4 ms·
A photon-recycling incandescent lighting device
- hammyhavoc 4y agoLateral thinking through withered technology prevails.
- philipkglass 4y agoThat's remarkable. I was afraid this was going to be a pure theory/simulation paper, but they built an incandescent light source that selectively recycles infrared photons back to the hot emitter, thereby dramatically improving the luminous efficacy. It's a white light source that produces a continuous spectrum in the visible range, like other incandescent light bulbs, but has efficiency comparable to LED lighting.
- adrian_b 4y agoTLDR: This paper demonstrates quite convincingly (because the descriptions are very detailed) that the ancient Edison light bulb (i.e. with light emitted by incandescent carbon) can be revived by using modern technologies in a form that can be better than the current LED lamps. The first incandescent lamps had 2 disadvantages, short lifetime and low efficiency. The evaporation and oxidation of the incandescent carbon can be avoided by a structure made of carbon nanotubes that works in argon. The claimed lifetime (based on accelerated aging tests) is as good as for LEDs. The low efficiency is solved by using a lossless optical filter (i.e. one that transmits the visible light and reflects back the infrared light) to prevent the heat loss from the lamp by radiation other than the useful light output. This method can reach the maximum energy efficiency determined by the human vision characteristics, unlike the current LED lamps, which are unavoidably limited to a value lower than that by the losses caused by the fluorescent light conversion. The design of the lossless optical filter is a difficult optimization problem due to the large number of parameters. Their solution, which is completely described in the paper, is claimed to have been found by a machine-learning algorithm.
- maicro 4y agoI'm not going to read the paper to check your work, but excellent TLDR - thanks X)
- muser8 4y agoFantastic summary! I wonder if the economics will make enough sense to overcome entrenched interests and the legislation backing them. It be great to have efficient incandescent light and put the failed promises of LED longevity behind us.
- tasty_freeze 4y agoAs far as I know, there isn't a law banning incandescent lamps. The law stated that such lighting needs to achieve a certain level of efficiency or greater, which in effect banned existing 1% efficient incandescent lights. > It be great to have efficient incandescent light and put the failed promises of LED longevity behind us. In my experience, the main failure mode of LED bulbs is the power supply -- they engineer every penny out of them even at the cost of reliability. Second, nearly all bulbs are dimmable, which complicates the power supply, because customers faced with dimmable vs non-dimmable will pick the dimmable one. Another factor is if you read those claims about 20 year lifetimes and such, often there is a footnote saying something like "assuming it is on for 3 hours a day or less". Finally, you are assuming that this new technology won't suffer the same fate as the LED bulbs. If they take off, they will be cost reduced at the expense of longevity. I saw the same thing happen in the era of floppy disks -- over time the price was reduced by a factor of 20 but reliability went down in parallel.
- kurthr 4y agoIt's the pure penny pinching form of Muntzing (just cutting parts out to see what still works). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muntzing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muntzing There seem to be two dominant pop commercial successes, those where brand means everything and cost is increased well beyond any utility to signal wealth, and brand AND reliability mean nothing (because like your mattress it'll be a few years later anyway) which is just a race to the bottom.
- dexzod 4y agoThe short lifetime of incandescent bulbs was by design https://spectrum.ieee.org/the-great-lightbulb-conspiracy https://spectrum.ieee.org/the-great-lightbulb-conspiracy. Otherwise they can last pretty long. This one is on since 1901 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centennial_Light https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centennial_Light
- philipkglass 4y agoRunning the filaments hotter makes the bulb more efficient but also shortens the lifespan due to faster filament evaporation. You could get very long life by under-powering the bulb but then the low efficiency of incandescent lighting would go lower. That's the other remarkable thing about this paper. They use a ceramic instead of tungsten as the hot emitter, and calculate that it should have a very long lifetime.
- hashmash 4y agoThe Centennial Light produces very little light and isn't very practical. https://www.urbo.com/content/the-lightbulb-conspiracy-shining-light-on-planned-obsolescence/ https://www.urbo.com/content/the-lightbulb-conspiracy-shinin...
