4 ms·
The big advantage would be that you learn to see that there is nothing magical or 'right' of one number base over another. Base 2 has it's uses as does base 10(
by jacquesm 4y ago
The big advantage would be that you learn to see that there is nothing magical or 'right' of one number base over another. Base 2 has it's uses as does base 10(10). And most computer programmers are familiar with at least one other base besides decimal, and quite a few will be able to use binary, octal and decimal with relative ease. It gets interesting when you go off the beaten path and you re-learn the rules for arithmetic in different bases. In my experience all of this gives you a much better understanding of why decimal is practical and widespread. But it also shows you that it is a convention that won out for both cultural reasons and because it made certain arithmetic easier.
If 10x10 = 100 looks natural to you in decimal then it will still be natural to you if you think of it as 16x16 = 256 when you look at the numbers in their hexadecimal representation. You can only get that kind of fluidity by playing around in different number systems. So I'm perfectly ok with students inventing their own number systems, they are definitely not going to get any dumber on account of having done that.
Growing up with Inches and degrees Fahrenheit is a cultural issue, most of the rest of the world has moved on from there, for reasons that are far more compelling than those that would apply to using a different number base. Those are arbitrary values, whereas all number bases exist regardless of whether we use them or not. Think of the one as cultural baggage and the others as just another part of number theory.
- kome 4y agogreat and enlightening comment.
- gladiatr72 4y agoNot trolling. Promise. I can't think of a non-computing/math-related context where being cog of base number theory comes into play.
- revscat 4y agoIt’s at least partially about recognizing that there are other ways to view the world than the default one we carry around inside our precious egos, ways that are — literally, in this case — equal to our defaults.
- thebooktocome 4y agoImperial units are unfortunately still in common use in the United States, the United Kingdom, and related colonies/ex-colonies. They are variable base number systems that people reckon with on a daily basis. It wasn’t so long ago, historically speaking, that England used pounds, shillings, and pence! Decimal currency really was a fantastic innovation.
- Swizec 4y agoPedantic comment: USA doesn’t use the imperial system, that was Britain. USA has used the “United States Customary Units” since 1832. Since 1893 the units have been defined in terms of metric. Since 1991 the rule has been to “prefer metric units”, which I guess is why all packaging you commonly see includes measurements in both systems. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_customary_units https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_customary_units edit: After living in EU and US, I will grant that the lbs is a more convenient unit for measuring food. A kilo of apples is a lot, but a pound is just right.
- thfuran 4y agoI don't think the difference between pounds and kilos really matters to purchasing food, but labeling everything with a per 100g nutrition facts rather than just whatever BS serving size the manufacturer makes up is a significant improvement. You can buy oil in the US that is listed as containing 0 calories and 0 fat per serving (and 1000+ servings per container). Not that that's a unit system issue.
- Swizec 4y agoAs a calorie counter, I have thoughts on this. Comparing foods at the supermarket based on 100g base units is easier, true. But that means you need a scale every time you eat anything. It’s waaaay easier to go “yeah that’s about 1/3rd of the package” (and accurate enough for me). So really I’d love nutritional labels that have both.
- 4y ago
- InitialLastName 4y agoYou've never needed to know what time it will be 2 hours and 45 minutes after 11:30 AM?
- gladiatr72 4y agoHeh. Yeah, I guess. Maybe I'm an idiot, but the idea of a minute being a unit of a base-60 system didn't occur to me til round the time I was learning about complimentary binary arithmetic.
- InitialLastName 4y agoI think you're not unusual in not having thought about it, but there's value in being able to intuitively extend your understanding of decimal math to cover it.
- gladiatr72 4y agoYeah, because it isn't required to facilitate the functional understanding of rough time (>=1s/tick) intervals. I understood how perceiving numerical values in various bases is useful, just not how it applies to the post.
- msla 4y agoWhat?
- naasking 4y ago> The big advantage would be that you learn to see that there is nothing magical or 'right' of one number base over another. Different bases do indeed have "magical" properties that make them appealing, which is exactly what you later acknowledge when you say that base 10 makes certain arithmetic easier. There's no issue with learning different bases, as long as it's not an excuse to avoid learning the common bases you need to interact with various fields.
- thomastjeffery 4y agoSome bases are inherently better for small integer arithmetic. Every base has difficulty representing some fractions. For example, 1/3 is written in base 10 as 0.333... The 3 repeats forever. You can use explicit notation like a line over the top, but that's still just a workaround. The Babylonians used base 60, which has many more prime factors than base 10: 60 can be divided evenly by 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 10, 12, 15, 20, 30, and 60. 60 is a lot of digits to remember, though. That presents its own overhead. Some people advocate base 12: it's only two more digits, and it's evenly divisible by 1, 2, 3, 4, 6, and 12. 1/5 is a mess, though: 0.24972497...