5 ms·
This argument doesn't hold. The effect that you are shooting for is that you minimize the damage to the planet. Having some people use the grid as an 'unlimited
by jacquesm 4y ago
This argument doesn't hold. The effect that you are shooting for is that you minimize the damage to the planet. Having some people use the grid as an 'unlimited free battery' is a fantastic way to achieve the exact same effect as if all those people invest in large physical batteries without the investment and without the environmental impact.
This sort of thing should be incentivized rather than discouraged because of the large scale effects, not because of petty accounting rules or by creating jealousy where there isn't ground for any: poor people without panels aren't subsidizing the rich, they are effectively not subsidizing the energy companies, which are far, far richer than the people with rooftop solar. It's citizens generating power for other citizens at the price that the market dictates. The thing to hope for is that enough of this will eventually lead to a reduction in retail prices rather than that we allow the energy companies to make money off surplus from one citizen sold to the next.
Batteries are nice, reduced grid generation requirement during daylight hours is even better. And that's before we get into fire risks of large battery installations, space requirements, depreciation, recycling and so on.
- majormajor 4y agoThere's still an incentive. A smaller one, yes. I'm not sure how paying wholesale for generation instead of retail would change "citizens generating power for others at the rate the market dictates" - it seems like the wholesale one is much more in line with that rate. If there was never the super-generous payouts for excess power would we be having this discussion? I'm not convinced of the doom and gloom about the change since it's coming from highly-invested people.
- jacquesm 4y agoIt's not 'super generous', it is a wash. And yes, you'd have the same problem but you'd also have more fires and a fair sized environmental problem. Having an inverter to recycle every decade or so is one thing (assuming it can't be cost effectively repaired), having to do the same thing with a 50 KWh battery is another matter entirely.
- majormajor 4y agoIsn't today's situation the utility paying a retail rate for something with a much lower wholesale replacement cost? That doesn't seem like a wash to me. EDIT: I'm not a big fan of "a battery in every garage" but I would much rather see subsidies of planned large-scale green power generation vs a shotgun of individual solar installs.
- jacquesm 4y ago> Isn't today's situation the utility paying a retail rate for something with a much lower wholesale replacement cost? Indeed, the utility will be making less profit. But the wholesale replacement cost is based on a market that the consumer doesn't have access to, they can only buy 'retail' so allowing them to sell their excess power back to the grid at that same price makes good sense. > That doesn't seem like a wash to me. From the POV of the electricity company it obviously isn't, which is why this was a politically imposed rule. But the power companies have a lot of lobbying power and that is why this is changed, not because it is good for the environment or 'more fair'. It's simply a matter of more money for the utilities. > I'm not a big fan of "a battery in every garage" but I would much rather see subsidies of planned large-scale green power generation vs a shotgun of individual solar installs. I actually am a huge fan of individual solar installs: it forces people to focus on their own consumption and their own habits rather than to see everything in terms of a couple of numbers. Once you realize how much you have to invest in order to generate a KWh you will most likely be more careful about how you use that, and conservation, not generation and definitely not storage has the biggest positive effect on the environment.
- majormajor 4y agoOne man's "the utility will be making less profit" is another "the utility will invest less in the infrastructure" especially in the case of municipal utilities. I think bundling in "maybe utilities won't spend their revenue wisely" is a distraction; if that's the big problem, that we're worried about what they're doing with the money they get from feeds, let's start pushing for that specifically. > I actually am a huge fan of individual solar installs: it forces people to focus on their own consumption and their own habits rather than to see everything in terms of a couple of numbers. Once you realize how much you have to invest in order to generate a KWh you will most likely be more careful about how you use that, and conservation, not generation and definitely not storage has the biggest positive effect on the environment. I think the current metering discourages that. Getting paid for excess at higher rates means you can get away with higher overall use to make back the same amount of $$$. Do you have any numbers on "total KWH used" for households with solar vs without solar?
- hot_gril 4y agoMost helpful thing for the environment would be for big solar facilities to handle all this instead of individual homeowners. It's less efficient trying to make people run their own mini power plants.
- 988747 4y ago[dead]
- ok_dad 4y agoLess efficient but more reliable, like software. The future of the grid should be many small generators and energy storage installations spread throughout the communities they service, not many large farms with requirements for huge transmission infrastructure. Spreading generation and storage will achieve more reliability than efficiency, sure, but when you're generating off solar or wind, who cares if it's efficient?
- luckylion 4y ago> when you're generating off solar or wind, who cares if it's efficient Whoever pays for the electricity, most likely. If you don't connect neighborhoods and each block or even house is an off-grid island, your reliability will suffer because you'll need large margins everywhere. If you do connect them, you have that "transmission infrastructure". Rooftop is great because it gives you a feeling of security and being self-sustaining, but if you want impact, it's probably much more efficient to have technicians install panels en masse at large installations than do one-off jobs on all those custom homes.
- jacquesm 4y agoThis is true, but with electric cars becoming more and more widespread local generation is having a measurable impact on daytime generation. It also offloads the grid because every KWh generated locally and consumed relatively locally doesn't need long haul transmission, as opposed to 'large installations'.
