7 ms·
Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by writing book reviews
- AdrianB1 4y agoIn Romania writing books reduced the prison sentences by months, not days. Writing a book is not even hard because there was no problem to get "help" from outside with the content.
- scohesc 4y agoPart of me wonders if some of the prisoners have others write book reports for them. Kind of like an Con(vict)GPT of some sorts. It's a very interesting idea - allows the prisoners that really want to improve and change their lives the opportunity to lower their sentence and get out quicker. Also has the side effect of becoming more educated potentially.
- outworlder 4y ago> Part of me wonders if some of the prisoners have others write book reports for them. Why would someone write a report for others if they could shorten their own sentence instead? Also: > Because the inmates were passionate readers, they were encouraged to write book reviews.
- antibasilisk 4y ago>Why would someone write a report for others if they could shorten their own sentence instead? There are things people might prefer to a shortened sentence, such as money on the outside.
- operatingthetan 4y ago>Why would someone write a report for others if they could shorten their own sentence instead? Isn't this like asking why economies exist?
- hervature 4y agoNot sure why you're getting downvoted. It's a fair point. The dollar someone else might pay for you to reduce their sentence might be higher than you would get outside. It's all about comparative advantage.
- Rebelgecko 4y agoIf it's the same program described here[1], there's a cap on how much credit a prisoner could get per year. Once they hit that point, many people would take the opportunity to make their life on the inside easier. However supposedly they were proctored while writing the book reports to avoid blatant cheating. 1: https://www.npr.org/2017/07/04/535530400/in-brazil-some-inmates-are-using-a-novel-way-to-get-out-of-prison-earlier https://www.npr.org/2017/07/04/535530400/in-brazil-some-inma...
- capableweb 4y ago> Why would someone write a report for others if they could shorten their own sentence instead? I think they mean sort of "ghost-reviewing", possibly under threats. Like I tell you to write a book review in my name, or I'd beat you up.
- mkmk 4y agoShort documentary on the subject here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LQ5dM-uRPPo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LQ5dM-uRPPo (english subtitles)
- pkaye 4y agoInitially I was reading "sentences" as a line of text and nothing made sense.
- geodel 4y agoIt made total sense to me. With increase in command over language inmates started using shorter sentences instead of long ones without break.
- bandyaboot 4y agoYeah I was thinking this might be a trick. Prisoners who write book reviews are eligible to have their sentences shortened [during the editing process].
- jeffwask 4y agoAnecdotally, my brother in law was in US prison (federal) and we would send him books all the time and he would read them and trade them around for other books. It's hard to contextualize how much nothing they have to do in prison. Reading is literally one of the only things you could be guaranteed to be able to do on a day to day basis regardless of lock down status.
- rqtwteye 4y agoI have seen videos where they trained dogs or had adopted rescue cats. I think a lot of prisoners would do way better if they got a chance to feel like a productive member of society. Them being firefighters in California wildfires comes to mind too.
- capableweb 4y agoThere is generally two types of prisons in the world, one is "Punish"/"Keep rest of the world safe" prisons, and the other is "Rehabilitation" prisons. The latter tries to make people be able to re-integrate after finishing the sentence, while the first doesn't care as long as they are imprisoned and kept away from the rest of "normal folks". Convincing people that rehabilitation is possible is a huge job, and I don't see that happening in the US anytime soon.
- diveandfight 4y agoRather than types, maybe those qualities are more like ends on a spectrum?
- rqtwteye 4y agoIt's a very US thing to present issues as one side or the other, "Left or Right", "Capitalist or Socialist" with nothing between. In reality almost everything is on a (multi-dimensional) spectrum with a lot of nuance. This binary thinking is reinforced by TV and social media and is tearing the country apart.
- 4y ago
- CaptainNegative 4y agoAmazon Meconical Turk
- csours 4y agoMeconvictical ? (I like this one because it sounds really dumb) Meconvictal ?
- Takennickname 4y agoBet this is gonna be true in less than 10 years. Train some AI to shorten your sentence.
- typon 4y agoShortening sentences using longer sentences
- sdfghswe 4y agoGet ChatGPT to do it, commit more crimes.
- lsllc 4y agoHere's a list of books for review: * Shawshank Redemption * The Count of Monte Cristo * Papillon * How to Escape From Prison * The Great Escape Actually, I wonder if prison libraries are allow to carry such books that might inspire prisoners to escape or otherwise give them ideas.
- noirscape 4y agoIIRC prison libraries do get screened for that sorta thing. Overly violent novels for example aren't allowed in prisons because of concerns that it might lead to criminals thinking violence is more acceptable. (So no Fight Club for example.)
