4 ms·
It's not that simple. 1. That tax money doesn't vanish down a hole. It gets spent, largely on American businesses. 2. By collecting more we reduce the deficit
by mattmaroon 18y ago
It's not that simple.
1. That tax money doesn't vanish down a hole. It gets spent, largely on American businesses.
2. By collecting more we reduce the deficit, so it also saves on inevitable future taxes plus interest..
3. The cleaner isn't paying a higher tax, unless the cleaner makes $250k a year. In fact since the cleaner is probably making 1/8th of that, he is paying a lower tax and could therefore charge me less while still making the same amount himself, and the free market will make that happen.
4. A rising tide lifts all boats. If there's one thing we can be sure of, it's that the middle class isn't going to save that extra money, that's just not the American way. They're going to spend it. A retailer's after tax margins might drop a bit, but their volume will increase. (I think that's what Obama was trying to say in response to the infamous Joe the Plumber question, but he didn't explain it well.)
I don't see the logic behind your number 3. Salaries are, of course, a deduction, so higher taxes should have little effect on them. Any employees making less than $250k (and that's the overwhelming majority of non self-employed people) will require less salary due to paying less taxes to maintain the same quality of life. And increased volume will make up for decreased margins at least to some extent (probably varying by industry).
Also, one of my blog readers sent me a neat economics paper he had written in college (I think at Harvard) that showed that sensible tax increases (like the Clinton years) have no impact on business creation. He used EINs issued, among other metrics.
- steveplace 18y agoA comment on your first point: It does not get spent on American businesses. I wish it did, but a large share (~40%) goes to entitlement programs (Medicare, SS). Then you've also got defense spending, which benefits some companies, and also you've got other things like debt interest, homeland security, etc. http://www.wallstats.com/deathandtaxes/ http://www.wallstats.com/deathandtaxes/ is a pretty good visualization.
- khafra 18y agoNot to belabor the point unnecessarily, but Social Security checks are generally injected immediately back into the economy as well, and Medicare-while it does help prop up the least fiscally efficient medical system in the world--does, at least, get spent in the US. Defense and Homeland Security spending benefit some companies at the expense of others; that's an effect with debatable benefit. The debt interest supports the GP's other point, that the money would be taxed or inflated away eventually, anyway.
- mattmaroon 18y agoThat's not accurate either. Those entitlement checks get sent out regardless of whether we raise or lower taxes, and come from FICA taxes. They have nothing to do with higher income taxes. They're a sunk cost. Raising income tax (and spending the newly raised money) would just lower the % spent on entitlements, since it wouldn't raise the dollar amount 1 cent. If there is any FICA surplus, it's saved to help pay for the huge amount of retirees we'll have in 10 years.