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- s1artibartfast 4y ago>It's citizens generating power for other citizens at the price that the market dictates. This is exactly what it isn't. It wasn't the market price. Homeowners were getting 10 to 20 x the wholesale price, not because the market wanted it, but because Regulators forced companies to buy it. If it's about saving the planet, then buy commercial solar for 10 cents on the dollar. If it's about freeloading, then continue to make others pay for the overpriced gadget on your roof
- jacquesm 4y agoThey are getting the retail price which is exactly what they are paying to get that power back in the evening.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoExactly! They are paid retail price, which is 10-20X the wholesale/production price.
- jacquesm 4y agoWhich is also what they pay. If consumers can only buy at retail it makes good sense that they can also only sell at retail. This is how secondary markets are valued for every other good so that makes good sense for electricity. I don't see why you'd want to disincentivize private individuals from energy generation while at the same time guaranteeing a revenue stream for very large corporates that are doing just fine without that help. Of course they are lobbying against that and of course they will do everything they can to buy 'at wholesale' from installations that have been financed by others. What netmetering shows you is how broken the market model is, retail should never be 10 to 20x the wholesale / production price. You are defending price gouging.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThis is not how it works for other goods. This is like saying a baker must buy flour or expired milk for the price their consumers buy a cake. If you wanted to treat it as a secondary market, then solar owners should have to pay for the delivery of power, and spot pricing. They would get close to nothing a peak generation hours, and pay top dollar at peak consumption. The way power regulation works in california is power companies have a fixed profit margin. Every penny they pay over market price for rooftop solar is passed on to other consumers without it. Those consumers could be getting that power 90% cheaper.
- nawitus 4y agoSelling electricity at wholesale rate is an incentive.
- jltsiren 4y agoYou should look beyond the short-term consequences. Net metering is a benefit to well-off homeowners. Such benefits can be difficult to take back when they are no longer useful, because those are the people who vote. That means you should avoid creating them unless you are sure of the long-term consequences. The question is not how net metering affects a grid still dominated by fossil fuels but how it works in a grid dominated by renewables. Some European countries are already getting there, so this is not hypothetical. When you have a period of high generation overlapping with a period of average demand, electricity is cheap. Paying a fraction of a cent for a kWh is common. When you get high generation and low demand, the prices can even go negative. On the other hand, when you have low generation and high demand, power becomes expensive and you may have to pay tens of cents for each kWh. If you have net metering, the power you sell to the grid is worth much less than the power you buy from it. One of the key tools for dealing with the variability of renewable energy is shifting demand that is insensitive to time of use automatically. Instead of buying expensive power now, you buy cheaper power hours or perhaps even days later. But if you have net metering, that does not concern you. You can keep using power as usual, because the price you pay is fixed. That can make net metering an incentive for inefficiency.
- evandijk70 4y agoAs an owner of solar panels, I agree - prices were negative today in the Netherlands and I made money by delivering electricity to the grid. Solar panels are extremely easy to disconnect, but this is only done at big commercial sites due to net metering
- opportune 4y agoLet’s say everybody had rooftop solar and net metering. Everybody produces an excess of energy during the day which they give to the grid, then at night they start pulling energy from the grid. They could very well have a net energy consumption of 0 and pay very little. But someone, somewhere that is connected to the grid has to be doing something to provide that energy at night, whether it’s batteries or a gas peaker plant or pumped hydro or whatever. Who is going to pay for all that power if none of the consumers are? At least in that thought experiment, everybody gets to pay little for electricity. But in the real world not everybody can install solar (I live in an apartment building, others in less sunny areas) and not everybody can afford it. So I don’t end up with a net 0 bill and get charged the actual per-kwh rates, which the utility company sets to recoup their costs. Sure I use energy just like the zero-metered folks, but I have to pay full price while they pay very little relative to what it actually costs to give them power when the Sun is down, so I end up subsidizing them.
- jacquesm 4y agoYou can't push energy into the grid at will, there is simply an upper limit where the inverter will stop raising the voltage and leading the grid phase. So for the grid to accept your power it has to have a drain somewhere.
- dbjacobs 4y agoHere in Hawaii the electric company is installing smart meters so they can charge different rates during the day evening and night. So your solar production during the day will credit you at the day rate, then your usage in the evening charges you at the evening rates (about triple the day rate). And then late night usage is about double the day rate. This mostly solves the retail/wholesale/base rate problem.
- the_third_wave 4y ago> Who is going to pay for all that power if none of the consumers are? The consumers of course, that is assuming the grid uses an hourly rate. When all those roof top solar arrays push power into the grid the price goes down, possibly even below zero - you'd have to pay to push power into the grid and "get paid" [1] to consume power - if the grid is close to capacity. During the night they draw power from the grid and pay the hourly rate which may be - but does not have to be - higher than the rates paid when the sun was up. What if the grid gets more power in during the day than can be delivered to customers? They can use it to charge their "grid-scale" battery which they use during the peak hours in the evening when everyone comes home, turns on whatever power-hungry devices they have. That battery will save them a lot of money compared to the gas-turbine peak power plant they'd otherwise have to use. In a hypothetical situation where everyone has enough solar capacity installed to cover their own needs it will be more efficient to have those batteries installed as close as possible to where the power is needed, i.e. in individual homes or possibly at local transformer stations. I don't think they're there yet nor will they ever be able to get there in urban environments with largely multi-storied buildings.