- Syonyk 4y agoIt's really more "by physics." You can pick how you want to run a tungsten filament and end up with either a long life bulb, or a high(er) efficiency bulb, but not both. The ~1000 hour goal was, at the time, an attempt to optimize the total cost of lighting - bulb and power combined. As your bulb lasts longer, you get rather fewer lumens per watt. A typical 1000 hour rated 60W incandescent (an old one, not the new halogen "efficient" ones - 28% less power for 28% less light) will put out around 850 lumens. I have a 20k hour rated bulb with the same output - but it pulls 75W. Over the lifetime of the bulb, that increased power use is quite a bit more expensive than replacing bulbs would be - but they're designed for places that are harder to access, or that are high vibration (typically, long life incandescents also have more supports, so they work better in higher vibration environments). There's no magical tungsten filament, 60W, 850 lumen bulb that will last 10k+ hours. It's simply not possible within the normal constraints. This new tech, though... I'm very excited by it!
- npunt 4y agoThis uses carbon nanotubes, which can have asbestos-like effects on the lungs. Nanotubes are great for tons of applications, but especially those where safe disposal procedures are possible. If these are a replacement for LEDs with better properties, these would be widely deployed in everything from lighting to devices. I wonder whether at that scale this presents a safety challenge, given the probability of breaking and the way people dispose things. The glass substrate does hold them in place, but what happens when the glass breaks in all the myriad ways it can in real life?
- zakki 4y agoI am just excited as others when reading the TLDR comment. But this warning made me think of do I still want it? Is there anything in the paper explaining about the safety of nano carbon they use?
- jiggawatts 4y agoWhen there's articles about Gallium arsenide (GaAs) semiconductors, you get the same comments. "Arsenic is a poison!" Yes, we know. Are you cracking the chips open an licking the semiconductor wafers inside for their flavour? No? Then you have nothing to worry about. This is the same category of thing. There's micrograms of carbon nanotubes in these lights as a thin-film inside a very strong ceramic casing. Unless you're smashing the thing open and then scraping the surface so you can snort it with a straw like it's cocaine, you'll be fine.
- throwaway8503 4y agoPurely as a matter of esoteric interest, does anyone know of any affordable photon counting devices?
- CyberDildonics 4y agoDo you mean a camera?
- throwaway8503 4y agoIf there's a way to get an integer value on the number of photons per cell in a camera sensor, let me know
- milleramp 4y agoNo but there is a way to get integer values for the photo-electrons per pixel.
- throwaway8503 4y agoI suppose there would be a rough conversion between that value and photon count (at some wavelength range). I just imagine the error bars to be very wide.
- tigershark 4y agoNot really, it depends from the application. Even something like 20 years ago the CCDs available at the time were capable of astrometric measure of star magnitudes with 1/100 of magnitude precision using some control stars.
- CyberDildonics 4y agoYou realize that light is actually electromagnetic radiation and there is no such thing as a physical photon right?
- strangeloops85 4y agoThis basic idea was demonstrated by some groups at MIT in 2016: https://www.nature.com/articles/nnano.2015.309 https://www.nature.com/articles/nnano.2015.309 MIT news article about it: https://news.mit.edu/2016/nanophotonic-incandescent-light-bulbs-0111 https://news.mit.edu/2016/nanophotonic-incandescent-light-bu... I think this paper follows the same basic principle and idea.
- adrian_b 4y agoThe MIT article is cited in this research paper and it is likely that it has been the one which inspired the start of this research. However the progress made from the very primitive device described by MIT and the high-performance prototype made by the Chinese team has been huge. The Chinese have used completely other materials, which enabled also a long lifetime, not only a better efficiency. There are many new constructive details which contribute to an increased efficiency. The design methodology used by the Chinese for the lossless optical filter is far more advanced and it enabled a much better filter with much less layers. The MIT article showed an interesting idea, for which it was not clear if it can be successful in practice, while this shows a real device that needs only minor changes in order to become suitable for mass production (e.g. the replacement of HfO2 with TiO2 in the window coating and the replacement of the O-ring used in the prototype with hermetic glass-alumina bonding). This device could be easily converted into a commercial product in a couple of years.
- jiggawatts 4y agoA yardstick that I like to use for the exponentially increasing pace of technological advancement is the transition from one lighting technology to the next. Wood fires were the only lighting we could muster for a few hundred thousand years. Wick-based lighting like candles and oil lamps for a few thousand. Incandescent electric lighting started about 150 years ago. Fluorescent lighting about 70 years ago. CFL lighting about 30 years ago. LED lighting about 15 years ago. OLED lighting about 7 years ago. There's talk now of direct EL nano-rod lighting, this photon recycling thing, and more. We'll reach a point where new lighting technology is developed faster than the previous lights reach their end-of-life!