3 ms·
James Cameron and Peter Jackson were pushing high frame rate but critics absolutely hate it so I don't think it's going to happen.
by wmf 4y ago
James Cameron and Peter Jackson were pushing high frame rate but critics absolutely hate it so I don't think it's going to happen.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ShadowBanThis01 4y agoJames Cameron's usage of it was gravely flawed because he arbitrarily kept switching back and forth between 24 and 48 FPS from one shot to another in Avatar 2. There's absolutely no discernible pattern or motivation for the changes. WTF. I wish 48 FPS were adopted widely so we could all just get used to it, because it simply and undeniably renders motion better.
- christoph 4y agoSame to some extent with IMAX Blu-rays. It drives me mad when certain “blockbuster” IMAX disks shift aspect and film stock so quickly, just because… let’s use “IMAX” for some shots... It totally breaks the feel and flow of a movie for me when black bars and film grain suddenly start shifting about and changing. Either film and release it all in IMAX or don’t bother IMO.
- dylan604 4y agoThis is what the Dark Knight does. The majority of the film is in whatever wide aspect ratio, but then for the "epic" IMAX shots the aspect ratio switched to a much more square aspect ratio. It was very noticeable in the theater when I saw it way back when.
- seabass-labrax 4y agoI haven't seen Avatar 2, but this or something similar is something I notice all the time in films on DVDs, especially those originally for TV: the camera will cut to a long shot and everything becomes weirdly smooth until the camera cuts back again. Whether it's due to a change in film speed, frame rate or something else I can't work out, but I would imagine that these long distance shots are in fact library footage spliced into the film.
- christoph 4y agoI think because while visually and technically better in the right hands (with multi hundred million $ budgets), it will almost always end up looking like a cheap soap opera in lesser hands - every imperfection in makeup, set and lighting becomes immediately obvious to even an uncritical eye. It’s kind of similar to an uncanny valley situation in VR, side note: I think ultimately AI on its current trajectory will finally push forwards and make VR accepted and feasible for entertainment in a multitude of ways... For 4K or 8k HFR HDR live filming, you have to raise all your general production values by a really crazy amount for it not to look cheap and naff. Forget additional storage and transmission costs of the extra data, the actual day to day increases in production costs (and timelines) rapidly scales far beyond those, making such trivial things like storage a mere rounding error. Case in point - the most watched UK soap opera “Eastenders” saw the BBC go way over budget and spend £90m+ over many years just rebuilding all of their iconic sets so they could finally film it in basic HD. HFR 4K HDR would require an even bigger and more serious upgrade across the entire production, and a long term commitment to those bigger budgets, which the BBC have clearly decided is totally not feasible and also not worthwhile for a 3-4 times a week half hour soap opera. It won’t happen for most things because HD and certainly 4K is more than good enough for most normal people to enjoy video media on a screen up to around 100”’s at a sensible seating distance… So most entertainment can be done at a much lower cost and with way lower risk. The benefits just don’t and probably never will outweigh those factors.
- readbeard 4y ago2k is enough for most cinema purposes. https://www.yedlin.net/ResDemo/index.html https://www.yedlin.net/ResDemo/index.html I do think 8K will make a big difference for VR though due to the extreme angle of view.