- t-3 4y agoAnything too ideologically or politically radical, sexual, or violent might be banned. Some bans just seem to be random, though. https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/banned-book-lists/ https://www.bookstoprisoners.net/banned-book-lists/
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoAre you concerned that the prisoners would think of escape only after reading said book? I think you'd be able to spot the deception the first time an inmate asked for a poster of Rita Hayworth.
- ankaAr 4y agoNoobs.. Argentinian condemned vice president got a sentence reduction doing some courses (short ones), some from prison, some from his home (he was at home confinament because he alleged he must care of their childs (? DDBB programmer(? Electrician Another electrician one, but longer. Events organizer Philosophy He got almost 1 year cut. He was condemned because he bought the company that printed paper money :D What a nice country!
- matheusmoreira 4y agoNoobs? Our entire government is made up of corrupt officials. The lawyer of the biggest organized drug trafficking gang in the country is in the supreme court and electoral court and by now the nation has essentially turned into a judiciary monarchy of sorts. They basically erased our president's crimes, undid the entire investigation into him and his party and basically buried everything, and now this corrupt communist ex-con is in power. They're trying to ban Bolsonaro from politics right now for "abuse of political power" or some other equally vague made up crime. Biden actually backed this communist and then had to watch him strengthen ties with China. Our impeached former president is now chief of some BRICS bank thing and making like $100k+ a month to do fuck all. It's comical. This country ain't for amateurs.
- bloomingeek 4y agoIf I was ever stupid enough to commit a crime worthy of prison, I would want to have an active, outside job. Example: cleaning up old cemeteries, repairing park trails, working in a recycle facilities... I realize there's the possibility of liability, and yes, I have seen the movie "Cool Hand Luke", but non-activity is almost inhuman. Punishment is essential, but common sense must prevail.
- Ar-Curunir 4y ago> stupid enough to commit a crime worthy of prison This is a terrible attitude. Go read some of the other comments, and maybe learn a bit about the prison-industrial complex and how it incentivizes to law-enforcement agencies to maximize the number of people in prison. Try arguing that this system would only target "stupid people", and not, say, communities that are easy targets, and historically over-policed.
- bloomingeek 4y agoStupid as in breaking known laws. Before you judge me or anyone else, remember you don't know everything and never will. To presume you can read minds on this site is shortsighted and...stupid.
- Ar-Curunir 4y agoMy point is that most people have probably broken a bunch of laws unknowingly, but only some get hit with jail time for it. For example: ever jaywalked? you probably broke a law. Police have used jaywalking as an excuse to jail people.
- bloomingeek 4y agoI guessing we can't find any instance of a jaywalker ever going to prison. Remember, I said stupid enough to go to prison, not local jail. A big problem we have today in the social revolution we are going through is most readers don't thoroughly read posts before going off with their own biases.
- zac23or 4y agoHomicides in Brazil lead to 6 years in prison. The system doesn't work, but we have these gems like "if inmates read books...", the cherry on top of shit.
- anthk 4y ago6 years of prison in Brazil sounds like hell.
- zac23or 4y agoFor a homicide the hell is nothing.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoMake a racist joke or something though and you'll probably get 20+ years.
- vitorgrs 4y agoIt's 6 to 20 years. Not "only 6". And that is, "simple" murder.
- zac23or 4y agoIs not only 6 (i never say "only"), but is not rare 6 years. X years in prison in Brazil is bullshit. At 1/3 of x or 1/2 or .., the prisoner is free. Suzane von Richthofen cruelly killed her father and mother. She is 39 years old. After 20 years on prison, she is already free.
- AlbertCory 4y agoGood idea to learn useful skills. Just two caveats: 1) This can easily become cheap labor for outside companies, like book publishers, in this case. Books with many reviews sell better than books with none, I've been told. Any self-published author will receive unsolicited email offering to review their books. 2) With respect to "rehabilitation": a substantial number of prison inmates have psychopathic traits [1]. That's not to say they're unemployable; it may even be an asset in some professions [2] /s [1] https://www.apa.org/monitor/2022/03/ce-corner-psychopathy https://www.apa.org/monitor/2022/03/ce-corner-psychopathy [2] https://www.amazon.com/Snakes-Suits-When-Psychopaths-Work-ebook/dp/B000QUCOAS/ref=sr_1_1 https://www.amazon.com/Snakes-Suits-When-Psychopaths-Work-eb...?
- ugh123 4y ago>Each well-written review would shave four days off an inmate's sentence. What about lifers?
- jutrewag 4y agoWow. So you could write enough reviews in a month to shave off 10+ years.