6 ms·
TLDR: This paper demonstrates quite convincingly (because the descriptions are very detailed) that the ancient Edison light bulb (i.e. with light emitted by in
by adrian_b 4y ago
TLDR:
This paper demonstrates quite convincingly (because the descriptions are very detailed) that the ancient Edison light bulb (i.e. with light emitted by incandescent carbon) can be revived by using modern technologies in a form that can be better than the current LED lamps.
The first incandescent lamps had 2 disadvantages, short lifetime and low efficiency.
The evaporation and oxidation of the incandescent carbon can be avoided by a structure made of carbon nanotubes that works in argon. The claimed lifetime (based on accelerated aging tests) is as good as for LEDs.
The low efficiency is solved by using a lossless optical filter (i.e. one that transmits the visible light and reflects back the infrared light) to prevent the heat loss from the lamp by radiation other than the useful light output.
This method can reach the maximum energy efficiency determined by the human vision characteristics, unlike the current LED lamps, which are unavoidably limited to a value lower than that by the losses caused by the fluorescent light conversion.
The design of the lossless optical filter is a difficult optimization problem due to the large number of parameters. Their solution, which is completely described in the paper, is claimed to have been found by a machine-learning algorithm.
- maicro 4y agoI'm not going to read the paper to check your work, but excellent TLDR - thanks X)
- muser8 4y agoFantastic summary! I wonder if the economics will make enough sense to overcome entrenched interests and the legislation backing them. It be great to have efficient incandescent light and put the failed promises of LED longevity behind us.
- tasty_freeze 4y agoAs far as I know, there isn't a law banning incandescent lamps. The law stated that such lighting needs to achieve a certain level of efficiency or greater, which in effect banned existing 1% efficient incandescent lights. > It be great to have efficient incandescent light and put the failed promises of LED longevity behind us. In my experience, the main failure mode of LED bulbs is the power supply -- they engineer every penny out of them even at the cost of reliability. Second, nearly all bulbs are dimmable, which complicates the power supply, because customers faced with dimmable vs non-dimmable will pick the dimmable one. Another factor is if you read those claims about 20 year lifetimes and such, often there is a footnote saying something like "assuming it is on for 3 hours a day or less". Finally, you are assuming that this new technology won't suffer the same fate as the LED bulbs. If they take off, they will be cost reduced at the expense of longevity. I saw the same thing happen in the era of floppy disks -- over time the price was reduced by a factor of 20 but reliability went down in parallel.
- kurthr 4y agoIt's the pure penny pinching form of Muntzing (just cutting parts out to see what still works). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muntzing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muntzing There seem to be two dominant pop commercial successes, those where brand means everything and cost is increased well beyond any utility to signal wealth, and brand AND reliability mean nothing (because like your mattress it'll be a few years later anyway) which is just a race to the bottom.
- elihu 4y agoMy heuristic is to just buy LEDs made by Phillips or GE, since invariably any generic or store-brand LED I've tried seems to lack rectification and/or filtering and stobes at 60 or 120 hz. I haven't tried any fancy/expensive "smart" programmable bulbs, but plain ones I do get seem pretty reasonably priced.
- Spooky23 4y agoI have a 60w Phillips Endura LED bulb that has been continuously lit since about 2014. Quality parts last.
- leobg 4y agoIt’s an aptly named product then. Quite rare these days.
- Spooky23 4y agoIIRC, it was a product designed for a huge Federal RFP. So it was built to meet a meaningful standard. The facilities guys at my former employer were very excited about it as they did an LED pilot previously that didnt go well.
- Maursault 4y agoUndoubtedly it is not producing the same color spectrum as new, as phosphors fade over time, its blue spike is getting wider and taller, so it is always producing more and more blue light, slowly permanently blinding you while disrupting your circadian rhythms, increasing your chances of having diabetes and heart disease, and taking years off your life. But at least you saved a buck.
- orbital-decay 4y ago> the failed promises of LED longevity LEDs last remarkably long if used correctly. You can make a light that will easily last thousands/dozens of thousands of hours. What doesn't last is a typical LED lightbulb for legacy sockets, because of the planned obsolescence/race to the bottom, and because it's a complete device (power supply, heatsink etc) which is far too powerful for its form-factor. Not sure what of that you expect to change.
