5 ms·
The case against pet ownership
- taeric 4y agoThese sorts of articles are... interesting. Especially when it gets down to the "boring life." I'm more than a little curious on what sort of fun filled journey folks thing outside animals have? The coyotes I see on a regular basis aren't living any more of a fulfilling life than the dogs I see around. And they are almost certainly holding parasites. Same for the deer I see on the regular. Do I think we should go to box farming animals? No, but that is just the other end of a straw man here. I do want more investigation to do what we can to make all life better. But I don't want to begin with odd guilt trips for the rest of society.
- version_five 4y agoA prowling wolf, whose shaggy skin (So strict the watch of dogs had been) Hid little but his bones, Once met a mastiff dog astray. A prouder, fatter, sleeker Tray, No human mortal owns. Sir Wolf in famish'd plight, Would fain have made a ration Upon his fat relation; But then he first must fight; And well the dog seem'd able To save from wolfish table His carcass snug and tight. So, then, in civil conversation The wolf express'd his admiration Of Tray's fine case. Said Tray, politely, 'Yourself, good sir, may be as sightly; Quit but the woods, advised by me. For all your fellows here, I see, Are shabby wretches, lean and gaunt, Belike to die of haggard want. With such a pack, of course it follows, One fights for every bit he swallows. Come, then, with me, and share On equal terms our princely fare.' 'But what with you Has one to do?' Inquires the wolf. 'Light work indeed,' Replies the dog; 'you only need To bark a little now and then, To chase off duns and beggar men, To fawn on friends that come or go forth, Your master please, and so forth; For which you have to eat All sorts of well-cook'd meat - Cold pullets, pigeons, savoury messes - Besides unnumber'd fond caresses.' The wolf, by force of appetite, Accepts the terms outright, Tears glistening in his eyes. But faring on, he spies A gall'd spot on the mastiff's neck. 'What's that?' he cries. 'O, nothing but a speck.' 'A speck?' 'Ay, ay; 'tis not enough to pain me; Perhaps the collar's mark by which they chain me.' 'Chain! chain you! What! run you not, then, Just where you please, and when?' 'Not always, sir; but what of that?' 'Enough for me, to spoil your fat! It ought to be a precious price Which could to servile chains entice; For me, I'll shun them while I've wit.' So ran Sir Wolf, and runneth yet. https://www.bartleby.com/lit-hub/the-worlds-best-poetry/the-wolf-and-the-dog/ https://www.bartleby.com/lit-hub/the-worlds-best-poetry/the-...
- hirundo 4y agoI envy Sir Wolf but wear the chain for the savoury messes.
- greenie_beans 4y ago[flagged]
- smt88 4y agoYou can't allow the fearmongers to stifle the exploration of new and uncomfortable ideas. People like DeSantis only need one or two people talking about a new idea to create a culture war.
- greenie_beans 4y agoit's a joke
- smt88 4y agoIf the only value of a comment is to be funny and there's no discussion allowed afterward, then it's a waste of everyone's time to post it in the first place.
- greenie_beans 4y agoyour response made it seem like you thought i was being serious. the best jokes are critical and can prompt discussion.
- beckingz 4y agoAnd the best discussions of jokes are critical and prompt!
- dieselgate 4y agoI liked and feel _somewhat_ similarly to the quote about “living with dogs is great but can be considered morally wrong at a certain point” or something to that extent. But you kind of have to draw the line somewhere - I personally feel it’s way more important to stop eating meat than to worry about the “morality” of having a pet. But yeah indoor cats and breeding mills are “bad”. Support your local animal shelter as much as possible and don’t worry about it too much seems pragmatic to me. Edit: two words
- stringfood 4y ago[dead]
- throwaway22032 4y agoThe term "ownership" does a lot of heavy lifting here. I'd argue rather that a family or person "has" a pet in the same way that they "have" children. They are guardians rather than owners. They just don't ever come of age like children do.
- hinkley 4y agoAnyone who thinks they own a cat is a fucking idiot.
- gladiatr72 4y agoha! Indeed. Perhaps could more accurately be stated that one coexists with cats (or rather, they deign to coexist with us)
- Auracle 4y agoThe way my dogs have lived runs almost completely counter to this article. My dog has a doggy door, and we live on 15 acres. She can go out whenever she wants. Her food dish is always full of dog food, but she gets scraps at almost every meal. We also work from home, though it’s not like we can give her much attention during the day. My other dogs we also free to run away at any time and chose not to. Any one of them would have given their life to save mine, and I’ve personally run into (some) danger to save our current dog. I do agree that people need to think more about what would be best as far as pet ownership goes. I know not everyone is rural so you can’t treat them like I’ve been able to. Still, don’t only give them pet food. Don’t get a big dog if you live in a small place. Don’t get an active breed if you’re not able to give them enough exercise. Some breeds straight up shouldn’t exist as is and you should feel absolutely terrible about buying one. The author’s is included in that (and I’d eliminate them all if I could), but at least they adopted. Mutts are best.