8 ms·
"(a system that’s distinct from our diverse gender identities)" Please don't take this the wrong way, this is a genuine question. Is there an explaination some
by giantg2 4y ago
"(a system that’s distinct from our diverse gender identities)"
Please don't take this the wrong way, this is a genuine question. Is there an explaination somewhere of what purpose gender identities serve and what benefits that provides (ie why don't animals need them)? Aside from reproduction, I don't see how gender would really influence anything.
- capableweb 4y ago> ie why don't animals need them Is there a reason to believe it doesn't exists in animals as well? Homosexuality is common in many species, are some individual animals in those species more prone to homosexual "relationships" than others? If so, maybe those animals are feeling some sort of expression by their gender identity based on their preference. I'm guessing gender identities serve the same purpose as individual expression, just to be self-expressive.
- dahfizz 4y agoI thought gender and sexuality are totally independent?
- sorokod 4y agoDepends on when you had that thought https://www.websters1913.com/words/Gender https://www.websters1913.com/words/Gender
- ThrowawayTestr 4y agoWhat does gender have to do with sexuality have to do with gender?
- paxcoder 4y ago[dead]
- bell-cot 4y agoHuman society. Animals are also “adults” or not without reference to a local legal age of majority or government ID, move across borders without going through Customs, pay no taxes, subscribe to no ideologies or religions, die without death certificates being issued, etc.
- DoctorOW 4y agoGender identity is a subset of identity as a whole, something animals don't have the self awareness for. Pretty much every term for referring to someone in human society is influenced by gender.
- ben_w 4y agoAs gender dimorphism can influence external characteristics, I assume it can also influence personalities. If animals have any senses of identity (I think at least some non-human animals do) or beliefs about what their bodies "should" look like (passing the mirror test at least weakly implies so), then likewise. How much any of this is present in different species, and how much the range of personality traits can diverge from the other traits, I wouldn't want to even guess.
- giantg2 4y agoI understand that. Then is this just an inherent cultural need for labeling of in-groups vs out-groups, or potential mates vs non-mates? In today's world, there's very little restriction on gender, and most of those restrictions do not change based on changing gender. For example, I can shave my legs and identify as a man, woman, or some other gender, but how does that change what I can and can't do?
- ben_w 4y agoYou're asking the wrong person. When I first read about the topic in the newspaper aged about 13, noticing the existence of trans women despite the existence of sexism (transitioning to man comes with a pay rise, transitioning to woman with a pay cut) was enough by itself to make me realise that there was a deeper issue, but not to understand it. For myself, I don't have any sense of gender identity; if we lived in a magical otherworld where waking up surprised to find yourself gender-flipped was just a thing that happened and not a sign of non-consensual invasive surgery, if we lived in that world and I woke up gender-swapped, I don't think I'd care. It's like asking if I prefer Pepsi or Coke: whatever, to me all the sweetened carbonated phosphoric acid drinks with hints of caramel are much the same. Likewise with gender: bits on the inside, bits on the outside, whatever, don't care. The fact that people are willing to go through invasive surgery, even though (unless you're literally a lab rat) it's form without function, is the second thing that tells me that there are powerful drivers besides in/out groups. But what those are? I'm the wrong person to ask.
- giantg2 4y ago
- version_five 4y agoI'll probably get flagged - I see it more like being a goth or a skater or whatever. Identity is something people like to have generally, it's normal, but somehow it gets politicised in certain cases. I don't think a relationship to sex has to enter into it, it's more like a justification maybe?
- butterNaN 4y agoIt gets politicized because there is real-world discrimination if one's not under the normative curve, which is a political issue.
- cs02rm0 4y agoGender identity was synonymous with sex. Today it seems to have morphed into something on a spectrum from being synonymous with sex to having no meaning at all. It seems worth avoiding for the sake of discussions around sex.
