5 ms·
Breast feeding is a natural thing and should be accepted in public by society. However, the people flagging these pictures are most likely the woman's friends.
by k-mcgrady 15y ago
Breast feeding is a natural thing and should be accepted in public by society. However, the people flagging these pictures are most likely the woman's friends. She should speak to them instead of protesting at Facebook. I would guess her friends don't like pictures of her breasts showing up regularly in their News Feed. If you are using a public computer for instance and the pictures show up it could land you in an embarrassing situation.
Personally I think it is a case of over sharing. I have nothing against public breast feeding but I don't need to see dozens of photos of you doing it. If you think it is a mundane activity that should be more socially acceptable don't share it on Facebook, you're sensationalising it.
And if it matters to you that they can share any content without risk of it being pulled, start a blog. This is a case for the open web I guess which there has been quite a lot of talk about these last few days.
I hope that doesn't come off as a rant/rude but it seems like something blown out of proportion.
- blahedo 15y ago> the people flagging these pictures are most likely the woman's friends. Why on earth would you assume that? Edit: oh, duh, I get it. I read "friends" as "friends", not "Facebook friends". Makes more sense now.
- k-mcgrady 15y agoBecause unless she has made them public the only people who would see them are her friends.
- sliverstorm 15y agoWho else is likely to see the pictures?
- darxius 15y agoI agree with the "start a blog" approach. It scares me to think that social networking is getting closer and closer to: "but my genitals are the most fundamental aspect of my humanity, I should be allowed to post a picture of them on my wall".
- erikpukinskis 15y agoBreasts are not genitals. http://www.thefreedictionary.com/genitals http://www.thefreedictionary.com/genitals
- lucisferre 15y agoI find it most disappointing that someone here had to be told this.
- pjscott 15y agoWhy does that scare you? This is the Internet; people post pictures of their genitals all the time, and the world does not seem substantially harmed by it, because it's usually easy to avoid seeing things you're not interested in, and the back button is easy to press. In general, I would rather not weigh ourselves down with unnecessary rules.
- k-mcgrady 15y agoThe problem with having no limits on what can be posted to Facebook is that you cannot easily avoid it. If someone you friend posts it, it will appear in your news feed. If they have a blog with pictures you don't want to see you just don't visit that blog.
- khuey 15y agoNothing stops you from hiding that person from your news feed, or removing them from your friends list entirely.
- tsuraan 15y agoBreast feeding is a natural thing and should be accepted in public by society. I think you want to re-think your logic here. There are a lot of natural acts (e.g. defecation, sex, dying of tuberculosis) that aren't generally accepted as public acts, and that arguably shouldn't be. I don't care one way or another about public breast feeding, but your argument seems broken to me.
- k-mcgrady 15y agoYou're completely right. I worded that badly. I didn't mean that it should be accepted because it is natural. But that it is natural, not obscene or disgusting, and should be acceptable in public.
- alphakappa 15y agoIt's a hard sentence to word correctly. (For example, your new statement may be taken to imply that sex is obscene/disgusting, which many may not agree with). Your original intent is clear enough though, so it doesn't matter. While posting in places like these where sentences can be taken apart, one develops a new respect for television personalities and politicians who have to think of how every sentence can be interpreted.
- lucisferre 15y agoI second this, I think we could do with a lot less of the semantic quibbling. If the grandparent had a legitimate beef with understanding the intent he could have simply asked for clarification. Obviously the intent was understood and this was completely superfluous.
- omonra 15y agoYou realize that words like 'obscene' and 'disgusting' are judgement calls? So while you may not find it to be either, others do? I personally think that certain bodily functions are better kept private - this one included. In Asia I've frequently seen women breastfeed while covering themselves with a shawl. Why do western women insist on making it a public display?
- tnicola 15y agoI am not sure it is as simple as her friend's flagging it as inappropriate. If someone was that offended by her posting breastfeeding pictures, they could just hide her newsfeed or unsubscribe from her. I am a breastfeeding mother who lives in Vancouver and to be completely honest with you, while I do breastfeed in public without any consideration for people around me (passport office, liquor store, park bench etc.) and do not cover myself up, I do feel that some women in my community take it too far to prove a point. Someone has either told them something and they are lashing out or they are simply trying to do something for the cause. The article doesn't tell us what was the privacy level of her photos. I wonder if they were public and have been taken down for that reason. If Facebook, however, is in the business of taking down private photos, then anyone posting a picture of their child could be seen as a child pornography, couldn't it? And that is not even legal. Methinks that there is more to this story. Something is not adding up.
- omonra 15y agoMay I ask why you find it ok to not have "any consideration for people around" you? I want to make it clear that I really want to understand how you think (ie not trolling). Why do you not insist on performing other bodily functions in public?
- mrj 15y agoCome on, baby gets hungry. Baby wants to be fed, now. Mom feeds baby. This happens all day and all hours of the day. You cannot seriously expect that all breastfeeding mothers will be hidden away for 30m to an hour every 2 hours simply because somebody might see a booby.
- dsl 15y agoIf you have a dog, clean up its crap. If you drive a car, don't cut people off or take up two parking stalls. If you have a kid, don't flop your saggy tits out in public. If you love blasting your music at insane volumes, don't move into an apartment with thin walls. Jesus christ people, it all basically boils down to respecting the people around you. If you can't handle the consequences of breeding, you shouldn't be doing it in the first place.
- rsanders 15y ago> Personally I think it is a case of over sharing. So what you're saying is that Facebook should be removing something like 90-95% of the photos uploaded to it.
- k-mcgrady 15y agoNo, I did not say that. Re-read my comment and you will see that that is just my opinion. I did not say that is a reason Facebook should take it down. I gave plenty of other reasons it may have been taken down. I did not say anywhere that Facebook should be taken down photos of breast feeding.