3 ms·
A search engine that forces people to "sign-in". There is a problem here and that is how to stop "users" from spamming the project with marketing garbage. If
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y ago
A search engine that forces people to "sign-in".
There is a problem here and that is how to stop "users" from spamming the project with marketing garbage. If the "solution" is to collect more personal data from users, e.g., e-mail addresses, mobile phone numbers, multi-factor authentication, etc., as a prerequisite to even submitting a search query, then that is not a solution. It is an additional problem.
Assuming the project is collecting personal data from users, e.g., peoples' search queries, where is the agreement that governs what the project is allowed to do with that data. If there is no agreement, then presumably the project can do whatever it wants.
We can guess what happens next. Search engine as userdata-gathering exercise and commercial entity. Been there done that.
- BeetleB 4y agoCurious: Did you try it out before typing this up?
- collaborative 4y agoI recently came up with aisearch.vip (similar concept) and frankly, there is no way around this A future is coming where everything that isn't behind a login wall will be widely abused. ToS mean nothing in the era of AI. Quality searches will stop being free and cost actual money because the alternative is to drown the users in ads and, yes, monetize their data If you can't learn to establish trust with non-AI entities then..
- rchaud 4y agoThe reality is that your data privacy gets abused even when you do pay.
- collaborative 4y agoAre you saying that you would abuse users' data if given the chance?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- marginalia_nu 4y ago> A search engine that forces people to "sign-in". I honestly think this may be what the future of search looks like. The only reason Google doesn't force you to sign in is they already know who you are. Operating a truly public and anonymous search engine is a serious uphill battle with the background noise of bot traffic. Looking at what Cloudflare turns down, I'm currently on the receiving end of about 1.5 million fake queries per day from a botnet[1]. It's more traffic than you typically get from lingering on the HN front page for a day or so, and these aren't just favicon.ico requests, but actual search queries. Websites submitted to HN regularly keel over from this amount of traffic. In any other business this would be a low grade DDoS attack. In search we call it Tuesday. Now I run my own hardware and the worst that happens is my site becomes slow or drops out. If I was cloud backed, I'd be destitute from paying the bills. [1] https://www.marginalia.nu/junk/cloudflare.webp https://www.marginalia.nu/junk/cloudflare.webp