3 ms·
I don't think the concern is about machines doing it better, but machines being able to angleshoot around copyright. The issue is most easily demonstrated in wr
by somenameforme 4y ago
I don't think the concern is about machines doing it better, but machines being able to angleshoot around copyright. The issue is most easily demonstrated in writing. The current state of technology is already sufficient to create a program that could take as input a book and produce as output a book with identical story, characters, settings, and more - but 'nudged around' just enough to skirt current copyright law.
Humans have already been able to do this of course, but the difference is scale and automation. With this software one could, under current law, setup a 100% legal 'shadow library' that effectively infringes on every single book published. Even a leaked copy of a book could be released and shared (in its legally infringing format) before the "real" copy hit the market. And again, all completely legally. The impacts of copyright infringement are regularly grossly distorted, but I think this is the sort of technology that could genuinely damage artists and creators across many endeavors.
The exact same thing will be coming to software soon enough. 'Take this assembly/IL code, and create a functionally identical but superficially rebranded program while working to ensure you sidestep all relevant patents.' 'Sure, here you go.' The issue of this being done [relatively] instantly is going to really impact things in ways I think many are not considering. Never in a million years thought I'd see myself on the side of the copyright cartel, but this is one of the extremely rare times they're right.
- CuriouslyC 4y agoThat shadow library already exists, people write a shit ton of fanfic and publishers publish highly derivative stories specifically because they're basically veiled ripoffs of highly lucrative IP hoping to cash in. The barrier to shadow libraries is marketing, which is the only thing that really separates huge blockbuster music/art/books from stuff that makes literally zero money. Quality and ideas haven't been the gate for a long time.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]