showing here seems very quick to draw the causal connection between vaccines and long covid. I got covid immediately after receiving my first Nintendo Switch for a Christmas present, but most people would consider it absurd to blame the switch for my covid. On a more serious note, my grandmother did die of heart failure very shortly after her covid vaccine. However she was 91 and in poor health. It's not outside the realm of possibility that your wife happened to get covid roughly the same day as she got her vaccine. The claim that "there are indeed a very small % of people whose symptoms started after a vaccine" also covers this possibility unless you can clearly show that the incidence of getting covid among this population is significantly higher than would be expected. It wouldn't surprise me terribly if there was eventually found to be a variety of complications caused by the vaccine which explain many of these things, but I also see people making very quick causal connections between events that seem to have a great many other plausible explanations.
- hanniabu 4y agoFrom my experience with gastro issues, it sounds like covid causes leaky gut and dysbiosis which is leading to a lot of these other issues like brain fog, tiredness, laryngitis, etc. Is there any research looking into this?
- thenerdhead 4y agoThere's a lot of research looking into this. Go search on pubmed. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36639608/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36639608/ There's also a large RECOVER initiative to better understand it. https://directorsblog.nih.gov/2023/03/02/recover-what-clinical-research-comes-next-for-helping-people-with-long-covid/ https://directorsblog.nih.gov/2023/03/02/recover-what-clinic...
- CamperBob2 4y ago"Go search on pubmed" isn't the argument-winning strategy it used to be. They will sanction any sort of quackery that anyone comes up with. Not saying you're wrong or that I disagree, just that PubMed citations aren't a useful way to prove anything.
- thenerdhead 4y agoYour bias is showing in this comment. I was just trying to be helpful. I have no agenda here. There’s plenty of articles indexed on pubmed about long Covid and GI issues.
- lamontcg 4y ago> They will sanction any sort of quackery... pubmed doesn't 'sanction' anything. it just a database of published articles.
- CamperBob2 4y agoBy including an article in their database and linking to it from a .gov website, they most certainly are giving it a stamp of approval in the eyes of the public. Sure, that's like saying that Google approves of a given page just because they pull it up in response to a search query. But that goes back to my original point: no intelligent person (or true Scotsman) would back up their argument by saying "Go search Google" and leave it at that. A hypothetical https://www.google.gov https://www.google.gov would be held to very different standards than Google is today. I'd like to say the same about PubMed, but can't.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tpmx 4y agoOne of my fav youtubers; Physicsgirl (Dianna Cowern) is currently completely out of action due to long covid. She was young and healthy when she was hit with this. This is scary.
- anamexis 4y agoIt's hard to overstate how "out of action" she is. She hasn't been out of bed in months except to go to the hospital, and can barely speak.
- andyjohnson0 4y agoUpdate from early March presented by her friend Simone Giertz: https://youtu.be/vydgkCCXbTA https://youtu.be/vydgkCCXbTA Really awful situation.
- Invictus0 4y agoFor all the people in this comment section saying long covid is fake, please watch the video the other commenter posted and ask yourself: Why would Dianna fake this? Why would she fake being on a ventilator for 14 months in the prime of her life? Why would she fake being unable to move, think, talk, read?
- josephcsible 4y agoFalse dichotomy. The only possibilities aren't "Dianna is faking being ill" or "Dianna really has long COVID". There's also "Dianna really is seriously ill but not with long COVID".
- tpmx 4y agoNo true Scotsman would...
- skrebbel 4y agoThis is an uninteresting argument. COVID happened, and suddenly way more people than before reported these kinds of symptoms. You can make this argument in any individual case, sure, but on the macro level, your argument becomes that either somehow lots of people got chronic fatigue syndrome (and similar) all at the same time, or lots of people are suddenly faking it all at the same time, or long COVID is real. I mean yes, mass hysteria does exist, culturally-bound mental disorders also exist, but the most obvious explanation of these facts is that yes, long COVID is a thing.
- bugglebeetle 4y agoCue Long COVID being being disqualified as a disability, just like the pandemic “ended.”
- hezralig 4y agoI believe that this is exactly what will happen. There are so many doctors currently treating it as a somatic condition in spite of published evidence that COVID leaves a lasting mark on every organs with an ACE2 receptor. My MIL has recovered about 70% from a bout of LC and was directed multiple times to exercise at a time that it was known that exercise would actually make her condition worse. It doesn't help that the majority of these cases affect women, who have historically not been taken as serious as patients in the health field when it comes to MS/CFS.
- jinpa_zangpo 4y agoThe number of applications for disability payments from Social Security has declined every year since Covid began. https://www.ssa.gov/OACT/STATS/dibStat.html https://www.ssa.gov/OACT/STATS/dibStat.html
- ben_w 4y agoHow do those payments work? Are you allowed them if you're also working? Separate question: I vaguely remember that everything else made COVID more likely to kill, so how many people already on disability were killed, proportionately speaking?
- hezralig 4y agoDid you know there is a reduction in staffing for the SSA office and that creating an application is becoming more difficult? Also, applications are routinely denied upon first submission and then worked on as an appeal that can span years. Ask me how I know, I have been assisting a friend with a disability (not COVID related) to get assistance for over a year now. So either there are applications still being processed, in appeal, or people are frankly struggling to navigate the submission process, especially with fewer SSA employees to get assistance from.
- aaomidi 4y agoBased on how the rules for disability goes, this isn’t surprising at all.
- lucabs 4y ago[dead]