4 ms·
Dad had FAR more buyIng power on his $4-6000 per year salary than we do today. ...people simply went out and ate out far less and just lived on less. These tw
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
Dad had FAR more buyIng power on his $4-6000 per year salary than we do today.
...people simply went out and ate out far less and just lived on less.
These two statements contradict each other.
- dredmorbius 15y agoNot from a "keeping up with the Joneses" basis. Or from a "you spent less because you had to spend less" basis. The first assumes that a large amount of spending is done in order to signal or gain social advantage. Signaling would be ostentatious consumption to express a higher social status. Gaining would be, say, buying a house in a good school district in order to gain social advantage for your children. A perverse logic of a constrained-resource economy may be that such socially-driven spending may increase, not decrease. The second assumes that one didn't need to go out to eat, because one spousal partner (OK, the wife) stayed home and incorporated the roles of cooking, cleaning, childcare, etc., which are now frequently treated as external expenses. Likewise shorter commutes with cheaper gasoline. There is no contradiction.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoNot from a "keeping up with the Joneses" basis. On a "keeping up with the joneses" basis, we are exactly as rich now as we always were. In 1950, 1960, and today, there were 50% of people above the median. If your dad had more "keeping up with the joneses" buying power, it's only because someone else's dad had less. Incidentally, when you compare people to their parents, you find that income went up vastly more than you think. It's only when you compare people today (Americans and immigrants) to the parents of Americans that incomes appear to have stagnated. http://crazybear.posterous.com/did-immigrants-and-simpsons-paradox-cause-the http://crazybear.posterous.com/did-immigrants-and-simpsons-p...
- dredmorbius 15y agoIf we're talking aspirational spending, no, we're not. It's not the median, but the marginal cost to advance to the next level. In 1947, to go from the top of the first quintile by income to bottom of the top 5%, required increasing your income 501%. In 2001, the differential was 685%. Wealth disparities tend to exceed income (your marginal savings and/or investment growth increases with marginal income). http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/DistributionofIncome.html http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/DistributionofIncome.html A similar relationship is shown in this plot: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:US_Income_Inequality_1967-2003_relative_to_median_(log_scale).svg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:US_Income_Inequality_1967-... Another relationship is to consider ranking determined by mean (not median) income. If half the wealth and spending power is in the top 5% rather than top 20% of households, then the relative wealth of the lower 95% has decreased -- they're not keeping up with the Jonses.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoIt's not the median, but the marginal cost to advance to the next level. Again, the marginal cost to advance to the "next level" can only increase if more people are able to achieve it. "Keeping up with the joneses" is a zero sum game. Also, if we are talking about "keeping up with the joneses", then it's irrelevant to focus on income or wealth. We should focus on consumption - interestingly, consumption inequalities are lower than both income and wealth inequalities.
- yaix 15y agoNo they don't. Only because a person has more disposible income does not mean they /have/ to consume more. The poster has actually a point. In a "consumerist" culture however, "instant satisfaction" is much more important and constantly promoted as important.
- rsheridan6 15y agoSince mom didn't work, she had time to stay home and cook without wearing herself ragged, so eating out wasn't so popular. Obesity was also the exception then rather than the norm. Coincidence?
- rmc 15y agoSince mom didn't work, she had time to stay home and cook Mothers working? Why that would be child abuse. A mother should stay in the home and look after her children. Also, we can't have them taking jobs away from men!
- rsheridan6 15y agoIs there a specific disagreement with anything I said anywhere behind that snark?
- rmc 15y agoNot really. More just annoyance when people have rosy eyed view of how glorius the past was where mum stayed at home. However that was legally and socially enforced, so it wasn't so good IMO.