- rsynnott 4y agoDo you mean biological purpose? This may be the wrong question to ask; gender is arguably to a large extent part of _culture_, which is more or less the stuff that we've built on top of biology. There's no _biological_ reason that ancient Celtic women were allowed own property while contemporary ancient Roman women were a literal possession of their father or husband and ancient Greek women weren't really allowed leave the house; that was _culture_. (Simplified example, btw; there were edge-cases where Roman women were essentially emancipated, say, and Celtic and Greek practices differed dramatically by region, but even within a pretty restricted time and area of the world there were massive differences in how this all worked)
- giantg2 4y agoI understand that historically. However, I would argue that those restrictions were actually by sex as changing gender was not really an option back then. Even if one tried, I assume most cultures would still enforce those ideas based on sex. We have very few restrictions on gender today, and the ones we do have still tend to exclude transgender individuals (combat roles, some levels of some sports, some bathrooms). So I'm having trouble understanding in general what a tangible benefit would be. For example, what changes for a man that dresses to look like a woman if they say they are a man vs they say they are a woman (or some other identity)? Are all the physical attributes and actions the same? If someone wants to be a specific gender that's fine, but does that actually change anything they could or couldn't do as their prior gender in today's world?
- amanaplanacanal 4y agoQuite a few places have gendered dress codes (still!), among other things. And you appear to be talking mostly about the US and similar countries, much of the rest of the world is different.
- giantg2 4y agoYeah, I am mostly taking about US and similar countries. But changing gender in one of those other countries would likely be moot, right? Hmm, I haven't really seen gendered dress codes aside from schools (which could/should be rewritten to be gender neutral) or the "entertainment" industry (which is likely to descriminate regardless of dress code).
- pron 4y agohttps://nautil.us/no-animals-do-not-have-genders-237938/ https://nautil.us/no-animals-do-not-have-genders-237938/
- harpiaharpyja 4y agoWhy does this article even mention gender? It's completely unrelated to the topic at hand. Every mention of it is in some parenthetical jammed into the article with no logical flow.
- debacle 4y agoMuch of this "sex in nature is super complicated, actually" content is driven by the push for gender ideology in humans.
- VeninVidiaVicii 4y agoIt seems to be worth saying, considering the climate. Recently I was a teacher assistant in a genetics lab, and an undergrad student lodged a complaint against the professor for talking about some of this very same stuff, ie, biological determinants of sex. But the prof was quite oblivious with no idea about the current culture wars.
- tlogan 4y agoThe reason gender roles have evolved differently can be attributed to the costs associated with reproduction for each sex. In our species, females tend to bear significantly higher reproductive costs than males. For example, men have the ability to father multiple offspring simultaneously, whereas women must devote substantial time and energy to pregnancy and childbirth. These disparities in reproductive investment have contributed to the development of distinct gender roles over time.
- paulddraper 4y agoThat, and other physical differences. Men are on average larger and stronger, making them more capable of manual labor.
- giantg2 4y agoIt seems this is also a blocker to integrating sports. It seems the whole trans people playing on whatever team would be moot if we didn't have sex/gender discriminate teams.
- fauxpause_ 4y agoHumans are relatively unique when it comes to sexual relationships. We’re very developed and our social roles are hugely important. It’s not crazy to think that there are aspects of our sexual identities that don’t appear in other animals. We’re not unique in being unique. Consider our relatively close relative, the bonobos, in which they’re all bisexual sluts. Gender is sort of a natural thing in human identities, even if it is a social construct. Intersex individuals are a pretty good piece of evidence of this. People born with ambiguous genitalia. Doctors often pick which one to go with and will do surgery to make it so. They often “get it wrong” and the individual will later feel they are the wrong gender WITHOUT necessarily knowing they were intersex at birth. Gender can be a social construct and still have biological intrinsic factors behind it. It doesn’t need to arise from a purpose per se. it doesn’t NEED to have biological intrinsic factors either.
