2 ms·
Everything is "it depends". For every truism from Sun Tzu, there is a data point providing a counter argument. For the truism you are presenting, to whit: >
by lelanthran 4y ago
Everything is "it depends".
For every truism from Sun Tzu, there is a data point providing a counter argument.
For the truism you are presenting, to whit:
> The carnage of war, the worse it is the more it avoids even more war. If you win without battle then others will keep starting more battles because why not? But if you defear your enemy well and in the most horrific way then it becomes unthinkable to willingly start a battle or war with you.
The counterpoint is WW2, which was a result of how horrifically Germany was defeated in WW1.
So, no, it's not always true.
- _8j50 4y ago> how horrifically Germany was defeated in WW1. I'd argue not horrifically enough. I mean their defeat eas decisive and the toll on their morale was huge but their idea of greatness through war and appettite for war in general was obviously not resolved. Hiroshima and Nagasaki on the other hand swiftly resolved Japan's appetite for violence (not that I neccesarily agree). WW1 and Germany to me are good examples of how not to finish a war. I ask why Germany was allowed to continue to be a free state? Why not divide up Germany as a foreign territory or colony between victors? Why not make sure no military or hostile government ever rises up again like the US did with Japan (still has no offensive military!). If you want to see how effective what I am saying is, look at Genghis Khan. Any sign of resistance and your entire town or village was burned and erased out if existance. Many of his enemies surrender long before he ever arrives there. You cannot take half-measures with an aggressor. Victory can't be partial for it to last. If you merely wound your enemy he will regain strength and come back at you many times stronger or at least keep coming back until you surrender (Taliban). You must do what it takes to kill off your enemy fully even after victory.
- denton-scratch 4y agoGermany wasn't defeated in WW1 on the Eastern Front, I think; and I believe that Hitler's attack on Europe in WW2 was incidental to his true goal, which was to occupy Poland and Ukraine. He didn't want to start a punch-up with the British Empire, and he initially thought Britain and Germany could be buddies.