- Maursault 4y agoLED phosphors begin to fade immediately. Within dozens of hours of use it will produce noticeably different light, getting bluer and bluer over time.
- neilfrndes 4y agoCheck out Dubai Lamps: https://hackaday.com/2021/01/17/leds-from-dubai-the-royal-lights-you-cant-buy/ https://hackaday.com/2021/01/17/leds-from-dubai-the-royal-li... > Dubai Lamps are special LED lamps designed by Philips for high efficiency and very long operational life. A simple design change reduces stress and excess heat that otherwise significantly lowers the mean time before failure of regular LED lamps
- UncleOxidant 4y agoI don't see any discussion of manufacturing costs, anything here that might be more expensive than current LED lighting?
- adrian_b 4y agoWith a bulb made of alumina and having a window made of quartz on which thin films have been deposited, it would be more expensive than a traditional incandescent lamp, but that would be compensated by the high efficiency and long life. If in mass production, I see nothing that would prevent it from being cheaper than a comparable LED lamp. I am not familiar with the technology used to make the incandescent band made of carbon nanotubes and boron nitride ceramic, but everything else is made with standard equipment that is widely available.
- fbdab103 4y agoCould it be made with a plastic and not glass exterior? One minor benefit I have enjoyed about the transition to LEDs is that they are physically more sturdy and will survive being dropped.
- adrian_b 4y agoThe alumina cannot be replaced with plastic for 2 reasons. It must be hermetic, to keep the argon inside and the air outside, for the lifetime of the bulb. It contributes to the high efficiency, by reflecting both the visible and the infrared light and preventing thus the heat loss from the lamp. Nonetheless, alumina is less fragile than ordinary glass. It might be possible to replace the quartz window with some kind of glass window, for a lower cost, but not with any kind of plastic, because it must also be hermetic and it must be usable as a substrate for thin film deposition in vacuum and it should have a coefficient of thermal expansion matched to those of the multiple layers of the infrared-reflecting filter.
- scythe 4y ago>With a bulb made of alumina I didn't mention this in my other comment because I thought the use of alumina could be avoided, but I suggest you look up the price of some optical sapphire (ie transparent alumina) before you get excited about that. Even for a tiny, flat circle you're looking at around ten bucks. A bulb would likely be harder. https://www.uqgoptics.com/catalogue/optical-windows/sapphire/sapphire-windows-plates-random-orientation/ https://www.uqgoptics.com/catalogue/optical-windows/sapphire...
- zubiaur 4y agoThis seems similar to HIR technology, widely available on car headlamps: “The HIR1 (9011) and HIR2 (9012) Halogen Infrared Reflective bulbs have micro-thin layers of electro-deposited coating on a specially-designed bulb. The coating reflects the filament's infrared (heat) back onto the filament, which results in a hotter filament that produces more light without increased power consumption, shorter bulb life, or extra heat production.“
- adrian_b 4y agoThe principle is the same, but here a much more sophisticated implementation is shown, which is able to achieve better performances than the LED lamps.
- narrator 4y agoCarbon nanotubes are about as toxic as asbestos. So unless you're making that bulb for somewhere that's absurdly hard to change, it's probably a bad idea.
- Accujack 4y agoAsbestos isn't toxic at all unless the fibers are airborne. Unless you disturb the nano tubes in the device in such a way that they become airborne, they're safe. Probably they're less dangerous than the mercury in the CFL tubes.
- RedShift1 4y agoInevitably this stuff is going to end up in landfills, oceans, ... What if it's ingested?
- aappleby 4y agoCarbon nanotubes are flammable.
- shrx 4y agoThe amount of nanotubes in a light bulb filament is measured in milligrams. There is a bigger fire hazard from the lint accumulated in your bellybutton.
- MayeulC 4y agoIt just means they are quite easy to get rid of in practice, and likely to be disposed of "naturally" eventually, unlike other substances.
- Etrnl_President 4y agoReplace Tungsten with Osmium for longer lifespan, and operate at lower voltage.
- milleramp 4y agoThe optical filter is critical to the design, and big curiosity to me. Normal dielectric filters have a large angle dependence. Of course and It’s solved by machine-learning, I am hopeful but skeptical. Need to dig further into this.