- Spivak 4y ago> They often “get it wrong” and the individual will later feel they are the wrong gender WITHOUT necessarily knowing they were intersex at birth. You see a similar phenomenon with trans people too. By a huge margin trans people know they're the wrong gender at age 5-6 well before they have any idea what boys vs girls even means. And it can't be they go with whatever people say they are because otherwise they wouldn't reject it. It's not something socialized. The expression is cultural -- boys have short hair, girls wear makeup, but the identity is fixed. It's not really all that surprising in hindsight but humans seem to have an internal sense of their gender that's independent of their chromosomes. I mean if you swapped my body or did some weird gene therapy I would still know I'm a woman. Trans folks seem to just be people for whom the firmware doesn't match the hardware. It's not even up there with the weirdest human things and now that we don't stigmatize it as much we're seeing that it happens wayyy more often than we thought it did.
- fauxpause_ 4y agoHmm wow that does not match my expectations but the average age of gender dysmorphia beginning appears to be about 6 years old for adult trans individuals. I would have expected a closer tie to puberty but it would seem you’re closer to the mark.
- coldtea 4y ago>Aside from reproduction, I don't see how gender would really influence anything. In a modern society where food comes prepackaged in supermarkets (or delivered), there is police on tap, and the most hostile thing is perhaps somebody swearing at you from road rage, maybe not. In historical societies up to very recently it played a huge role in lots of post-reproduction things, considering how raw physical force, stamina, stature, etc. is a huge advantage in battle, hunting, threat avoidance outside the house, law enforcement, demanding manual labor, etc. This means that sex automatically leaks into societal roles. Doesn't matter is some societies, out of some historical peculiarity or out of necessity used women instead, or both men and women, for some of these roles, as the physiological tendency pushed towards the conventional setup as having an advantage (an army of women would be trivially defeated in hand battle by an army of men, for example), and so the general trends seen globally, in thousands of unrelated cultures followed it.
- bell-cot 4y ago> In a modern society ... maybe not. True in a way...but I fear that your outlook on modern society is far more flattering than the reality. Even in the "best" little niches of modern human society.
- thejackgoode 4y agoSexual dimorphism exists to split evolutionary pressure and allow a species to both survive (conservative) and adapt to (risky) a changing environment. Human gender identities are several layers on top of this evolutionary foundation. In theory, they are needed to help socially indoctrinate people to what is now a successful meta model of behavior. They are progressively converging in terms of gender roles difference, not only because of societal and ideological changes of the last century, but as well because there are less severe crises, so that less of adaptive behavior is required.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bluGill 4y agoSexual dimorphism means that the two different sexes can specialize on their niche. What the niche is can be very different (male seahorses give live birth) between species, but the one that doesn't have to do something can focus more one something else. You can have one guard the young and thus get more camouflage or other defense - while the other parent will hunt food and thus get more hunting abilities. There are many other examples in nature where the differences in behavior are and advantage to both (even if one clearly has the worse life overall it is an advantage to the species)
- where_is_spegg 4y agoIt's typically used as a euphemism for a desire to be the opposite sex in some way or another. For example, if a male wants to be female, or even just sees himself as somewhat feminine (i.e. having some interests or behaviours that he perceives as being more commonly associated with women), he may announce that he has a 'female gender identity'. The benefit of framing this as an identity (and one most often described as innate and unchanging) rather than a desire, is that it has a 'who I am' connotation instead of 'who I want to be'. Which has been useful in a broader cultural context in gaining acceptance for this desire, especially in the political arena; compare e.g. 'trans women are women' versus 'transwomen are men who desire to be women'. Another useful property of gender identity is that it is unverifiable and unfalsifiable, much like the concept of having a soul. Therefore anyone can claim to have any gender identity, and there's not really any challenge that can be made to such claims other than accusations of deception or delusion, neither of which are considered socially acceptable, in most contexts. This also shifts the rhetorical ground from the material (biological reality of sex, sexual mimicry via hormonal and surgical interventions) to the metaphysical. So this also helps shield this desire to be the opposite sex from criticism. Also, as it's usually defined as something like 'an innate sense of one's gender', there's a useful definitional confusion in that. Most people will just use their self-knowledge of being female or male to answer the question of gender identity, even though this is a different type of concept to desiring to be the opposite sex. So in this way, gender identity can be presented as being something everyone has, despite it referring to distinct phenomena. In short, it's the centrepiece of a rather impressive rhetorical strategy to normalise and institutionalise the desire to be the opposite sex.