4 ms·
I don't understand. "Synthetic intelligence" is just a synonym for "artificial intelligence". The term has all the same issues, does it not?
by JohnFen 4y ago
I don't understand. "Synthetic intelligence" is just a synonym for "artificial intelligence". The term has all the same issues, does it not?
- ftxbro 4y ago> The term has all the same issues, does it not? It could be useful for a similar reason as the euphemism treadmill. We could leave behind all of the misguided assumptions about AI with the old 'artificial intelligence' nomenclature and move forward with 'synthetic intelligence' which has our new understanding of what systems like GPT-4 can do.
- JohnFen 4y agoI'm thinking the problematic part of the term isn't the "artificial" part, but the "intelligence" part. Since nobody actually knows what "intelligence" is, the word will mean to people whatever they want it to mean.
- nwienert 4y agoI’m partial to Plausible Regurgitation
- fasterik 4y ago>Since nobody actually knows what "intelligence" is Everybody knows what intelligence is. Even if we can't agree on a precise definition, it's pretty obvious that it's the thing that humans and other animals do that involves learning, reasoning, planning, and problem solving. We can also agree that being successful at certain tasks constitutes intelligence. Solving a math problem is intelligence. Writing a poem is intelligence.
- pixl97 4y ago>Everybody knows what intelligence is Much like... "Everyone knows what porn is" "Everyone knows who god is" "Everyone knows what beauty is" The devil is in the details and rather generic words that describe a gradient can never capture the exact nature of what we're trying to define in specific situations.
- fasterik 4y agoYou can never capture the exact nature of anything outside of logic and math. That's too high of a bar. Philosophers who have worked on this problem like Wittgenstein talk about concepts in terms of family resemblances, not exact definitions. If I'm trying to understand whether a system is intelligent, I don't need a logical proof. I learn whether it is intelligent by testing whether it can successfully do many of the same things that other intelligent systems do.
- JohnFen 4y agoBut words are meant to convey meaning to other people, so what the word means to others is more important than what it means to you. This sort of problem is common with language, and is a great example of why I'm not really on board with using natural language for technical things.
- fasterik 4y ago>But words are meant to convey meaning to other people, so what the word means to others is more important than what it means to you. I pretty much agree with that, so I'm not sure where the disagreement is here. Let me go back to the original statement I was responding to. >Since nobody actually knows what "intelligence" is, the word will mean to people whatever they want it to mean. If I tell you someone is intelligent, you roughly know what I am talking about. Just because it's hard to formalize that doesn't mean that that the word can mean whatever people want it to mean. For example, if I tell you my friend is intelligent, you would be wrong to interpret that as meaning that my friend has red hair, because hair color is irrelevant to the traits that we normally associate with intelligence. The fact that there are right and wrong ways of interpreting my sentence implies that there is some generally agreed upon notion of what intelligence is, even if that notion is fuzzy and has grey areas.
- JohnFen 4y ago> I'm not sure where the disagreement is here I'm not sure we are disagreeing. I'm just having a discussion. > If I tell you someone is intelligent, you roughly know what I am talking about. Correct, because the context (you're talking about a human, and I know roughly what that means with humans) narrows the possibilities. But even there, it's a vague sort of intuitive knowledge, like trying to say what "art" is. But when it comes to other areas -- such as machines -- context doesn't help narrow the possible meanings. What does saying a machine is "intelligent" mean? If you ask a machine learning person, you'll get a reasonably specific answer. If you ask the average person on the street, you'll get very, very different answers. The reason is because we don't know what "intelligence" actually is. We don't even know, with any specificity, what it is in humans -- which is why psychologists assert that there are multiple kinds of intelligence (even if they disagree about how many there are). > even if that notion is fuzzy and has grey areas. I don't disagree at all. But the notion has more fuzzy and gray areas than solid ones. As an example, when most people imagine an "artificial intelligence", what they're really imagining is "consciousness". Is consciousness required for intelligence? Who knows? The answer to that depends on what you mean by "intelligence" and we don't agree enough on what that means to have that sort of discussion without beginning by defining the terms.
- JohnFen 4y agoI disagree. I think that nobody knows what it is, as demonstrated by the fact that there is such a wide disagreement about what it is. > We can also agree that being successful at certain tasks constitutes intelligence. Solving a math problem is intelligence. Writing a poem is intelligence. As an example, I don't agree that either of those things indicates intelligence all by themselves. We've had programs that nobody would call "intelligent" to do both of those things for decades.
- fasterik 4y ago>We've had programs that nobody would call "intelligent" to do both of those things for decades. So you're right that if I have separate algorithms, each designed for a specific purpose, that those algorithms aren't intelligent. However, if I have a general system that can learn how to solve a math problem, write a poem, and do a bunch of other things that humans can do, then that system is intelligent.
- xmprt 4y agoI think Artificial Intelligence has taken on the meaning that the intelligence is real but just that it's coming from machines. Synthetic intelligence (at least to me) sounds more like we're acknowledging that the machines aren't really intelligent and just simulating intelligence.
- akiselev 4y agoWhy not just eliminate the middle man and call it simulated intelligence? That at least implies that there are different levels of fidelity as quantified by number of parameters and training data set size.
- jonplackett 4y agoThis makes more sense
- DJBunnies 4y agoIf we can’t (and we haven’t) define intelligence, how could we possibly define artificial intelligence or synthetic.
- dougmwne 4y agoActually I agree with them a new name would be helpful. I would propose inorganic intelligence to try to pick a term with less value judgments. AI is really an overloaded term that includes 70 years of snake oil, Skynet, the Singularity and killer robots. I think we need a new name to start fresh. And personally, I think we are extremely biased by our sci-fi to think of this tech as malevolent. As far as we can see, it can only know what we teach it since it relies on all of our perceptions to learn. LLMs seem both extremely promising as a useful tool and very pliant to the operator’s wishes. I’m way beyond “this is a fancy next word predictor” as I think it’s emergent behavior has many of the hallmarks of reasoning and novel inference, but at best I think it is only part of a mind and an unconscious one at that.
- riffraff 4y ago> Let’s forget the term AI. Let’s call them Systematic Approaches to Learning Algorithms and Machine Inferences (SALAMI). https://blog.quintarelli.it/2019/11/lets-forget-the-term-ai-lets-call-them-systematic-approaches-to-learning-algorithms-and-machine-inferences-salami/ https://blog.quintarelli.it/2019/11/lets-forget-the-term-ai-...
- cjbprime 4y ago> it can only know what we teach it since it relies on all of our perceptions to learn > I think it’s emergent behavior has many of the hallmarks of reasoning and novel inference You contradicted yourself here, right?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]