- nine_k 4y agoI don't think a "filament" would work. To obtain the efficiency gains, the device needs to reflect most of the IR photons back onto the hot emitter, which would be a filament in a regular incandescent lamp. But the filament's cross section is small compared to lamp's. If an IR photon must reflect 1000 times before hitting the filament (very optimistic!), and the reflector reflects 99.9% of the IR photons back inside, only about 37% of the IR photons will hit the filament. And at that they only have about 5-10% chance to be re-emitted as visible light, depending on the temperature. So, for the economy of the photons to work, a large black glowing ball would be needed; any photons inside it would be recycled, and it would readily absorb most of the photons returned to its outer surface by the miraculous IR reflector. Thermal losses would still be pretty noticeable because argon can't have too low pressure, else it won't prevent the evaporation of the emitter. The device would run pretty hot, which is a source of inefficiency. I don't know whether it would be more efficient than the large and very hot arc lamps [1] which illuminate stadiums or even large shopping centers, with electrical efficiency above 50%. [1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-intensity_discharge_lamp https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-intensity_discharge_lam...
- Etheryte 4y agoThey built one and it recycles 92% of the IR radiation, what do you mean?
- nine_k 4y agoI only mean that the suggested use of a filament in a comment above mine won't work. The lamp won't look like a regular incandescent lamp.
- Etheryte 4y agoI see, sorry for the confusion.
- SideburnsOfDoom 4y ago> suggested use of a filament in a comment above mine won't work Perhaps the "comment above yours" has been edited, but the first mention of the word "filament" is in your comment. Does the current wording meet with your approval?
- Gordonjcp 4y agoIs the efficiency of an incandescent lamp really a problem though? If your power comes from renewable sources then over its entire lifespan an incandescent bulb has to be way cleaner than an LED. In general something that's a coil of wire in a glass bottle with the air sucked out that you could reasonably make in a blacksmith's forge is going to be less environmentally horrible than a hundred grams of plastic, fibreglass, epoxy, copper, tin, bismuth, gallium arsenide, phosphorus and so on that has to be put together in a multi-billion-dollar factory.
- adrian_b 4y agoThe difference in efficiency is too high to not matter. In the past, I had used for the lighting of my house various combinations of 100-W incandescent lamps. When better technologies have appeared, I have substituted them with other lamps having an 1500-lumen light output, which is slightly more than provided by the 100-W incandescent lamps. With compact fluorescent lamps, I have used 22-W lamps, while during the last decade I have been using 13-W LED lamps (with 1500 lumen at a pleasant 4000 K color temperature, i.e. only slightly warm, not noticeably yellow, like the lamps with a color temperature of 3000 K or less). Even the early prototype described in the research paper can achieve 1500 lumen at 8.7 W. The difference between 100 W and 8.7 W is too large to ignore. In my case, both transitions, to CFL, then to LED, have been extremely visible in my monthly bills.
- Gordonjcp 4y agoOkay, but leaving aside the bills, how much damage do those LEDs cause to the environment? Consider that electricity mostly comes from renewables now, it just doesn't matter what the efficiency is.
- nicoburns 4y ago> Consider that electricity mostly comes from renewables now That isn't remotely true yet. And while renewables are much better for the environment than other energy sources, they're still a lot worse than not using that energy in the first place.
- mike_hock 4y ago> useful light output Part of what makes LEDs and neon lights feel so fake and sterile is that they give off visible light but no perceptible heat. You can feel the heat from a 100W light bulb on your skin and you pick up on that subconsciously. That being said, getting an even spectrum back would be a nice "improvement" (regression fix).
- db48x 4y agoPersonally I’ve always disliked feeling the heat of an incandescent lamp. And I’m fairly certain that one of the advantages of electric lighting over gas was the _reduction_ in heat produced while lighting the room.
- mike_hock 4y agoAnd objectively this is again an advantage with LEDs. Yet, we still light candles today.
- db48x 4y agoSpeak for yourself, I don’t like candles for the same reason that I don’t like incandescent lights. Not to mention the smoke, the wax guttering and dripping everywhere, the fire hazards, etc, etc.
- MengerSponge 4y agoI bet you've just learned to associate the continuous spectrum from incandescent bulbs with the heat they also emit. Have you ever been in a space illuminated by sun tubes or skylights? Did that light feel fake and/or sterile?
- mike_hock 4y agoThat's the whole point. It's a learned combination of stimuli that (now, having learned them) belong together.
- itronitron 4y agoIt's like a wood stove, but for light.