2 ms·
The alternative to this is 3 (or whatever number) strikes type laws where successive crimes, even small ones, are punished more severely.
by lotsofpulp 4y ago
The alternative to this is 3 (or whatever number) strikes type laws where successive crimes, even small ones, are punished more severely.
- giantg2 4y agoThat could be one option, but still has room for abuse. Maybe a homeless person shoplifts some candy three time. That's a felony in many states. Maybe they have a mental condition that causes them to shoplift, or maybe they were hungry. Now it's up to someone's opinion, who is likely overburdened, to decide which one it is. Either way, it's likely to result in custody, but one of those ways might involve mandated medication and a lifelong (mis)diagnosis. At least in this case it would be going through the court, and under the current laws should require some input on the part of the defendant to seek an insanity plea.
- dionidium 4y agoWe're quite literally to the point where something like a 20-strike law, which sounds like parody, would actually be quite useful.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 4y agoSo you want to spend 60k/yr on prison times the homeless population of America? Because that’s what your comment suggests and there’s a litany of better options.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoI have yet to see a better option in action. It would be nice to have sufficient supply of quality mental healthcare and oversight to prevent abuse of involuntary committal, but as far as I see, that is a pipe dream.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 4y agoHave we tried dragging the army Corp of engineers in to build housing? What about a national jobs guarantee? National healthcare that can’t bankrupt people? I’ve met a lot of homeless people in my life, most have no use for a counselor. They’re largely uninterested in self actualization or recovery. They want safe shelter, affordable and accessible healthcare, reliable transportation, a job they can be proud of that provides for them and their family consistently. These people are gripped by despair and acting it against society at large because society has relegated them to the fringes as useless, hopeless, and expendable. Housing, healthcare, and respect for each individual human is the minimum. Just because that won’t scale does not it can be ignored. Ignoring this is how we got here. Continue ignoring it and we’ll probably see more tech bros murdered in broad daylight. We might also see the security teams of these tech bros commit a few massacres.