2 ms·
> I don't believe this works the way you think. Within the same chat session with GPT3 you can ask it to explain addition, then ask it to do addition, and the e
by vidarh 4y ago
> I don't believe this works the way you think. Within the same chat session with GPT3 you can ask it to explain addition, then ask it to do addition, and the explanation will be perfectly accurate but the sums it does will be complete rubbish. It's not enough to remind it.
Again, I've had this exact experience with people many times as well, so again I don't think this in itself is any kind of indication of whether or not LLMs are all that different from humans in this regard. The point is not that there aren't things missing from LLMs, but that I don't find the claim that this behaviour shows how different they are to be at all convincing.
My experience is that people do not appear naturally generalise reasoning techniques very well unless - possibly - if they are trained at doing that (possibly, because I'm not convinced that even most of those of us with significantly above average intelligence generalise reasoning nearly as well as we'd like to think).
Most people seem to learn not by being taught a new technique and then "automatically applying it", but being taught a new technique and then being made to repetitively practice that technique by being prompted step by step until they've learnt to apply it separate from the process of following the steps, and tend to perform really poorly and make lots of mistakes when doing it by instruction.
> You can't remind them they learned this or that when learning to do sums and to use it again in this context, as you would with a human, at the moment that flat out doesn't work.
I don't know what you're trying to say here. Mentioning a technique to ChatGPT and telling it to go through it step by step is not flawless but it often does work. E.g. I just tested by asking GPT4 for a multiplication method and then asked it to use it on two numbers I provided and show its working, and it did just fine. At the same time, doing this with humans often requires a disturbingly high level of step by step prompting (having a child, I've been through a torturous amount of this). I won't suggest ChatGPT is as good as following instructions as people, yet, but most people are also really awfully horrible at following instructions.
- simonh 4y ago>Again, I've had this exact experience with people many times as well There's a difference between some people sometimes needing to be reminded to do something, and them flat out not being able to do it due to fundamental cognitive limitations. >"E.g. I just tested by asking GPT4 for a multiplication method and then asked it to use it on two numbers I provided and show its working, and it did just fine." That's because GPT4 has been custom tuned and trained on that specific task as well, along with many others. It's that training, why it was necessary and how it works that the paper referred to previously was about. This is literally the subject under discussion. You're using the fact the system was custom trained to do that specific task as is therefore good at it, along with other basic mathematical tasks, as evidence that it has a general ability that doesn't need to be custom trained. This is what I'm talking about and as these models get better specific problem domain training two things will happen. One is that they will become dramatically more powerful and capable tools. That's great. The other is that more and more people will come to fundamentally misunderstand how they function and what they do, because they will see that they produce similar results to humans in many ways. They will infer from that they work cognitively in the same way as humans, and will reason about their abilities on that basis and will make errors as a result, because they're not aware of the highly specialist training the systems had to go through precisely because there are very important and impactful ways in which they don't cognitively function like humans. This matters, particularly when non specialists like politicians are making decisions about how this technology should be regulated and governed.
- vidarh 4y ago> There's a difference between some people sometimes needing to be reminded to do something, and them flat out not being able to do it due to fundamental cognitive limitations. GPT4 isn't "flat out not able to do it" when reminded. My point was that I have had the same experience of having to prompt step by step and go "why did you do that? Follow the steps" with both fully functional, normally intelligent people and with GPT4 for similarly complex tasks, and given the improvement between 3.5 and 4 there's little reason to assume this won't keep improving for at least some time more. > That's because GPT4 has been custom tuned and trained on that specific task as well, along with many others. It's that training, why it was necessary and how it works that the paper referred to previously was about. So it can do it when trained, just like people, in other words. > They will infer from that they work cognitively in the same way as humans And that would be bad. But so is automatically assuming that there's any fundamental difference between how they work and how human reasoning work given that we simply do not know how human reasoning work, and given that LLMs in increasing number of areas show similar behaviour (failure to e.g. fall back on learned rules) when their reasoning breaks down as untrained people. Again, I'm not saying they're reasoning like people, but I'm saying that we know very little about what the qualitative differences are outside of the few glaringly obvious aspects (e.g. lack of lasting memory and lack of ongoing reinforcement during operation), and we don't know how necessary those will be (we do know that humans can "function" for some values of function without the ability to form new lasting memories, but obviously it provides significant functional impairment).
- simonh 4y ago> Again, I'm not saying they're reasoning like people Cool, that’s really the only point I’m making. On the one hand it’s certainly true we can overcome a lot of the limitations imposed by that basic token sequence prediction paradigm, but they are just workarounds rather than general solutions and therefore are limited in interesting ways. Obviously I don't know for sure how things will pan out, but I suspect we will soon encounter scaling limitations in the current approach. Not necessarily scaling limitations fundamental to the architecture as such, but limitations in our ability to develop sufficiently well developed training texts and strategies across so many problem domains. That may be several model generations away though.