3 ms·
SmartTVs have had an interpreted frame rate mode for a long long time now. Die hards HATE HATE HATE it.
by dylan604 4y ago
SmartTVs have had an interpreted frame rate mode for a long long time now. Die hards HATE HATE HATE it.
- 0x457 4y agoAre you sure you're not confusing inserted generated frames to "we do some annoying things that, we think, make our 60Hz TV look like a 240Hz TV"? Those things are incomparable.
- dylan604 4y agoeither way, you are showing something to the viewer that is not part of the original image. whether that is the result of some AI's hallucination into what it thinks is there or some frame duplication/blending, it all means you've made up stuff that didn't exist to trick the mind into thinking it does.
- 0x457 4y agoYes, but one is significantly better than the other. I don't mind a bunch of if statements inserting frames in most cases, but manufacturers can shove their "Effective Refresh Rate" you know where.
- oofbey 4y agoDiehards also think vinyl sounds better than CD, or at least many used to. (You know, because CD's are digital, which limits their dynamic range and frequency, whereas analog can be "perfect" in theory if you don't think too hard about it.) Some people are just allergic to anything that "improves quality". The reason these technologies exist is because _most people_ think it does improve quality. Haters gonna hate.
- blangk 4y agoWriting off subjective assessments of modes of art as 'haters' seems like something a true hater might do. If you admit there is a qualitative difference then it seems obvious there would be mixed opinions about the different modes. Latest isn't always greatest.
- ShadowBanThis01 4y agoPlenty of wrong here. "CD's are digital, which limits their dynamic range" No. In fact, some CD players used to come with discs intended to demonstrate the huge dynamic range of discs. My Sony portable came with Dire Straits' Brothers in Arms, one of the earlier full-digital releases; it was noted for its dynamic range. Also, fake frames inserted into material shot at a lower frame rate can't "improve" quality. It's a gimmick. SHOOTING at a higher frame rate? Sure, that improves motion quality. On a side note: Almost all the popular music you hear today on streaming services and on "remastered" albums has been destroyed with dynamic compression to make it "louder." Many engineers cite the early '90s as the peak of mastering quality. So don't act as though people objecting to "new" things are automatically wrong.
- seabass-labrax 4y agoMy father and I are listening through each CD in my late grandmother's collection. There's lots of truly excellent recordings from the 80s in there, from a time when record labels took the idea of 'digital quality' _really_ seriously. When I buy CDs for myself of my preferred genre of progressive rock, I make a point of searching for non-remastered CD copies (MusicBrainz is useful here), as the remasters inevitably limit the dynamic range. Another symptom of 'industrial disease'!
- ShadowBanThis01 4y agoAbsolutely! Don't get rid of those CDs! The dynamic-compression problem is so severe, widespread, and yet under-recognized that I don't think music will ever recover. I have 45s from the '80s that sound way better than "remastered" digital releases today. And that has nothing to do with "vinyl vs. digital." It's about everyone having access to devices capable of incredible fidelity today, and nothing but ruined trash to play on them.
- dylan604 4y agolet's face it, there is a very large amount of music consumed on nothing more than earbud level of speaker. so large, that if they make it sound good on those and not so good on larger speaker systems, most people wouldn't know. that leaves a small number of very vocal people to bitch about it. however, these are the same people that believe you have to have gold plated cabling and all the other nonsense that audiophiles believe. so, if you mix for something that keeps >90% of people from bitching while cashing in all of those $9/month subscription fees, then sounds like a pretty decent bizplan. even "room" sound is nothing but bookshelf sized speakers. i miss my towers with a 12"-18" sub, a 8"-10" mid, and a 1"-2" tweeter. i cried a bit having to get rid of those.
- ShadowBanThis01 4y agoThey hate it because it looks like shit. I'm not against higher frame rates; I saw the Hobbit in 3-D 48 FPS and it was the coolest movie-going experience I've had. But FAKE frames? Trash.
- beebeepka 4y agoCertain company is trying to normalize interpolated frames in games which makes even less sense as it introduces latency but latency is like the main reason to want high frame rate in the first place. Almost exactly the same as SLI/crossfire. More frames overall but they come so late...
- ProfessorLayton 4y agoNot all games require super low latency. My TV's frame interpolation is pretty damn useful for certain Switch games that struggle to hit 30fps consistently. Breath of the Wild, while gorgeous, benefits quite a lot with smoothing turned on. However, a game like Smash Bros would be unplayable with the extra latency.