3 ms·
Paternalism is a good thing. One of the things that makes human beings successful as a species is learning successful behaviors. Carnegie was doing those towns
by rayiner 4y ago
Paternalism is a good thing. One of the things that makes human beings successful as a species is learning successful behaviors. Carnegie was doing those towns a favor by ensuring that they thought through the logistics of operating a library—in the process learning how to operate a public institution.
People rail against paternalism out of a misguided egalitarianism. You see this all the time in the context of the World Bank and IMF telling developing countries how to run their economies. You know what? That’s a good thing. Singapore became one of the wealthiest countries in the world by studiously copying the aspects of the British financial and legal system that worked. NGOs that just give money without helping countries learn how to use it effectively aren’t doing anyone any favors.
- Anechoic 4y agoSingapore became one of the wealthiest countries in the world by studiously copying the aspects of the British financial and legal system that worked Did Singapore copy those aspects because they chose to do so, or were those aspects imposed on them? (sincere question, since if they chose of their own free will, that would seem to argue against "paternalism is good")
- azmodeus 4y agoChoosing what the keep and what to innovate is still choice. The beginning was imposed but they took it from there and made it work.
- SamReidHughes 4y agoThey (Singapore, or the PAP) have freely amended their judicial system as they see fit.
- jonhohle 4y agoI completely agree Re: NGOs, but at least Carnegie put up resources for libraries without getting anything back specifically (possibly political good will, but not equity in anything). Does World Bank and IMF want to help developing countries to help others prosper or to grab resources and power from those building it?