3 ms·
I don't think a "filament" would work. To obtain the efficiency gains, the device needs to reflect most of the IR photons back onto the hot emitter, which woul
by nine_k 4y ago
I don't think a "filament" would work.
To obtain the efficiency gains, the device needs to reflect most of the IR photons back onto the hot emitter, which would be a filament in a regular incandescent lamp. But the filament's cross section is small compared to lamp's. If an IR photon must reflect 1000 times before hitting the filament (very optimistic!), and the reflector reflects 99.9% of the IR photons back inside, only about 37% of the IR photons will hit the filament. And at that they only have about 5-10% chance to be re-emitted as visible light, depending on the temperature.
So, for the economy of the photons to work, a large black glowing ball would be needed; any photons inside it would be recycled, and it would readily absorb most of the photons returned to its outer surface by the miraculous IR reflector.
Thermal losses would still be pretty noticeable because argon can't have too low pressure, else it won't prevent the evaporation of the emitter. The device would run pretty hot, which is a source of inefficiency.
I don't know whether it would be more efficient than the large and very hot arc lamps [1] which illuminate stadiums or even large shopping centers, with electrical efficiency above 50%.
[1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-intensity_discharge_lamp https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-intensity_discharge_lam...
- Etheryte 4y agoThey built one and it recycles 92% of the IR radiation, what do you mean?
- nine_k 4y agoI only mean that the suggested use of a filament in a comment above mine won't work. The lamp won't look like a regular incandescent lamp.
- Etheryte 4y agoI see, sorry for the confusion.
- SideburnsOfDoom 4y ago> suggested use of a filament in a comment above mine won't work Perhaps the "comment above yours" has been edited, but the first mention of the word "filament" is in your comment. Does the current wording meet with your approval?
- nine_k 4y agoDefinitely :)
- adrian_b 4y agoYou are right, but the authors are not fools, so they do not use a filament. The incandescent part has the form of a rectangular tape, with the front side made of black carbon (nanotubes deposited by CVD) and the back side made of white boron nitride, so that most of the radiation is directed towards the front, i.e. towards the exit window, to minimize the heating of the enclosure (which is made of white alumina, to minimize the absorption of the radiation that does not go out through the window). If the alumina enclosure gets hot, the efficiency can be further increased by reducing the heat loss with an extra surrounding layer of thermal insulator (which could be provided by a plastic or ceramic socket). Increasing the efficiency up to the ultimate limit imposed by the human vision may become too expensive to be worthwhile, but there is no other obstacle except cost, unlike for the current LED lamps with fluorescent phosphors. I have never heard of any arc lamp that has any chance of even remotely approaching a 50% efficiency, when counting only the useful light. Otherwise, even an archaic incandescent lamp can approach an 100% electrical-to-light efficiency, but almost all of the light output is in the form of useless infrared light. Besides using an incandescent emitter with a lossless optical filter, the only other way to approach the ultimate efficiency for lighting (with a good color rendering) would be with a lamp including at least 4 LEDs or laser diodes of different colors. The latter solution is much more expensive, requires electronics for compensating the change in time of the color temperature and it is currently limited by the lack of semiconductor emitters with high efficiency for yellow and green light.
- nicoburns 4y agoWhat makes you think this technology is inherently capable of scaling it's efficiency better than the phosphors that shift the frequencies in LED lights?
- adrian_b 4y agoThe frequency shift that you mention reduces the efficiency by a factor equal with the ratio of the frequencies. When making green light out of blue light the efficiency cannot exceed about 83% and when making red light out of blue light the efficiency cannot exceed about 70%. Real efficiencies of the fluorescent conversion are much less. Moreover, there is no hard limit for improving the efficiency of an incandescent light emitter with better infrared filters and better thermal insulation. Therefore, when the comparison is made for a great enough frequency bandwidth, the efficiency of an incandescent light emitter coupled with a lossless optical filter should be able to exceed even the efficiency of a LED without fluorescent phosphor. The best colored LEDs can reach an efficiency of 70%, but only at very low output power densities. When the output power density is increased, to reduce the cost of a LED lamp by using a smaller LED, the efficiency drops a lot, to levels that should not be hard to exceed with a filtered incandescent lamp. The LEDs and the laser diodes are unbeatable in efficiency when it is desired to produce light within a narrow frequency band, which is not the case for lighting applications.