3 ms·
>It's citizens generating power for other citizens at the price that the market dictates. This is exactly what it isn't. It wasn't the market price. Homeowners
by s1artibartfast 4y ago
>It's citizens generating power for other citizens at the price that the market dictates.
This is exactly what it isn't. It wasn't the market price. Homeowners were getting 10 to 20 x the wholesale price, not because the market wanted it, but because Regulators forced companies to buy it.
If it's about saving the planet, then buy commercial solar for 10 cents on the dollar. If it's about freeloading, then continue to make others pay for the overpriced gadget on your roof
- jacquesm 4y agoThey are getting the retail price which is exactly what they are paying to get that power back in the evening.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoExactly! They are paid retail price, which is 10-20X the wholesale/production price.
- jacquesm 4y agoWhich is also what they pay. If consumers can only buy at retail it makes good sense that they can also only sell at retail. This is how secondary markets are valued for every other good so that makes good sense for electricity. I don't see why you'd want to disincentivize private individuals from energy generation while at the same time guaranteeing a revenue stream for very large corporates that are doing just fine without that help. Of course they are lobbying against that and of course they will do everything they can to buy 'at wholesale' from installations that have been financed by others. What netmetering shows you is how broken the market model is, retail should never be 10 to 20x the wholesale / production price. You are defending price gouging.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThis is not how it works for other goods. This is like saying a baker must buy flour or expired milk for the price their consumers buy a cake. If you wanted to treat it as a secondary market, then solar owners should have to pay for the delivery of power, and spot pricing. They would get close to nothing a peak generation hours, and pay top dollar at peak consumption. The way power regulation works in california is power companies have a fixed profit margin. Every penny they pay over market price for rooftop solar is passed on to other consumers without it. Those consumers could be getting that power 90% cheaper.
- jacquesm 4y agoClearly, a cake is a different thing than flour or milk. Buy from a retail customer -> pay retail prices. It's as simple as that. I buy a book from Amazon, send it back the next day. I get my money back, not Amazon's whole sale buying price.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI don't know why you would compare it to a refund or return. It is completely different, and many Goods don't come with a refund. I think it's closer to buying toilet paper from a store and returning the used toilet paper and expecting a full refund.
- jacquesm 4y agoWait until you discover that it's all the same electrons doing the work. Back and forth, all day long... And no, they don't get dirty, like toilet paper would.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoHowever, you continually ignore the fact that they are used at different times and in different places.
- renewiltord 4y agoWell, the real market solution is to permit the provider to buy the electricity off the market where they can and sell the electricity off the market where they can. The provider will likely buy at the cheapest place they can and sell at the most expensive place. It is definitely a market inefficiency to require them to buy at the same price they sell.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoEspecially so when 90+% of the retail costs are not purchasing the power. It is like forcing bakers to buy flour for the cost of a cake.
- CuriouslyC 4y agoIt'd be pretty feel bad if the big wealthy energy company got to buy your power for a pittance then resell it to someone else for a big profit, to the point that I'd run a device to burn down any net power rather than let them sell it.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoBig wealthy energy company is already buying power for a pittance and reselling it to someone else for a big profit. That's how wholesale and retail markets work. Why should they be forced to buy from you when a generation company will sell for 10 cents on the dollar?
- jacquesm 4y agoBecause that's the best for the environment. If you are only focused on the money then that's fine but in the end that is what got us in this mess. So I propose that instead we look at what's best rather than at what makes companies the most profit for a change.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoYou keep saying that but it's not best for the environment. What's best for the environment would be buying commercial solar with 10% the cost and 10% of the waste
- s1artibartfast 4y agoCalifornia Power companies are highly regulated with a fixed profit margin. The cost of every kW purchased from rooftop solar gets passed on consumers that dont have it. Consumers could instead have 10x the kW from a clean solar plant out in a desert.