3 ms·
I've come to think that whatever eventually replaces USB should add some separation between power and data. Let's call it MSB (Multiversal Serial Bus). Maybe so
by tzs 4y ago
I've come to think that whatever eventually replaces USB should add some separation between power and data. Let's call it MSB (Multiversal Serial Bus). Maybe something like this.
MSB would define 2 connectors: a data connector and a power connector.
MSB would also specify that if you have both data and power connectors they should be physically laid out in data/power pairs and would define the spacing/positioning (e.g., the power connector should be parallel to the data connector 2 mm apart with the power connector above the data connector).
The idea behind the layout specification is that for applications that need both the power and data connectors you could make cables that include both, with the housing at the ends holding the two connectors fixed so they can treated as a unit when it comes to plugging into things.
The power port would include data line, but they are just used for power negotiation.
The data port would include power, but just a fixed voltage and max current, comparable to pre-high power USB, so for low power peripherals you would just need to use a data port. I.e., for low power peripherals it is pretty much just like USB.
- sacrosancty 4y agoThat's pretty much USB3-A isn't it? High speed data is separate from power and low speed data. You can have connectors with just one or the other. Anyway, the world will be worse place with just incremental incompatible tweaks to the so-called "universal" connectors so that they're never universal because of churn. Hopefully USB-C is the end of the line forever, whatever its flaws might be.
- i_am_jl 4y agoWhy not offload this to the device? Why doesn't my device today have an option that allows me to set the USB port to "power only"?
- mr_mitm 4y agoMy Android does that. And at least with thunderbolt I can enable thunderbolt security on my laptop, which essentially does that.
- Tommstein 4y agoBecause you don't have an Android? I don't remember the last one I had that didn't have that setting, if ever.
- i_am_jl 4y agoTry plugging a keyboard into your phone. That setting does not work the way you think it does.
- yencabulator 4y ago(Apart from very low level USB firmware stack attacks:) That's a purely software issue, though, and actually easier to solve on phones (with built-in display+input) than on PCs (how to trust a keyboard/mouse without having keyboard/mouse to input approval with?). https://usbguard.github.io/ https://usbguard.github.io/
- i_am_jl 4y ago>That's a purely software issue, though, I know, that's why I'm so annoyed! And Android is already half-way there; they've already acknowledged that I should be able to control how my phone interacts over USB with a PC, now all that's left is a proactive control that sets the mode for the USB port globally instead of asking my preference in reaction to a device being connected. >and actually easier to solve on phones (with built-in display+input) than on PCs (how to trust a keyboard/mouse without having keyboard/mouse to input approval with?). I feel like PCs are less of an issue; I'm not out with my PC at a coffee shop or bus station when suddenly I'm tempted to use the publicly available USB keyboard. At least to me phones and tablets seem like the problematic devices here since charging them (with a wire at least) necessitates connecting them via USB.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]